Mike Johnson: "I cannot for the life of me understand how the Democrats think this is some kind of winning political message. Yield man! Let the troops come into your city and show how crime can be reduced."

— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2025-09-09T14:40:46.870Z

First, Johnson made it sound as if there’s a national crime wave sweeping the nation, forcing Americans to cower in fear behind closed doors. That’s ridiculous, as the evidence shows.

Second, the crime rate in Louisiana isn’t exactly worth bragging about, compared to national averages, and I haven’t yet seen Johnson demand the deployment of federal troops to patrol the streets of Shreveport.

Third, the idea that troop deployments necessarily eliminate crime has already been discredited, and although it might offer some temporary improvements, unless the House speaker expects to see permanent troop deployments to American municipalities from coast to coast, this isn’t a serious approach to crime reduction.

Fourth, the president has already militarized Washington, D.C., and most of the residents of the nation’s capital overwhelmingly oppose the deployments. This probably hasn’t gone unnoticed among local officials in other areas.

Fifth, it remains jarring to see far-right Republicans talk about the federal mobilization of troops on domestic soil after years of listening to other far-right Republicans describe exactly this scenario as tyrannical. Now, evidently, Johnson sees it as “common sense” — a position he seems likely to abandon the next time there’s a Democratic president.

Sixth, this isn’t an all-or-nothing situation in which the administration offers Guard troops or nothing: Plenty of Democratic officials in cities nationwide would welcome increased federal support to make local streets safer, even as they resist police state–style deployments.

Finally, even if we put all of this aside, the House speaker suggested the Democratic position is a political loser for the party. Indeed, the GOP leader explicitly said he couldn’t understand “how the Democrats think this is some sort of winning political message.”