General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI need help from folks here who know the Bible: what did Jesus say about abortion?
I'd like to know what the pro-lifers base their religious view on.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)Old Testament, they believe Jesus came to "fulfill the law" rather than abolish it, so those commandments are still in effect.
malaise
(290,995 posts)That is all
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)people protesting at a clinic why they're there, it's generally the "do not murder" commandment.
malaise
(290,995 posts)and they never think about their contradictions
PoindexterOglethorpe
(28,302 posts)to the death penalty.
Otherwise, they're fucking hypocrites. Oh, and by the way, the ONLY person who needs an opinion of abortion is the person who might be having one.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(28,302 posts)And all those who oppose one and not the other are still hypocrites.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(28,302 posts)Although I've known for decades that all religions involve massive amounts of hypocrisy.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,969 posts)Don't get me wrong, I don't believe any of this myself. But I've studied it out of necessity and accusations of hypocrisy are simply "I'm rubber, you're glue" to their way of thinking. OPs like this one are not gotchas.
DBoon
(24,498 posts)Some Catholic religious orders make a point to protest executions.
questionseverything
(11,473 posts)Because we couldnt
He was tortured on the cross, died and descended into hell, fought the devil and on the 3rd rose victorious from the grave
He paid the price for our sins, so whoever believes in
Him will never die and have eternal life/ peace
Xxxxxx
Coventina
(28,905 posts)tintinvotes
(108 posts)dsc
(53,254 posts)New International Version
Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, before you were born I set you apart; I appointed you as a prophet to the nations. This is about John the Baptist according to tradition.
CTyankee
(67,537 posts)haele
(14,845 posts)Don't remember exactly
"God chose him to be Prophet, while he was still being created"
Which means one really has to be aware of the vagaries of translations and the potential for "added context" in later translations. I've heard some scholars say the context was more like indicating poetically that the Prophet referred to was was going to be "that guy", born at a specific time and place and guided by God to be the Great Prophet to lead them back to Israel from Babylon.
RockRaven
(18,349 posts)backfill with bullshit from their giant book of multiple choice in the mistaken view that if they can claim that some deity said so (or some insinuation of the same) that they have some sort of argument-ending trump card.
multigraincracker
(36,697 posts)Many times it mentions The Breath of Life as when life begins.
Always fun to bring that up in Sunday School.
😎
milestogo
(22,198 posts)Life begins when a baby draws its first breath.
milestogo
(22,198 posts)There is nothing in the bible which refers directly (or indirectly) to abortion.
Midnight Writer
(24,979 posts)A man who suspects his wife has been impregnated by another man takes his wife to a priest who gives her a liquid to drink that will kill the baby.
Exodus also has a bit about striking a woman to cause a miscarriage
Neither of these condemn abortion.
As far as I know, there is no mention of abortion in the New Testament.
TomSlick
(12,806 posts)God commanded the administration of a potion that would cause an abortion if the pregnancy was the result of adultery.
OC375
(336 posts)Hence the Abortion is Murder slogan.
haele
(14,845 posts)Back in the day, it wasn't. Women were property of either the husband or father/family patriarch, as were all the children, born and unborn, until the sons left their father's house.
Born children were "People", and murder was strictly defined.
For instance, if you beat your child, wife, or slave in chastisement (instead of in anger - like, tell me the difference?) and they died immediately, it was murder.
If they died a couple days later, it was considered a regular unexpected death or accident, I.e.God's Will.
Anyway, causing a miscarriage is still identified as a property crime in the Bible, not murder.
marble falls
(69,215 posts)CTyankee
(67,537 posts)marble falls
(69,215 posts)... Seriously, though: I don't believe in abortion, but it's an easy stand for me - I'm male. I believe it's a free will choice choice that is ultimately a woman's choice. I don't think very many, if any woman makes this choice lightly. There should be no laws against abortion. It should be covered by health care providers; if pregnancy is gawd inspired, why is ED not?
All people are all things in different portions.
Krazy_Kat
(69 posts)marble falls
(69,215 posts)... MSL churches and been denied Communion by the pastor because he personally din't know I was confirmed MSL. I've had Communion at every Evangelical church I've been in.
I went to MSL parochial schools in Ohio, and we were taught that dinosaurs were fake.
Happy Hoosier
(9,260 posts)I guess we were rebels, because we got none of that. We had bull roasts where the beer flowed, dances, halloween parties.
Of course, Im an atheist now so none of that matters to me. But I was shocked when as an adult I found out MSL is fundie!
marble falls
(69,215 posts)... It seriously broke me. Going to sixth grade in public school was amazing.
In second grade I got a Timex for Christmas. Also we learned that any unforgiven sin would consign us to hell. Someone asked the teacher if a small unforgiven sin might be overlooked at judgement. And the teacher, Mr Roberts said, "no", that if a sock had a small hole in it, it was still a defective sock.
I used the watch to beg forgiveness every ten minutes for any sin I might have even unconsciously thought about.
I told Roman Catholic friends they were going to hell, not as a jeer, but for concern of losing friends forever.
Happy Hoosier
(9,260 posts)My church experience was much more chill! My Father-in-law was MSL and he was shocked when he found out about what my church was like. He was not super strict himself, but he told stories of hiding the beer from the minister when he visited. I was all, hiding beer!? Lutherans were GERMAN!!!!
Good times. He was a right wing nut, but i still miss him.
marble falls
(69,215 posts)... despite not having lived there since '82.
Girard442
(6,791 posts)Be it further RESOLVED, That we call upon Southern Baptists to work for legislation that will allow the possibility of abortion under such conditions as rape, incest, clear evidence of severe fetal deformity, and carefully ascertained evidence of the likelihood of damage to the emotional, mental, and physical health of the mother.
Anybody who tells you the Bible has always been crystal clear on abortion is full of...themselves.
rollin74
(2,241 posts)at least
Hassler
(4,647 posts)MurrayDelph
(5,683 posts)because in Judaism a fetus isn't a person until it breathes on its own.
But he DID spend a lot of time telling people to not be assholes.
They pretend he spoke on the former and ignored the latter.
sarisataka
(22,144 posts)As he did about 3-D printing
mcar
(45,473 posts)Wiz Imp
(8,081 posts)They base those views on various passages in the Old Testament (pre-Jesus) while conveniently ignoring many other passages because those other passages don't tell them they should "hate" other people.
In reality, The Bible only mentions abortion once, and its a recipe. Numbers 5:11-31 is the only time abortion is mentioned and its a recipe on how to perform one.
16 The priest shall bring her and have her stand before the Lord. 17 Then he shall take some holy water in a clay jar and put some dust from the tabernacle floor into the water. 18 After the priest has had the woman stand before the Lord, he shall loosen her hair and place in her hands the reminder-offering, the grain offering for jealousy, while he himself holds the bitter water that brings a curse. 19 Then the priest shall put the woman under oath and say to her, If no other man has had sexual relations with you and you have not gone astray and become impure while married to your husband, may this bitter water that brings a curse not harm you. 20 But if you have gone astray while married to your husband and you have made yourself impure by having sexual relations with a man other than your husband 21 here the priest is to put the woman under this cursemay the Lord cause you to become a curse among your people when he makes your womb miscarry and your abdomen swell. 22 May this water that brings a curse enter your body so that your abdomen swells or your womb miscarries.
Wounded Bear
(63,486 posts)as in nada fucking thing.
rsdsharp
(11,524 posts)That said, in the late 1980s I represented Planned Parenthood in a case in which we successfully obtained an injunction against the leader of the local Operation Rescue chapter to prevent her from going on PP property.
When she violated that injunction, we successfully sought to hold her in contempt. She was ordered to to spend 37 days in jail (reduced from 40 because the Judge didnt like the Biblical connections with that number.)
While in jail, she sent me a Christmas card (really!) with the following verse:
But whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.
Matthew 18:6. (Ho ho ho)
So apparently, that was her justification for being virulently anti abortion.
Jacson6
(1,643 posts)Is based on a man pulling out early during intercourse with a woman and spilling his seed on the ground. In the OT abortion is okay if the woman had an affair and got pregnant. They would give her bitter water to induce abortion. Jesus never talked about sex or abortion. He just said that a man can only divorce a woman for adultery.
There are theology books on the subject in libraries & book stores.
GoCubsGo
(34,539 posts)"The Separation of Church and Hate." You can hear and read excerpts from it is many of his recent book tour interviews and podcasts, but the book is far more thorough. He puts all the issues in historical context, as well.
RedWhiteBlueIsRacist
(1,492 posts)Remember, if the Church is not a building as Christians like to say, then neither is the Temple.
OAITW r.2.0
(30,936 posts)And that is defined at birth. OK, so a woman has a stillbirth....is she guilty of manslaughter? How far will these people go in their twisted view of reality?
Chemical Bill
(2,988 posts)If he disagreed with Orthodox Jewish teachings about life beginning at first breath, it might have been a big enough deal to make it into the Bible.
In any discussion about the Jesus, I like to bring up the fact that Jesus preached in the Temple, and was called Rabbi. According to Jewish law, Jesus would have to be married to do that. A Jewish friend once added that if Jesus was not married, Jews would not have listened to a word....
Kaleva
(40,063 posts)Xolodno
(7,241 posts)...nothing really.
I could actually make a solid case against Christmas.
Ironic isn't it?
KentuckyWoman
(7,330 posts)The old testament supports forced abortion if a husband thinks his wife is pregnant by another man. However, Jesus never addressed it.
Midwestern Democrat
(1,012 posts)- about 16 to 22 weeks into pregnancy - which is in the second trimester and is pretty close to the Roe framework (elective abortion could be banned at the point of viability - third trimester).
MineralMan
(150,208 posts)Assuming that there was a Jesus as described in the New Testament, the words recorded there don't discuss abortion, homosexuality, contraception nor many other things. Christianity is an interpretation of what someone says that Jesus said, over 2000 years ago.
How many other accounts of things that happened 2000 years ago do we pay attention to?
Jesus is irrelevant when it comes to abortion, contraception, any other rights women have.
Rebl2
(17,204 posts)C_U_L8R
(48,521 posts)And something about loving your neighbor. All news to the redhatted.
Mike Nelson
(10,833 posts)... people cite the Bible in condemning it... BUT there is no specific, direct command that forbids abortion. It used to be that "life" began when the baby was born... and God provided its first breath. In the old days, there were fines, sometimes, if you caused a woman to lose the baby of a nobleman, you would have to "pay" - a small fine.. maybe two chickens. I think, today, many believe God is present at conception and has a "plan" for every life, from that moment. "I knew you in the womb" is often cited. This is also why that (?) Politician said "legitimate rape" - I can't recall his name - it's because God/Jesus would not permit conception in a "real" rape. "The woman's body has a way of shutting that down," he said, with Jesus' help. Of course, the original intent is to make as many Jewish people as possible, as the OT God says, "Go forth and multiply!" In the NT, that means make more Christians. Today, abortion does not help make more Christians.
jfz9580m
(16,103 posts)It answers your questions.
https://www.currentaffairs.org/news/john-fugelsang
**************************
Theres so much evidence in the Bible that Jesus is not anti-gay, namely the Sermon on the Mount. You cant talk this bullshit that Allie pushes and claim to follow this guy. Toxic empathyturn away more refugees. Turn away more refugees while boasting of your piety.
ROBINSON: Turning to the abortion chapter of the book, I was interested in finding out how she uses the text of the Bible to justify opposition to abortion. And its quite thin, this part. I mean, basically she says that God expresses deep detestation for the unjust killing of people; the prohibition of murder is the fifth of the 10 Commandments.
FUGELSANG: Yes, strong argument.
ROBINSON: The Lord hates hands that shed innocent blood. And thats about it.
FUGELSANG: So again, Im not saying the Bibles pro-abortion or that Jesus would work as a clinic escort on the weekends, but abortions are legal and free in Israel right now. You wouldnt know this if you watch Fox News, but do you know why abortions are legal and free in Israel right now? Because the one religion thats in the Bible, that would be Judaism, the religion of MosesJesus died being a Jewnever bans abortion. Judaism believes that life begins with the first breath. Thats repeated throughout the Gospels. Now Im not going to say that its pro-abortion, but abortions are legal and free in Israel right now.
They want to believe in a Christianity where God really wants men to force people to be pregnant against their willwhere men force rape victims to be pregnant by their attacker against their willand none of this appears in the Bible. At no point do they say youve got to force poor women to have greater poverty. My Christian take is, considering that abortion is less dangerous than pregnancy or childbirth, I dont have any goddamn right to tell a woman what she can or cannot do with her body. Im on the side of men not telling women what to do with their bodies. Thats the world Jesus grew up in. God, in Exodus 21, asserts that a fetus is property and that a womans life has more value in his eyes. In Numbers 5, God gives rather gruesome, detailed abortion tips for pregnant, unfaithful wives. Lets talk about killing innocents because, oh, you Gentiles heard about Passover? God killed the firstborn of all the Egyptian sons. God kills tons of kids and fetuses in this book; one time, God drowned every pregnant woman and fetus on Earth with a flood because he was in a mood. Jesus never comes out against abortion. God never mentions it. God never has any characters of the Bible say anything against abortion. Jesus is vigorously against the death penalty, but Allie Beth Stuckey thinks that Jesus is wrong on that, and Donald Trump is right. So again, man, you want to go ahead and fight for criminalizing abortion? Go ahead. But dont tell me youre doing it because of Jesus.
Fugelsang is cool..
11 Bravo
(24,244 posts)He did, however, speak at length about "welcoming the stranger" and "caring for the least of us".
Somehow MAGAT "Christians" missed those parts.