General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHow Do You Coach/Counsel Young Offspring in the Face of Athletic Team Non-selection?
My wonderful first grandchild failed to get selected for the 7th-grade volleyball team. I have only heard second-hand reports so far, but will be in attendance at her final pre-playoffs YMCA match tomorrow. She is one in a long line of perfectionists, and I suspect she sees this as a personal failure.
Probably goaded by slightly sadistic classmates, I ran for office my Junior year in HS. A nerdy, teacher-oriented bookworm, I lusted after the same cheerleaders as everyone else, and envied the jocks, but I was pretty well content with my niche, which included being a certified Mountaineer. Of course, this was politics, something I knew little or nothing of, and lo-and-behold, two full-blown jocks (both with 4.0, having never veered anywhere close to a challenging or AP class) took the top seats.
So I offer that up as context. It's highly amusing now. What was I thinking?
But to the matter at hand. My initial temptation to offer that up as a life-experience to my dear one seems foolish, self-serving, and irrelevant.
I'm thinking more along the lines of short and sweet. "I'm so proud of you. Trying out with 45 other girls for a team of 12 or so is not easy. In no way is your non-selection a 'failure' on your part. Of course it hurts. I cried, too. But try not to beat yourself up over this - you are a fabulous person."
ultralite001
(2,272 posts)It may be the only word thats heard 100% the rest
The Roux Comes First
(1,975 posts)Yes, that "F" word, much like the other F word and the "N" word, are like gas to a flame much of the time.
dem4decades
(13,390 posts)Just support her, ask if there's recreational volleyball and encourage her to do that and have fun.
Melon
(885 posts)Number 1. 7 th grade is not career ending.
If volleyball is import to her, she needs to improve. My daughter is at a higher level, but during the off season she will see a private coach maybe twice a month. This is just an intense 1 hour with skills homework.
She can and should play intramural or a club team during the offseason. There are beach tournaments all summer in most places that she could join a team.
She wasnt told she can never play volleyball. She was told there were 11 other girls that had a higher skill set that day. Those girls will be playing and getting better. She needs to improve despite not being on the team to make it next year.
Or
..find a different sport that is less competitive or doesnt cut at that age( track and field).
ultralite001
(2,272 posts)A star
She runs to this day w/ a family of 3 + teaching full time
Irish_Dem
(77,800 posts)It is part of growing up.
They need to learn how to handle loss in a constructive way.
She could examine why she did not get a place on the team.
Figure it out perhaps, and learn how to succeed in that sport if that is her goal.
Work harder, try new strategies to get the spot she wants.
It is not personal, it is business to some extent.
There could be many reasons she did not get selected, some of them nothing to do with her.
(Coaches' kids are get spots, etc.).
Or she could go to Plan B.
Is there another sport she will enjoy more?
I always told my daughter to have a Plan B.
If Plan A doesn't work out, go to the Plan B.
Often she found Plan B was more to her liking.
Children and teens need to learn that failures to make a sports team, or loses in competition, are parts of the process. This is true in grade school, junior high, and high school. It is part of life after leaving school and becoming part of the adult world.
In the great sport of boxing, there are those who are crushed by a lose, and never regain confidence. That is likely due to the expectations that others have burdened them with. When I trained fighters, I taught that a loss is only a loss if one does not learn from it. I actually lost a few fights, and that always resulted in my preparing for a re-match. And I always won re-matches.
SheltieLover
(74,994 posts)Right or wrong, that's what I did with my 1 soccer goalie/softball catcher & 1 softball pitcher.
I hate school sports.
But only if this sport is the love of her life.
Otherwise, help her explore other activities she might well enjoy more.
You could also find her an elite club team to play on. Again, that's what I did. School sports only get in the way of superb club teams in high school.
I know dissapointments are tough & kids are so mean, but even little losses like this are a teachable moment.
Good luck!
On edit: if she might be interested in college scholarships, volleyball is the ticket. Not sure where she lives, nut I know scouts look in Chicago first.
Srkdqltr
(9,096 posts)If you make too much its not good. Short and sweet.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)H2O Man
(78,253 posts)I know you very well might be right -- and I sure hope so.
A lot of that could depend on how the important people in her life respond. All kids at that age can be damaged if they react by saying it is important that she/he improve her skills, as if they somehow failed.
I will add that over the decades I've been familiar with school sports, I can say without risk of error that not all adults & coaches are objective when it comes to team sports. That is often another issue that parents and others have to deal with. (When I was on the school board, and watching my daughter's junior varsity basketball game, we had to have the state police remove one parent. She was way out of control. An extreme example, perhaps, but there are many others. Parents actually engaging in fist fights happens. And some coaches lack the capacity to deal with students in a positive manner. I watched as one of our school's coaches humiliated a good friend's daughter on the b-ball court in front of a packed gym. I went over and said, "Hey, sport, don't mistake yourself for a university coach, and I won't mistake you for an Elvis imitator." Later I did a training for coaches on the emotional development of teens, noting the differences between the average 15 year olds and 19 year olds. Any good coach knows that stuff.)
A lot of that could depend on how the important people in her life respond. All kids at that age can be damaged if they react by saying it is important that she/he improve her skills, as if they somehow failed.
The Roux Comes First
(1,975 posts)But we don't want them as neurotic as we are!
She made me stop singing "Sweet Baby James" as a lullabye recently, and I can no longer inveigle her into readings of Madeline or Wind in the Willows. But she is still my darling.
kerouac2
(1,371 posts)That's what they do in our district. So 7th graders are competing with 7 and 8 graders. For sports with smaller teams , like baseball, a lot of good 7th graders don't make it. But they stick with training and playing and make it in 8th grade.
In baseball, many of the good kids I knew who didn't make it first time around made it next season and played thru varsity and some play college now.
Stinks to see 12 year olds quit a sport because of 7th grade cuts. Some schools are adding multiple teams so they can include more kids. Soccer is one example.
Also, kids who are cut in 7th can usually jump over to cross country in fall and track in spring. Wrestling for boys in winter. With no cuts. Then they can tryout again next season for the sport they didn't make.