General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIt is peculiar that the shooter escaped.
Usually, they shoot themselves or get caught quickly. This person shot at Kirk from hundreds of yards away and then escaped. This strongly suggests training and a premeditated act. This was carried out like a covert operation.

FarPoint
(14,196 posts)This may not be the last one for this gunman....
brush
(61,033 posts)Last edited Wed Sep 10, 2025, 10:37 PM - Edit history (1)
green light and getaway assistance.
They'll use him/her again. Seems there was much dislike among magats towards Kirk. Is it because he ran against trump from the right?
;
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)One perfect shot from a long distance.
Clean get away with no leads.
So far shooter has made no mistakes.
malaise
(288,842 posts)and rubbish about two different persons detained and released
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)Or was some of the confusion part of his plan?
malaise
(288,842 posts)or both?
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)bdamomma
(69,013 posts)I wouldn't put this past for this regime to do. Kirk the sacrificial lamb??? or am I just paranoid. Too change the narrative from Epstein to Kirk ( a worthless POS).
Prairie Gates
(6,206 posts)Everyone sees a guy in handcuffs and relaxes. Meanwhile Trigger sidles out of UVU and Provo and may be halfway to Reno by now.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)While events are fresh in their minds and before they disappear.
It is critical to get witness statements right away.
And other evidence at the crime scene.
A professional could be out of the country by now.
It was a remarkable shot and the shooter was calm, focused, and confident.
Perfect shot and clean get away.
Right now the FBI should be reviewing any and all video of the event.
Any clue could be helpful.
travelingthrulife
(3,209 posts)taxi
(2,479 posts)Many people are discussing the fatal shot from the perspective of it being too high for a torso shot and too low for a head shot, and I agree. If the shooter was looking to hit the trapezoid muscles, the muscles that go down to the shoulders from the neck, then it would be like nicking an ear. The shot would be the correct height and a near miss would place a deadly shot in the artery versus a flesh wound. But that's just my thinking.
AZJonnie
(1,397 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(33,939 posts)Although the people who would benefit from this the most would be people like the piece of shit who wants to send the military into every area where Democrats vote, what better reason than lots of shootings to do exactly that.
malaise
(288,842 posts)These are sick people
colorado_ufo
(6,137 posts)No one very close to him, a lot less chance of anyone being collateral damage. No bulletproof screens around him. I don't think anyone was behind him. No trees or other obstacles.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)To make such a perfect shot on the first try means he had scoped it out before perhaps?
colorado_ufo
(6,137 posts)He wasn't behind a lectern; he wasn't walking back and forth on the stage/platform with a portable mic; he was SEATED IN A CHAIR. Motionless. Still target.
Sitting duck.
sboatcar
(649 posts)The guy who was initially arrested and then charged with obstruction distracted the police while the shooter made his getaway
Jack Valentino
(3,193 posts)sboatcar
(649 posts)that's what struck me as odd
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)If another person is part of the crime it makes it more likely the shooter will be caught.
Once one other person knows your secret, it is no longer a secret.
The person running cover for him could flip.
But interesting plan if this is the case.
Have another person running cover for you as you escape.
sboatcar
(649 posts)But it sure seems like a professional job to me, 200 yards away, got away clean, one shot, one kill.....something reeks.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)And he stayed calm and cool as cucumber during the kill. One shot right on the money spot.
Bobstandard
(2,007 posts)Any one of a huge number of Utah hunters could have made that shot. Opening day of deer season is a secular holiday in Utah. Businesses close. Uncountable households harbor one or more super accurate, overpowered deer rifles. It neednt be a professional.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)Quite different.
It requires a different skill set and planning.
To make that shot requires training and practice.
Do you realize how many people in Utah CANNOT make that shot?
How many are capable of remaining calm, cool, professional while they kill someone?
A federal capital offense resulting in life in prison or the death penalty.
Then pulling off the escape without a hitch.
Clean quick getaway.
And did it all with producing no leads, no witnesses.
This is a man with nerves of steel. Some sort of gun training.
Remains calm, focused, skillful even under pressure.
Perhaps military training.
Some of the skill set is not necessary when killing a deer.
Johnny2X2X
(23,367 posts)I bet the number of hunters in America who have actually made a 200 yard shot on a deer or elk is exceedingly small. I'm sure there are many that will say they know someone who made a 200 yard shot, but if you actually went to the location of their shot and stepped it off it'd be 100 or 120 at the most.
And then you've got wind to deal with.
But I agree with your points about having the nerve to do it and the skill to have a pan to escape at least for now. If this person is still at large a month from now, they're almost for sure funded by a government or an ex spy of some sort who knows all the ins and outs of the FBI's tools for tracking them.
I've been to the range, I've shot targets in the woods. People aren't even practicing 200 yard shots from what I have seen.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)It is going to be hard to guess wind speed and direction in such an accurate way
especially at that distance. He had to only fire once to get the money shot.
He is either very lucky or had considerable skill, experience and equipment.
Yes of course. How many Americans have experience accurately killing human beings
at 200 years?
Yes we will know more as time goes by. If this man is at large one month from now with
no clues, we are looking at a professional. At the very least military training.
Johnny2X2X
(23,367 posts)Left in the woods with prints on it.
That kind of makes it seem amateur, but we will see, could be a decoy.
Irish_Dem
(74,298 posts)So someone with training but by no means a professional hit man.
Unless the prints belong to someone else.
Bobstandard
(2,007 posts)Cosmocat
(15,269 posts)of some of the actual tactical experts who have commented on it.
That said:
I still tend to believe that is it was someone with some military background because it was so well executed as a live kill and the shooter got out clean at this point. Hard to see how an "average" citizen pulled this off.
At the same time, if it was an "average" citizen, I have a hard time seeing how it is someone "liberal" cause this takes someone who is a gun nut and thinks in the ways needed to plan this out and again make an escape. Just almost seems to have to be a right winger to have this mindset and gun expertise.
Blues Heron
(7,484 posts)Response to drray23 (Original post)
Irish_Dem This message was self-deleted by its author.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)Just_Vote_Dem
(3,385 posts)Maybe a message to other MAGAs not to turn on the boss?
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
strongermessage
(317 posts)yellow dahlia
(2,952 posts)ancianita
(41,734 posts)what could be the motive of Homeland's layers of trumpcult help...
https://archive.ph/wchem
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
Delphinus
(12,439 posts)
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
ancianita
(41,734 posts)

SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
ancianita
(41,734 posts)SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)Going to k&r!
Danmel
(5,574 posts)A complete maga sycophant.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)I'm stuck with blackburn, so I empathize.
Danmel
(5,574 posts)PatSeg
(50,925 posts)professional assassin. Anything to do with Epstein and his clients tends to be dangerous.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)Cripes 200 yards...
With a clean get away screams pro to me.
EPSTEIN, MAXWELL, & MALARIA
ancianita
(41,734 posts)SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
ancianita
(41,734 posts)SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)


ancianita
(41,734 posts)
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)I'm stuck in the red hellhole TN, so I empathize.
ancianita
(41,734 posts)I'm just glad winter's coming, and still keeping my eye on NOAA. So far so good.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
lastlib
(26,670 posts)Lots of hunters are capable of it. Sure, there was a fair amount of skill involved, and a bit of luck to get a fatal shot when he missed the head. Trump's assassin in PA wasn't much closer, IIRC. I couldn't do it myself, I'm sure, but I know people out here who could.
sarisataka
(21,984 posts)A scope would not even be needed at that range. If a person had only iron sights and aimed for the head but did not allow for drop, they would hit the neck.
PatSeg
(50,925 posts)Maybe I've watched too many spy movies, but it is hard to believe that that was just a lucky shot by some unhinged nut.
H2O Man
(77,881 posts)I had just said this to my cousin.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
True Dough
(24,296 posts)Putin is always looking to sow political discord in the U.S. This act would further his cause.
roamer65
(37,761 posts)thomski64
(713 posts)MrWowWow
(1,101 posts)All three were sharpshooters. Would not be surprised if this shooter was one of putin's own....brought im to stir up shit by killing a very visible reichwingNut. Time will tell.
yourout
(8,571 posts)ancianita
(41,734 posts)Cha
(314,204 posts)all those things you suggested. Surreal.. but here we are.
There will be never ending conspiracy theories even after, if he should be caught.
Cha
(314,204 posts)SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)Who had motive? 🤔
Aloha 🌺

Cha
(314,204 posts)that had the link. That's one of the reasons I suggested a sniper. putting all the clues together.
TY, Sheltie! 💙
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)Aloha 🌺
kentuck
(114,591 posts)We know he was a big supporter of Trump but has he pushed for the Epstein files to be made public lately. At one time, he made a statement that he would have no more to say on it and that he would believe what came from the government.
anciano
(1,946 posts)Even though that shot was well within the capability of most experienced shooters, there are a lot of other factors that go into the equation, such as surveillance, site selection, timing, disguise, no collateral damage, and exit strategy. This was done by a professional.
Ace Rothstein
(3,358 posts)I'm assuming they dropped the weapon though as they probably would have stuck out with a bag large enough to carry it.
Xolodno
(7,148 posts)I'm guessing it was quickly dissembled and dropped into them as they are essentially commercial somewhat flat buildings. So they often put drains in the corners for the water to go somewhere.
jeffreyi
(2,433 posts)Reading up on Charlie, who was not known to me before, he was a prominent "influencer." And he apparently was not on board with blocking the epstein files contents.
SheltieLover
(73,542 posts)
Baitball Blogger
(50,867 posts)All the competent people no longer work for the FBI.
Prairie Gates
(6,206 posts)We'll have a visual on the shooter by morning, but whether it is a worthwhile visual is another matter. This is going to be a Luigi situation but maybe without the mental illness and silly mistakes.
orangecrush
(26,640 posts)tinrobot
(11,749 posts)BannonsLiver
(19,614 posts)Modern law enforcement whether its the local yokels or the feds is largely incompetent.
Tribetime
(6,828 posts)
erronis
(21,237 posts)ananda
(33,060 posts)Maybe staged so that Magats can blame Democrats
and give Trump the excuse to go nuclear on blue cities
and make sure elections are not free and fair.
Deuxcents
(23,927 posts)ananda
(33,060 posts)yes
Deuxcents
(23,927 posts)strongermessage
(317 posts)Johnny2X2X
(23,367 posts)To make that shot is hard. But to plan it such that you can get away from the scene takes a lot of know how.
Still will probably get caught, but this was not some amateur.
Prairie Gates
(6,206 posts)It takes a little while to collect the cameras and piece together the movements, but that doesn't mean it's somebody who's doing anything other than what would require moderate planning.
Puppyjive
(822 posts)So whatever he had for security, clearly was not enough.
marble falls
(68,277 posts)Bread and Circuses
(1,107 posts)bucolic_frolic
(52,305 posts)erronis
(21,237 posts)PJMcK
(24,202 posts)This could be fun if it were to get out of hand!
Vogon_Glory
(10,028 posts)There is nothing written in stone saying that an assassin is required to be a thoughtless, careless, stumblebum who failed to use the right tools for the job or littered the crime scene with clues. Kirks killer was much less inept than Ryan Routh.
Tree Lady
(12,689 posts)Where the guy shoots, makes his escape perfectly planned quickly, takes off jacket, hat, shirt, changes with backpack...then takes gun apart and throws it away in pieces no fingerprints. Goes back to motel changes wig, glasses clothes and is out in minutes and using fresh passport flies out instantly from SLC and is already overseas by now never to be seen again.
If it's true he wasn't going to give up on Epstein like the rest of maga podcasters then maga or Trumps people might have taken him out as he had a lot of influence. Joe Ryan better watch out then.
mcar
(45,291 posts)Ocelot II
(127,044 posts)just for not being white.
mcar
(45,291 posts)mnhtnbb
(32,810 posts)All white.
Emile
(37,340 posts)bluedigger
(17,317 posts)I believe the campus police force had all of six people, and Kirk's personal security detail would have been preoccupied with responding to him. I don't think six guys were ready to respond to all the resulting chaos effectively, other than some crowd control. The shooter had plenty of time to blend into the crowd and withdraw, if he kept his composure. Kirk was a soft target.
drray23
(8,407 posts)That might partially explained why he easily pulled it off.
Justice Brandeis
(261 posts)Or it was an inside job, but I'm not saying that.
At this time.
Prairie Gates
(6,206 posts)Just a blob, but obviously a person moving deliberately in a run.
spinbaby
(15,321 posts)Could just be some guy watching who panicked and ran like everyone else on the scene. What baffles me is that apparently no gun has been found. It would seem to me that either they find a gun at the scene or someone with a gun is seen running away.
Prairie Gates
(6,206 posts)Thanks for the qualifier. In another video, there were other people watching from a rooftop, so it's certainly possible that it was just a spectator.
Totally agree on the gun. I said so here: https://democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=20627370
Iggo
(49,172 posts)Thats some sniper shit.
And it might not be that peculiar for a sniper to get away.
sarisataka
(21,984 posts)for someone with a bit of experience
Kaleva
(39,876 posts)sarisataka
(21,984 posts)Is every person who shoots another always caught in less than six hours?
roamer65
(37,761 posts)Aka Russian.
Kaleva
(39,876 posts)If. I recall correctly, close to half of murder cases arent solved .
tonekat
(2,337 posts)Ned Low
(90 posts)Or Ernst Rohm, or Gregor Stasser. Wessell is more spot on. The Rohm and Stasser coincidences are still to come.
Beringia
(5,184 posts)iemanja
(56,664 posts)Last edited Wed Sep 10, 2025, 11:47 PM - Edit history (1)
and possibly someone trained as a military sniper. Not, however, a covert operation in the sense of the government being involved.
ToxMarz
(2,557 posts)Ice Ice Barbie at Homeland Security, and anyone who was competent in any of those agencies has been Doge'd. I don't know if it's peculiar or what would be expected
ReRe
(11,871 posts)Prescheduled rally. Probably a little female/male ex-military sniper. Everything planned out. Had to get in and get out in a jiffy. One shot. What the heck did he she/he do with the rifle on the way out? Hide it and come back for it later?
It HAD to be a sniper. Holy moley. I've been wondering whether this was going to start happening again,
like in the '60s: assassinations.
Feel Good Inc
(55 posts)The way he shot was pretty remarkable but he likely got away in the chaos and I doubt there was any thorough level of security so no snipes to quickly pick him off like with Trump's shooting.
I also think having an incompetent FBI helps.
Response to Feel Good Inc (Reply #107)
PeaceWave This message was self-deleted by its author.
Kaleva
(39,876 posts)Having the event outside shows a lack of concern for security. Had it been held inside, attendees could have been screened and there would have been no opportunity for a long distance shot.
Feel Good Inc
(55 posts)Not sure what the poster said since it's been deleted but on MSNBC or CNN a local reporter said there was no mention of security beyond his personal security on stage. There were no metal detectors, either.
Joinfortmill
(18,885 posts)dlk
(12,924 posts)n/t
Torchlight
(5,606 posts)The 'how' might be more surprising, but even then I'm betting myself a buck that the simplest process with the least moving parts was used.
sop
(15,921 posts)a Dallas Police Officer some time later. Using a scoped rifle, positioned inside a nearby building, most skilled marksmen could have made the shot that killed Kirk from 200 yds. then simply walked away. Unless Kirk's shooter is really stupid, left some evidence at the scene of the crime, or was seen by others who know what he did and turn him in, there's a good chance this guy won't be caught.
exboyfil
(18,275 posts)Then he would have been gone. He had to rely on buses and cabs to make his getaway.
Oswald was a crime of opportunity. Still there are things that make you wonder (such as the cluster f___ at the airport with Secret Service). The cop turning his head just as Ruby shot Oswald (like he didn''t want to see what was coming). Then you had the dead bodies afterwards (two reporters murdered - one in his home with his notes missing from a blow to the neck and the other shot in a police station by a cop).
sop
(15,921 posts)Too many questions still remain.
pwb
(12,353 posts)Killing a man to create false outrage is not beyond Putins pukes.
bdamomma
(69,013 posts)Yes I agree.
Covert operation???? Maybe so to change the narrative from Epstein to targeting another group of people to be caught by ICE, and the felon and his cohorts to plant the seed of going after Americans and to thrust us into martial law???