General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDo people actually believe the Epstein files matter?
Even if by some miracle they are released, Trump will not be removed from office- if attempting to overthrow the government wasn't enough of an offence, child rape won't matter.
It will shame Trump? -Sociopaths do not feel shame
Reduce support for Republicans? The cult is fully indoctrinated; they voted for a felon with 34 convictions and Congress persons who have repeatedly screwed them over. As long as there is an "R" after the name, Republican voters will support them.
Yes, there will be some satisfaction in confirming what we know but overall, there will be no significant change in the status quo
NoRethugFriends
(3,594 posts)AZJonnie
(2,246 posts)First I've heard of it in relation to the House proposal to order them released. Not saying you're wrong just not encountered that angle
NoRethugFriends
(3,594 posts)The discharge petition is just to force a vote on it in the house.
It would be a different story if a judge ordered the release, which he'd ignore anyhow.
Jersey Devil
(10,601 posts)My understanding is that H.Res.589 is a Simple Resolution and does not require a vote by the Senate or the President's signature.
https://www.house.gov/the-house-explained/the-legislative-process/bills-resolutions
https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-resolution/589/text
A simple resolution requires approval only from the members of that single chamber to be adopted. It does not need to be passed by the other chamber of Congress, nor is it sent to the President for signature or approval.
Legal Force and Scope
Simple resolutions do not have the force of law. Their effect is limited to the internal affairs, operations, procedures, or opinions of the chamber that passes them. They are essentially a way for the House or the Senate to manage its own business or express its collective sentiment on a matter.
https://govfacts.org/explainer/understanding-concurrent-joint-and-simple-resolutions-in-the-u-s-congress/
It does not have the force of law and Trump may simply ignore it, but it will trigger unrelenting demands and possible further action should he do so. Plus, maybe most important of all, it will piss off Maga World like never before.
purr-rat beauty
(819 posts)Hasn't made a dent. His minions and zealots just brush it off. We do have to accept the fact that this admin is a sex abuse ring?
And treat that as normal?
Like WTF
MarineCombatEngineer
(16,762 posts)IMHO, we're never going to see those files, unless someone leaks them and even then, Been A Dick Donald and his loyal MAGAt's will claim that it's fake news, call for an investigation and go after anyone who dares to call him out on this.
Semper Fi brother Marine.
sarisataka
(22,144 posts)Happy Birthday and Veteran's Day
OLDMDDEM
(2,910 posts)Silent Type
(11,959 posts)and GOPers try to shield it.
I do remember some posts a few weeks ago about leaks that there are photos of trump with naked young girls. If true, I take it all back. Maybe 2% of trump voters might care if something like that were released.
2naSalit
(98,839 posts)Suspect, it's far worse than what we know or imagine.
BlueTsunami2018
(4,754 posts)Its not going to matter what appears in there, it wont make a bit of difference. I think its going to be a big dud personally. All this build up to tell us things we already know.
Emile
(39,083 posts)Bettie
(19,116 posts)no matter what people say, everyone is aware of what he is.
He could rape and murder children live on national TV and lose no support whatsoever.
The people who support him are devoid of anything approaching humanity or decency.
AZJonnie
(2,246 posts)In no small part because we'll never get the whole thing, un-doctored by Bondi and Patel.
But also because I think that even the full files would drop with a nothing-burger level thud in the first place. In the sense there will be nothing new and earth-shattering in them.
That's because I believe if they actually contained the things that people frantically speculate about, like all-powerful Pedo Cabals with the power to whack Epstein in jail, and/or Epstein running a massive child-prostitution ring to the rich and famous, this would have part of the Biden DoJ's case against Maxwell. Instead they prosecuted her for trafficking a couple of girls to Epstein himself, and got a conviction for only 1.
Also I believe Epstein's pilots, who were PROSECUTION witnesses for the DOJ in the Maxwell case, who said Giuffre is the only minor they know of who travelled without a guardian on the plane, ever. And they presumed Guiffre was over 18 because of how she dressed, carried herself, and was treated by Epstein and Maxwell, i.e. like an adult, and she travelled with them a LOT of times. And that they never found evidence of sex while cleaning up after flights, and that they were never told any area of the plane was "off-limits", ever, and that they spent time in the cabin fairly often, used the restroom in the cabin area, etc. They testified this under oath, in a massive, high-profile case against Maxwell, where any of presumably dozens of women could call them out and say "bullshit" if they were lying? And none of them did.
I think the reality of the Epstein case is considerably more mundane than people speculate. A couple of rich perverts recruiting and paying vulnerable minors for sex, with themselves. Though I do believe they shared their concubine, Virginia Giuffre, with Prince Andrew, and probably some others, since she says that happened.
Basically, I think we already pretty much know what happened even without the release of the files. What probably IS in the files though is some evidence of people KNOWING, but not saying jack about it. People like TSF, for example.
Torchlight
(6,117 posts)And satisfyingly enough to my chair, the talk is more often than not by my politically apathet5ic coworkers.
leftstreet
(38,208 posts)If he files don't prove the conspiracy theories about elite pedophile rings and Clinton and Pizza Basements and all the other weird shit Trump promised he'd expose
Prairie Gates
(6,796 posts)There are no "Epstein files," and there never have been.
mr715
(2,267 posts)There will be conspiracy theories, gnashing of teeth, and denial.
To many pretend that this is a central issue motivating politics, when it is the dismantling of liberal democracy instead. I'm sure the pedophile/fascist overlap is real and will never be studied, because, you know, cancel culture. If Trump, etc. are found fucking little boys, I bet you $10 Rogan et al. will be talking about Ancient Greece and how badass the Spartans were.
There will be no justice for Epstein's victims.
misanthrope
(9,290 posts)In a deeply emotional way.
sarisataka
(22,144 posts)The victims would at least get vindication.If not justice
misanthrope
(9,290 posts)I think vindication for the abuse is more important.
viva la
(4,401 posts)Trump with underaged models. He talked about how Trump and Epstein spent the 90s chasing models, many quite young. It was really disgusting. Some of the modeling agencies in the 90s were trafficking these girls. There are pictures of Trump on his yacht with these young models, but I think those are already public.
Wolff also said he personally has hours of audio of Epstein-- who wanted him to write Epstein's bio! And he said Epstein said Trump and Melania first had sex on his plane. Melania threatened to sue him, and he turned at "slapped" her with a "Slapp" lawsuit, which is something about using the court system to deprive someone of free speech: SLAPP, or Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation
He set up a gofundme to get money for this and other similar lawsuits for other people, and got $700K in a day. People are MAD at Trump hiding the files.
Wolff said the best part would be discovery... maybe deposing the "first lady". (In " " because she doesn't even live in Washington.)
uponit7771
(93,398 posts)Qutzupalotl
(15,595 posts)then nothing matters except his next stroke.
But his base has been primed to believe it's mostly Democrats in the files. Once they realize they have been lied to and voted for pedophile protectors, they will be pissed, especially the victims of sexual assault.
That very well could erode support for the pedophile protectors, especially given the Trump Modeling Agency and Miss Teen USA Pageant were vehicles for Trump to traffic children for Epstein and himself.
usonian
(22,371 posts)DOJ. Defenders of Jeffrey.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=20790032
Please read and follow links.
Paladin
(31,988 posts)I'd tell you to be ashamed of yourselves, but I don't think it would do much good.
jfz9580m
(16,103 posts)Of my thoughts on Epstein.
[It is also how I feel about many other stories that get way more attention the stories that matter:
https://www.truthdig.com/author/christopher_ketcham/
I recently discovered Chris Ketchams work and he is pretty much the best environmental journalist I have come across so far, which makes him pretty much my favorite journalist.
Ditto with the horror that is modern animal agriculture which the awesome Maria Bolotnikova covers:
https://marinabolotnikova.com/writing#
I wish Ketcham, Bolotnikova etc got a fraction of the attention salacious drivel and faux stories do. Or other stuff like this should:
https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2024/11/demand-critical-metals-e-waste-recycling-clean-energy-climate-vince-beiser-book-power-metal/
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/09/us-waste-billions-unproven-climate-solutions-carbon-capture-storage-subsidies/
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-3010-5
https://www.science.org/content/article/human-stuff-now-outweighs-all-life-earth
https://www.inkl.com/news/a-new-report-says-50-billion-years-of-evolution-is-being-threatened-by-stupid-humans
https://scitechdaily.com/humans-have-erased-3-billion-years-of-evolution-and-its-getting-worse/
]
https://www.nefariousrussians.com/p/epstein-and-the-original-satanic
I imagine quite a few Americans look at this situation and think, What the hell is going on, man? Why are our elites so horrible? Why are they constantly lying to us? Why are they exploiting us? Why are they fucking us so hard? We live in the greatest country on earth! The freest, the most democratic. We are a light unto the nations! So why are the people who end up rising to the top of this amazing and free system such scoundrels? Why are they such evil shits?
Youd think some would then realize that, well, hey, maybe the system is built wrong? Maybe a system that puts private enrichment no matter how ruthless and destructive to the public and the planet, as the highest moral value produces an elite that reflects this debased morality? Maybe the conman ethos thats celebrated in America as mans highest calling translates into a less than ideal ruling class? Maybe theres something going on here?
I would argue even more broadly than Levine that it is not restricted to America or even capitalism. There is something fundamentally wrong with the way human societies concentrate power and veer between mob herding and Machiavellian plotting (by an increasingly dim-witted pseudo-elite), while the actual intellectual elites-honest scientists or doctors like Fauci have less and less power and are slandered/attacked. Our societies keep people focused on the dumbest things imaginable. Its effects can most clearly be seen in our treatment of non-human life:
https://www.currentaffairs.org/news/the-coming-revolution-for-animal-rights
(Btw as a serious supporter of animal rights, I thought that whitecoatwaste/beaglegate stuff was the most cynical perversion of concern over animal rights I ever saw. It misdirected attention from serious animal rights issues at scale like factory farming/ventilation shutdown to attacks on Dr.Fauci/medical research. I am vegan, but even I think where absolutely necessary (e.g.: for say cancer research), animal models are a necessary evil till organoids or similar can replace them. Obviously ethical guidelines must followed.)
Anyway, Levines series on The Spectacle pretty much nails it imo. I use DU and follow a few sites like Current Affairs, but that aside I largely think the net is (like most media) a waste of time. I personally dont think a small amount of technology itself is the issue. I am a solitary human, so in a certain way, I like anything that lets me lead a reclusive life while still participating as I choose to in society. But this specific version that these crass giants sell is garbage. That these morons are now engaged in a futile effort to bleed into a real life gives me hope that they went too far and it will be their end.
https://www.nefariousrussians.com/p/the-epstein-and-the-spectacle
https://www.nefariousrussians.com/p/influencerism-is-the-highest-form
doc03
(38,632 posts)DBoon
(24,498 posts)Prince Andrew was stripped of his title due to the Epstein files, parts not yet publicly known.
This isn't just about Trump.
yaesu
(8,807 posts)snot
(11,354 posts)imho is that, so long as the files remain secret, they can continue to be USED to blackmail or coerce any of the abusers who still retain any power to help or hurt us.
E.g., suppose the files incriminate Trump but also incriminate other powerful people in any governments, organized religions, news media, etc. Trump can keep his own misdeeds secret while using the dirt on other powerful people to coerce them to do or go along with things that harm the rest of us.
The ONLY way to neutralize the potential coercive power of these secrets is to expose them to light.
I cannot understand why so few people seem worried about this.
quaker bill
(8,260 posts)The economy is what burns this down. However, the files will matter enough to some to prevent any reconsideration. Remember, these people (some of them) vote for bathroom bills. They are very sensitive about little girls, and note that some who filed complaints about DJT were little boys. Will it get him impeached and removed, doubtful, it certainly should but probably won't. Could it add a couple of percent to the blue wave in 2026? This is much more likely.
He is already tanking on the economy and that party is only getting started. The firings in preparation for a recession are already started. Seasonal hiring has been cut dramatically. The Trump recession is coming quickly and it will be significant. This will not get him removed either but may render him useless.