Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Renew Deal

(84,460 posts)
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 09:26 PM Aug 31

History indicates the White House will lie about the presidentis health. Last president to die of natural causes: FDR

There has been a lot said in the last year about Biden's and Trump's health, but history indicates that the White House is likely to lie about the presidents health while in office.

When President Franklin D. Roosevelt turned 62 on Jan. 30, 1944, the New York Times reported that Vice Admiral Ross T. McIntire, the president’s personal physician, believed “the chief executive was in better health then at any time since he entered the White House.” In an April 4 update, the doctor told reporters “the greatest criticism we can have is the fact we haven’t been able to provide him with enough exercise and sunshine.”

And several weeks before the 1944 election, with FDR running for a fourth term, McIntire doubled down, stating, “The president’s health is perfectly O.K. There are absolutely no organic difficulties at all.”

In fact, nothing could have been further from the truth.

By 1944, FDR’s health was deteriorating rapidly. At the end of March, a cardiologist diagnosed congestive heart failure, a condition that had been aggravated by McIntire’s disregard of recurring symptoms. The president’s work schedule was curtailed, he was treated with digitalis — and was told to smoke no more than 10 cigarettes a day.

Roosevelt was also suffering from acute hypertension. The day of McIntire’s optimistic April 4 statement, his blood pressure was 226/118. And on August 12, in Bremerton, Oregon, he suffered a mild heart attack while delivering a speech.

https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/4380603-in-1944-fdr-was-reported-to-be-in-excellent-health/


Few had known of the severity of the president’s health problems.

https://www.fdrlibrary.org/document-april


So if Trump is suddenly gone one day, it shouldn't be a surprise. All the signs of health problems are plainly visible, and the WH will continue to lie about it.

Here are the ages of presidents that died of natural causes while in office. All are much younger than Trump:
Harrison: 68
Taylor: 65
Harding: 57
FDR: 63

One odd fact that I found about FDR while looking into this. On his last day...

He ate a light breakfast around 9:30 in preparation for a barbecue planned for that afternoon; he also planned a light lunch, then to go see some of the children at Warm Springs rehearse for a minstrel show that evening.

https://blog.dlg.galileo.usg.edu/?p=2022


8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
History indicates the White House will lie about the presidentis health. Last president to die of natural causes: FDR (Original Post) Renew Deal Aug 31 OP
"and was told to smoke no more than 10 cigarettes a day" tanyev Aug 31 #1
Well, odins folly Aug 31 #3
Granted. But in FDR's case, we were in the middle of a world war. paleotn Aug 31 #2
It does Renew Deal Aug 31 #4
Harrison was newly elected and died of a combination of acute food poisoning and flu. LeftInTX Aug 31 #5
People were smarter then dsc Aug 31 #6
Kennedy was worse than they said to Tree Lady Aug 31 #7
They probably covered up many presidents' health problems. It's just that they didn't die. LeftInTX Sep 1 #8

tanyev

(47,751 posts)
1. "and was told to smoke no more than 10 cigarettes a day"
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 09:38 PM
Aug 31

Whew, it was a different time alright.
🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬 🚬

paleotn

(20,870 posts)
2. Granted. But in FDR's case, we were in the middle of a world war.
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 09:53 PM
Aug 31

That changes the equation.

Renew Deal

(84,460 posts)
4. It does
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 10:04 PM
Aug 31

One of the articles about it says that everything about him was tightly controlled except his 1944 campaign.

LeftInTX

(33,736 posts)
5. Harrison was newly elected and died of a combination of acute food poisoning and flu.
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 10:08 PM
Aug 31

He was healthy when he got to town, but the WH water was also contaminated with sewage. He died after a month in office.

Taylor died of "cholera". Probably because of the sewage situation. He was in office for a year. Other WH staff also were sick.
(There were a few other presidents who suffered from food born, sewage born, water born illnesses but survived)

Harding most likely died of a heart attack. He had sharp stomach pains and was given digitalis. He also had pneumonia at the time (although maybe it was congestive heart failure???) He died 2 days later. His wife did not consent to an autopsy. His official death was listed as cerebral hemorrhage, because he "convulsed" when he died.

dsc

(53,121 posts)
6. People were smarter then
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 10:14 PM
Aug 31

The fact is Roosevelt was the best choice then and Biden was the best in 2024. Our ageism and our ableism lead us to make bad choices in 2024. What should matter is how the job was being done, and frankly Biden did a better job than literally anyone could have expected with the narrowest Congressional majorities in the lifetimes of many voters. I don't blame Harris who stepped up when the party bosses stabbed Biden in the back after the press printed bullshit article after bullshit article to force their hands but it was a massive blunder by both the people and our party to force the most effective President since Johnson off the ticket. BTW we did the same to Johnson and look how that turned out.

Tree Lady

(12,692 posts)
7. Kennedy was worse than they said to
Sun Aug 31, 2025, 10:45 PM
Aug 31

I think both sides want to project a strong president so foreign powers don't jump on a weakness or just the other party.

But that said Trumps people would let him die and keep that a secret as long as they could knowing what his cult might do.

And the rest of us dancing in the streets singing ding, dong the witch is dead!

LeftInTX

(33,736 posts)
8. They probably covered up many presidents' health problems. It's just that they didn't die.
Mon Sep 1, 2025, 12:37 AM
Sep 1

I know Wilson was pretty much incapacitated for quite awhile.

The first two that died in office were due to poor sewage at the WH. I wouldn't consider them to have "ongoing health issues".

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»History indicates the Whi...