General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe person who shot Charlie Kirk was clearly not an amateur
That was a very precise shot from a long distance.

ZDU
(754 posts)... and book repositories and will you LOOK at the travel path of the projectile!?!?! It's almost unbelievable, isn't it?
malaise
(288,844 posts)That is all
Bernardo de La Paz
(58,199 posts)malaise
(288,844 posts)That he was dead - they were quoting someone linked to the military
Maru Kitteh
(30,611 posts)But AF doesnt yet know.
Maru Kitteh
(30,611 posts)Per AF.
bdamomma
(69,015 posts)media will have the details.
malaise
(288,844 posts)AllyCat
(18,197 posts)He is not a good person, but no one deserves this.
IbogaProject
(4,931 posts)So better him than a school kid or teacher.
AllyCat
(18,197 posts)FoxNewsSucks
(11,314 posts)regnaD kciN
(27,252 posts)SunSeeker
(56,610 posts)As the saying goes, "live by the gun, die by the gun."
prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)would at least have a barbaric internal logic
SunSeeker
(56,610 posts)The whole point of stochastic terrorism is to get someone to do the murdering for you so you don't have to get your hands dirty (i.e. face liability for the murder).
All you have to do is tell your cult followers that liberals are responsible for murder and you leave it up to the cultists to do your dirty work, like Trump does here:
https://upload.democraticunderground.com/100220627245
prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)now if he had personally actually killed his political enemies, we'll I'd still want his arrested and tried.
Orrex
(65,991 posts)I'll shed no tears over a POS dying for the gun zealotry for which he advocated so tirelessly.
prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)And if not, doesn't unsolicitedly announcing that you won't be doing so seem a bit gratuitous.
Orrex
(65,991 posts)You sure told me.
prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)RPM
(5,636 posts)I'm more bothered by the concurrent school shooting.
sigh
Response to AllyCat (Reply #27)
Skittles This message was self-deleted by its author.
UpInArms
(53,377 posts)Anymore than I celebrated his life
All people bring joy,
Some when they enter
And some
When they leave
meadowlander
(4,967 posts)It's not a question of what he deserves or not. But also how you choose to live your life and the things that you choose to put out into the universe can come back on you. I think there's a lot of Republicans running around now thinking that there will never be any consequences for the things they say and do and, without sanctioning shooting political rivals, I'm comfortable with saying that this was a not unforeseeable consequence of having a high public profile and whipping up maniacs into a frenzy.
ancianita
(41,734 posts)Okay.
Bread and Circuses
(1,107 posts)Rebl2
(16,936 posts)first thought, but doubt it.
tritsofme
(19,505 posts)sarisataka
(21,984 posts)to just graze him.
It shows why the other conspiracy theories are ridiculous.
popsdenver
(428 posts)Trained Snipers rarely, if ever, go for a head shot.........
Trump/Republicans will use this non-stop, to deflect the media from the constant barrage of Epstein stuff........
Orrex
(65,991 posts)
littlemissmartypants
(29,597 posts)Orrex
(65,991 posts)Rocknation
(44,927 posts)which would allow him to sic his Gestapo on anyone who has publicly opposed him
Rocknation
Fla_Democrat
(2,618 posts)


prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)haele
(14,568 posts)Was he starting to stray from the talking points too much? Did he weasel his smarmy punk way into learning about a "future event" he couldn't be trusted to keep quiet about before it happened?
BeyondGeography
(40,646 posts)fwiw. That has been known to anger people.
markodochartaigh
(3,893 posts)have made it their policy for decades to stir up their vicious base. When you have so many loose cannons on your own ship it is hardly surprising when one of them blows a hole in your own ship.
Shipwack
(2,841 posts)Kirk had banned the most extreme groups from his rallies and conventions.
Everything is speculation, though. It could have been his haircut for all we know
Strelnikov_
(8,031 posts)enough to use as a diversion.
With Epstein looming, could not wait around for a Grynszpa.
Justice Brandeis
(261 posts)it seems unlikely that the shooter is trans, and I sure hope he/she/they isn't.
quakerboy
(14,532 posts)My instinct is regardless of who actually shot him, there will ve a full court press to hang a trans person. Or immigrant. I guess they could go with a gay person, but I think they want to go after trans folk first.
PJMcK
(24,202 posts). is a Democrat.
mainer
(12,424 posts)Did they get the right guy?
They did not
sarisataka
(21,984 posts)200 yards is not terribly difficult for an experienced person, so not an amateur probably.
For a skilled person the neck is a very good target, you are nearly guaranteed to cause a critical, if not fatal injury. Having seen the more graphic video, he had just sat back and was holding his body straight. The perfect time/posture for someone trying to kill him.
SSJVegeta
(1,433 posts)Military is usually somewhat comfortable with 300 yard targets
Katcat
(490 posts)I saw an elderly man in his 60s or early 70s shoot through the hole in a beer can and come out the bottom from a good distance away. The elderly man was my dad and he bragged her could do it and he did. Oh and he used a 22 rifle.
SSJVegeta
(1,433 posts)
markodochartaigh
(3,893 posts)it seems like they at least have some more information on the shooter. Hopefully they catch them quick. And hopefully Kirk doesn't become a martyr.
Bev54
(12,846 posts)markodochartaigh
(3,893 posts)are shot like in Minnesota and then it is just allowed to blow over.
Bev54
(12,846 posts)Total gaslighting sanctimonious bullshit.
AverageOldGuy
(2,934 posts)My arsenal includes:
-- .243 cal Remington 700 with a no-name scope, zeroed at 150 yards. I use it to shoot graoundhogs, mainly; most of them between 75 and 250 yards. In 15 years I have killed 6-8 a year and have never missed.
-- .308 Weatherby Mark V Deluxe with a Leupold Mark5 scope. Zeroed at 200 yards. At 300 yards the round drops 6-7 inches, at 400 yards between 19-21 inches. With about 20 minutes of coaching and firing, my 14-yr-old grandson was putting three-round groups into the bullseye at 300 yards.
-- My favorite is a Daisy Red Ryder Deluxe BB rifle. Never shot my eye out.
Straw Man
(6,900 posts)The military trains at 300 yards with iron sights. For a skilled shooter with a scoped rifle, 200 yards is a walk in the park.
sarisataka
(21,984 posts)And sometimes we went out farther. Yess, 200 is no big deal if you train for it
NickB79
(20,100 posts)With a cheap $75 laser rangefinder to get the drop right, I could probably make a headshot with my CZ 457 .22LR bolt action rifle. I know I can hit Coke cans in the field behind my house out to 150 yd if the wind isn't bad.
A center-fire rifle and a 14-16x scope with a good rest is nothing at 200 yd.
liberalgunwilltravel
(909 posts)sadly, marksmanship in Utah is more proficient than in Pennsylvania.
hamsterjill
(16,512 posts)Shooting an animal is an entirely different thing than shooting another human being with the intent to kill. Especially in a crowd.
Whoever this person is, they had confidence in their ability.
prodigitalson
(3,148 posts)malaise
(288,844 posts)maxsolomon
(37,337 posts)Missed his head by an inch from 140 yards.
Fuck Thomas Crooks. He assured MFer's victory.
usonian
(20,290 posts)1. A wounded Trump won. A dead Trump wouldn't have.
2. He gone. Dead men tell no lies.
How? Why? Don't ask.
Orrex
(65,991 posts)mountain grammy
(28,182 posts)littlemissmartypants
(29,597 posts)LeftInTX
(33,687 posts)hamsterjill
(16,512 posts)The day after Putin went after Poland.
Maybe this is a message to Trump that no one is safe???
Just thinking out loud as we obviously dont have details of the motive, etc.
quakerboy
(14,532 posts)mainer
(12,424 posts)Maybe Charlie was a necessary sacrifice to kick off Trump's purge of his enemies.
And MAGA is all over X calling Democrats the party of violence.
Is this the beginning of a new reign of terror?
orangecrush
(26,641 posts)Not really.
Vinca
(52,655 posts)rubbersole
(10,467 posts)Reprisals are coming.
hadEnuf
(3,381 posts)Hate mongers like her need to be shut down. They are a large part of the cause of all of this mess we are in with Trumpedo.
COL Mustard
(7,571 posts)Brings Hell here.
Nigrum Cattus
(993 posts)Lets see if one is declared to take away civil liberties
orangecrush
(26,641 posts)
calimary
(87,752 posts)That certainly is the quote of the season.
Scrivener7
(57,083 posts)Raster
(21,008 posts)Or are they not black and brown enough?
markodochartaigh
(3,893 posts)and the US attacked Afghanistan, which offered to turn Bin Laden over, and Iraq. Hardly surprising if a shooting in Utah provokes an invasion of Chicago.
Arazi
(8,350 posts)mnhtnbb
(32,810 posts)going on her show today.
The female very experienced and well respected head of the Salt Lake City FBI office was summarily dismissed 3 weeks ago. Retired FBI agent discussion suggesting that the purging that has been going on of the leadership of the FBI will not help the search for the shooter.
Discussing this 200 yard shot is not difficult for a professional. There was also discussion of this murder in context of political attacks and shootings over the last year or so.
usonian
(20,290 posts)More likely?
Doodley
(11,310 posts)dalton99a
(90,109 posts)Red Mountain
(2,182 posts)Was the shooter seen? I realize the person was not caught.
mnhtnbb
(32,810 posts)would have decent opportunity to easily leave the area. There was not much, if any, security at that distance from the tent where Kirk was speaking.
radical noodle
(10,394 posts)but I think they have an idea now what building the shot came from. If so, that's where the distance came from.
markodochartaigh
(3,893 posts)it seems that there is a building 200 yards away that may have been used.
scipan
(2,940 posts)LT Barclay
(3,102 posts)But on a more serious note, since I dont listen to him, was he pushing for release of the Epstein files? If so he wont be the last.
VMA131Marine
(5,080 posts)clearly has a lot of experience. There are a lot of people in the country who could have pulled that off. The bigger question is whether or not the shooter acted on his own initiative. At some point the issue will be raised whether this was a false flag: kill one of your own to incite others on your side to violence.
edbermac
(16,309 posts)Kirk was at the red spot, shooter was on a roof 200 yards away from the Losee Center.
Do you know how many transgender Americans have been mass shooters over the last 10 years? an audience members asked. Kirk responded: Too many.
The questioner followed up: Do you know how many mass shooters there have been in America over the last 10 years?
Counting or not counting gang violence? Kirk asked.
Then a single shot rang out.
How ironic.
https://apnews.com/article/charlie-kirk-conservative-activist-shot-546165a8151104e0938a5e085be1e8bd
RPM
(5,636 posts)it's oddly unnerving architecture
Response to Quiet Em (Original post)
Iggo This message was self-deleted by its author.
colorado_ufo
(6,137 posts)My husband works at the gun department of a sporting goods store and is a hunter. Although he is well into his senior years, he practices at 200 yards at the local shooting range and has no trouble hitting the target center, and he is definitely an amateur. This person may or may not be a professional, but he/she was definitely an experienced shooter.
Sneederbunk
(16,668 posts)jmowreader
(52,658 posts)Probably 85 percent of western hunters could have made that shot.
Warpy
(113,895 posts)Modern gear makes maiming and killing too easy.
I'll be surprised if the weapon was any sort of a hunting gun, but I suppose that's possible, too.
chowmama
(880 posts)Please, please, let it be a Swiftie.
But it was probably a RW nut job for reasons we will find out later. Even if most of them opt for the 'spray and sweep' guns that require little training and less skill. This was a sniper.
I shouldn't be celebrating. But anybody who delegates all females to second-class, subservient, "Dumb, docile and decorative" status isn't worth space, oxygen, or my personal time. The world is a better place this afternoon than it was this morning. I won't miss him.
OverBurn
(1,275 posts)chowmama
(880 posts)He told her she was going to have to submit to her husband from now on; she wasn't in charge now.
WestMichRad
(2,589 posts)Statistics says theyre not all right wingers.
I do not condone this violent act in any way, even though Kirk was an extremist Nazi. Expect that some extremist zealot will try to even the score on some left-leaning politician.
Kaleva
(39,876 posts)twodogsbarking
(15,624 posts)When the President preaches violence on a daily basis we shouldn't be surprised.
BidenRocks
(2,166 posts)Even without sighting in, 9/10 black.
The shooter was supposed to graze him.
Submariner
(13,108 posts)
AmandaRuth
(3,190 posts)what if the shooter was a women? (look, i'm not proud of this thought, but i can't get rid of it)
Deep State Witch
(12,182 posts)This isn't even like the Butler shooter, who was shooting from 50 yards away. This was a professional. My guess is that it was some kind of accelerationist who wanted to bring about the civil war.
Crowman2009
(3,252 posts)...that he would live long enough to see his movement turn to shit, get ruined financially, his trad wife divorce him, and his children disown him.