Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

UpInArms

(53,705 posts)
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 02:34 PM Sunday

The Most Terrifying Graph I Have Ever Seen

Last edited Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:32 PM - Edit history (2)

But, there was perceived potential there. Thanks to years of propaganda and reframing, the world came to see AI as this incredible futuristic technology that would revolutionise everything. Yet, the vast majority of people didn’t understand how it worked, its limitations, or its drawbacks. Due to the work published by Google in 2017, AI was just beginning to resemble this potential by 2022.

These Big Tech companies and their major investors had a choice. Follow the monetary policy, and take a minor hit in value while the economy sorted itself out. Or, ignore it, and use this perfect opportunity to embrace wildly unrealistic speculation and keep their value tracking upwards. They chose the latter and, through intra-industry and circular investing, managed to isolate this money machine from the wider economy. . Then, propaganda pushed by the investment banker “analysts” who poured money into this cycle grew it even more, making their own moronic investment “worth” more and giving this trainwreck the appearance of credibility.

This is why the S&P 500 didn’t decrease alongside job openings. Big Tech was large enough and powerful enough to reject monetary policy, so they built their own separate ouroboros-esque economy based on their own deranged desire to grow at all costs, rather than the needs of their consumers or reality.

This has pushed the US into a functional recession, even if the S&P 500 didn’t reflect it. Deutsche Bank found that if you exclude AI expenditure from the US’s GDP, its growth has actually dropped off rapidly to near zero, which is a key warning sign of a recession. The cost of living is soaring, real-term wages have fallen, and unemployment has risen. This threatened to crush the actual economy, so the Federal Reserve began cutting interest rates in late 2024 to boost investment and create jobs and has continued to cut them since.


More from Medium here:

https://archive.ph/TI9pm

ETA graph (thank you BRDS)

36 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Most Terrifying Graph I Have Ever Seen (Original Post) UpInArms Sunday OP
K & R bookmarked FakeNoose Sunday #1
Insightful analysis. Thanks. cachukis Sunday #2
Wow! Thanks so much for posting this. . . . h2ebits Sunday #3
Great article! RainCaster Sunday #4
Same people who have done the same thing with Crypto. ToxMarz Sunday #8
It is a horror wendyb-NC Sunday #5
AI + Robotics equals less jobs. patphil Sunday #6
You bring up the point that isn't being discussed enough. Shipwack Sunday #22
Tech isn't ready for that AT ALL, mostly hype. See IBM and McDs screwing up AI menu uponit7771 Sunday #35
Prescient Aviation Pro Sunday #7
The actual original post by Will Lockett. Full access, not processed through The Medium, etc. erronis Sunday #9
Thanks for the link UpInArms Sunday #10
We all find things through aggregators (DU is one also). I thank you for bringing this forward. erronis Sunday #21
Damned amazing for a journalist out of East Sussex County, UK. Analyzing data is one, thing, ancianita Sunday #20
Ok, but what about that Michael Burry story, him shorting nvidia and Palantir? intrepidity Sunday #11
Because He's Whiffed In Several Occasions... ProfessorGAC Sunday #13
But he's put a billion bucks on the line intrepidity Sunday #14
I Get It ProfessorGAC Sunday #16
Fair enough. intrepidity Sunday #17
I Certainly Hope So ProfessorGAC Sunday #18
He's correct bubble is high he has enough money for long term short position uponit7771 Sunday #36
The graph is real. The interpretation is way off, IMHO Bluetus Sunday #12
But that is also the conclusion of the article intrepidity Sunday #15
I see your point. That did not really jump out at me Bluetus Sunday #25
Here is the graph BumRushDaShow Sunday #19
Nobody is going to win here. tinrobot Sunday #23
When this bubble bursts (they alway do) it will dwarf the Dot Com, Housing Bubble and Covid Recessions. flashman13 Sunday #24
And add in TommyT139 Sunday #33
Most of those venture capitalist will go down in flames. Everyone takes an ass whipping this time. flashman13 Sunday #34
Imagine my surprise when no graph actually existed inside the post despite the subject of this thread. LonePirate Sunday #26
There is a graph in there jmbar2 Sunday #28
Edited to add the graph that UpInArms Sunday #29
The You Tube comment was because the post had a hyperbolic/incorrect subject line like so many You Tube threads. LonePirate Sunday #30
The explanation regarding market manipulation UpInArms Sunday #32
So as long as the working class markodochartaigh Sunday #27
Kick dalton99a Sunday #31

h2ebits

(958 posts)
3. Wow! Thanks so much for posting this. . . .
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 03:12 PM
Sunday

Earlier this year, Warren Buffett disclosed that he closed out Berkshire Hathaway's position in the S&P 500. Looking at this, it looks like it was a sound business practice.

RainCaster

(13,315 posts)
4. Great article!
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 03:36 PM
Sunday

Worth your time to read. It goes through many of the issues I have with AI, and points out that it is a failure. What I wasn't aware of is the way that the tech bros have falsely created their own stock value lie and stolen billions from our portfolios.

ToxMarz

(2,604 posts)
8. Same people who have done the same thing with Crypto.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:13 PM
Sunday

Could Crypto be done legitimately and have an inherent use, yes. Is it, NO! Right now the most value to be gained from both by the financial class is not in what good they could do, it's what can they grift off them for the fastest, biggest bang for their buck.

patphil

(8,483 posts)
6. AI + Robotics equals less jobs.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:02 PM
Sunday

Intelligent automation will reduce demand for human workers dramatically over the next decade. The problem is manifold.
1) A lot less people will have the necessary income to support themselves and their families.
2) Demand for goods and services will shrink as available dollars for non-essential items also shrinks, further reducing the job market.
3) The government will need to shift it's priorities to compensate for a different kind of population; one even more seriously divided between the haves and the have nots.
4) Elections will be seen as a serious obstacle to maintaining government in the hands of those who are seen as worthy to lead.
5) The government will need to be more authoritarian to protect itself and those whom it deems as worthy citizens from those who have little value, and might look to violence to recoup what they are expected to lose.

This does appear to be driving the long range planning by the republicans. They see the need to drastically reduce the number of people in the country who they perceive as not being able to contribute to this changing employment picture.
They are redesigning the government to phase out any program that supports certain types of people. Elimination of retired people who they see as a burden (useless eaters) along with people with serious illnesses and/or disabilities is part of how they plan to do this.
They also don't see the need for an educated workforce, since a lot of the jobs that will still be there will be semi-skilled. Also, they will want to tailor higher education to only be available to the select few.

So, we're looking forward to republican culture wars on a grand scale...if they get their way.
This is what project 2025 is really about; the redesigning of the United States into a authoritarian state that puts the "right" people on top of the heap, while insuring that the rest of the people are in survival mode, and aren't able to do anything about it.
AI is an integral part of this, since it automates the complete, total, utter control of the masses.

Shipwack

(2,907 posts)
22. You bring up the point that isn't being discussed enough.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:20 PM
Sunday

AI is not going to become SkyNet. It is going to become something that does mildly shitty work for a host of white collar jobs. The pointy-haired bosses are going to deem “mildly-shitty” is acceptable for as cheap it is. Lots of lost jobs, especially lower skilled and entry level. Magazines and websites are already using AI this way.

Meanwhile, under the radar, robotics is getting better. It used to be relegated to doing heavy work in factories. Now it’s being tooled for lighter industries. My grocery store is already nudging me to curbside pickup. Once robotic inventory control becomes “good enough” how long will it be before outside pickup is mandatory because the store is completely automated? Amazon is trying to get there now.

Right now I’m training myself out of a job. I currently am making valve assemblies for electronic component manufacturing. Sometimes I work setting up parts for a prototype robotic platform that picks up the part, placed it, and bolts it in place to the correct tightness. There goes the 800 jobs in this factory. It still makes many mistakes, but my current job days are numbered. I’ll be out of the workforce before that, but I worry about my granddaughter’s future.

erronis

(21,903 posts)
9. The actual original post by Will Lockett. Full access, not processed through The Medium, etc.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:24 PM
Sunday
https://www.planetearthandbeyond.co/p/the-most-terrifying-graph-i-have

Please try to reference the original piece for the full content. Also, the author Will Lockett is a pretty damned amazing person. This is on his substack.

erronis

(21,903 posts)
21. We all find things through aggregators (DU is one also). I thank you for bringing this forward.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:15 PM
Sunday

I'm just suggesting that when we find something on RawStory (as an example) we look to see if we can find the original material (RawStory isn't very good at making their references visible), and if possible posting additional original source links.

I guess I've spent too much time looking through scientific/medical citations trying to find origins.

ancianita

(42,539 posts)
20. Damned amazing for a journalist out of East Sussex County, UK. Analyzing data is one, thing,
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:15 PM
Sunday

telling Americans how fucked they are by Big Tech is quite another.
Sure, he's worked for Big Think and climate start-ups like Ocean Bird. His approach of explaining complex, state-of-the-art technology simply, combined with storytelling gets him north of 100,000 followers.

So in a global numbers context, his story here is insignificant to most of the 6.04 billion internet users worldwide, who represent 73.2% of the global population.


My take on this? Don't believe his hype. Facts are facts. His opinion of what they mean for America is a story that prioritizes precision over general accuracy -- because labor, labor markets, and other economic and political dynamics can change his story. So no one can predict whether advanced capitalism has won yet.

Just my opinion, too, of course.

intrepidity

(8,533 posts)
11. Ok, but what about that Michael Burry story, him shorting nvidia and Palantir?
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:34 PM
Sunday

If he is correct, Theil et al are about to have some very bad days.

ProfessorGAC

(75,188 posts)
13. Because He's Whiffed In Several Occasions...
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:39 PM
Sunday

...I'm not he's the most credible prognosticator.
I'd love him to be right, but it seems more like wishful thinking.

intrepidity

(8,533 posts)
14. But he's put a billion bucks on the line
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:43 PM
Sunday

That feels like more than just wishful thinking, but time will tell.

ProfessorGAC

(75,188 posts)
16. I Get It
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:47 PM
Sunday

But, he's got several billion.
He's gambling some of it, and if he whiffs again, no big deal. He's still got 4 or 5 billion.
This isn't like you and me betting 20% of our retirement portfolio. He can afford to guess wrongly.

ProfessorGAC

(75,188 posts)
18. I Certainly Hope So
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:51 PM
Sunday

And, we agree that it's a bubble.
It seems rooted in a belief that it will be winner-take-all, which seems utterly ridiculous.
All these companies can't achieve the "potential" if one winner takes all, and none of them will if the wins are distributed.

Bluetus

(1,894 posts)
12. The graph is real. The interpretation is way off, IMHO
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 04:39 PM
Sunday

ChatGPT is not eliminating many jobs so far. It probably will in the future.

What is eliminating jobs is the fear of a severe recession by the 493 companies in the S&P500 that aren't sucking up the oxygen like crazy.

Apple (AAPL)
Microsoft (MSFT)
Nvidia (NVDA)
Alphabet (GOOGL/GOOG) (Google's parent company)
Amazon (AMZN)
Meta Platforms (META) (Facebook's parent company)
Tesla (TSLA)

These 7 companies are over-valued like crazy, and THAT is the present AI effect. These companies have such insane valuations now that they have completely distorted the SP500 index. If you have some money in an index fund, I urge you to consider moving some of that to cash.

Bluetus

(1,894 posts)
25. I see your point. That did not really jump out at me
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:58 PM
Sunday

when I read the article.

I think the article makes important points. I just think it is important to make the distinction between:

* The big money interests have extracted trillions of dollars of wealth from the middle class and are now dumping practically unlimited amounts of money into "AI" with the expectation of big returns in the future, and in so doing have greatly distorted the markets, at least the SP500. Those 7 grossly overvalued companies now represent nearly 40% of the S&P 500 index, but the combined revenues of those companies is less than 8% of US GDP (and that includes lots of revenue earned globally that was never part of the US GDP.

- and -

* AI, and specifically CHATGPT is responsible for job losses.

I'm not saying that no jobs anywhere have been eliminated because some AI process does that job instead. I'm sure there must be such cases. And I am not saying we should be unconcerned over future job losses resulting from AI. That likely will be a real thing. But what we are really seeing TODAY is a faltering economy NOT being reflected in the major stock market indices because of the gross overweight of the Mag-7 companies.

BumRushDaShow

(163,191 posts)
19. Here is the graph
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:06 PM
Sunday

Source: QEX Management

(the legend on the bottom goes from Dec. '01 - Jun. 23, the orange oval is around the pandemic period and the red is closer to current)


tinrobot

(11,870 posts)
23. Nobody is going to win here.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:25 PM
Sunday

This quote pretty much sums it up:

The logic surrounding the AI boom is utterly moronic. The idea is to gamble the entire Western economy by heavily investing in technology that will wipe out almost all jobs. It is a lose-lose scenario. If the bet fails, the economy crashes. If the bet succeeds, the economy crashes. And this graph shows that this is precisely what is happening.

flashman13

(1,755 posts)
24. When this bubble bursts (they alway do) it will dwarf the Dot Com, Housing Bubble and Covid Recessions.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 05:25 PM
Sunday

It is going to be a 1929 style Depression. The suffering will be extreme and no one will escape it.

And it is going to happen on Trump's watch. We already know these buffoons have no idea how to deal with a real crisis. On the plus side (if there is such a thing in this situation) it is probably going to happen before the mid-term elections. That will mark the end of the MAGA/Republican party for all times. I just hope we have an FDR type to lead the progressives, We the People, back into the light. I do have one in mind.

TommyT139

(2,071 posts)
33. And add in
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:39 PM
Sunday

...the increasing severity of natural disasters; climate change drowning countries and propelling mass migration; increasing authoritarianism assisting a few at the top to take put as much profit as they can in the short term.

As if venture capitalists are buying up the US and selling it off for a quick buck.

flashman13

(1,755 posts)
34. Most of those venture capitalist will go down in flames. Everyone takes an ass whipping this time.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 07:14 PM
Sunday

Natural disasters are just going to be the icing on the cake.

LonePirate

(14,308 posts)
26. Imagine my surprise when no graph actually existed inside the post despite the subject of this thread.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:07 PM
Sunday

In reality, the only surprising thing about the post is that it didn't contain a You Tube link.

jmbar2

(7,437 posts)
28. There is a graph in there
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:28 PM
Sunday

Don't know why you aren't seeing it, or snarking on the OP. If there's a YouTube link, so be it.

Not anyone's place to censor what people want to share or view on DU.

UpInArms

(53,705 posts)
29. Edited to add the graph that
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:31 PM
Sunday

BRDS put in their link down thread … you could have seen it there ..

Ps … am not a big YouTube poster … so not sure why that comment was necessary

LonePirate

(14,308 posts)
30. The You Tube comment was because the post had a hyperbolic/incorrect subject line like so many You Tube threads.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:35 PM
Sunday

You added the graph so the post actually matched the subject line. Thank you.

UpInArms

(53,705 posts)
32. The explanation regarding market manipulation
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 06:38 PM
Sunday

Seemed more important than the graph (imho) and made the article worth reading in its entirety, where the graph would be seen

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Most Terrifying Graph...