Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsImportant and informative (It's The Eugenics, Stupid - by Alyssa Milano)
Researched and shared by Alyssa Milano
It's both informative, and a bit disturbing
She spend over two years suffering from long Covid,
I speculate she had a lot of time to read, research, ponder and write this topic
(Note to mods: she requests we share this, so I am quoting the full post, and source link)
Her intro:
I am embarrassed to say, the first time I had any interest in educating myself on Eugenics was when disability blogger and activist, Imani Barbarin, (Crutches and Spice on instagram. I highly recommend you follow her.) used the phrase in her content. I went looking for the history. What I found was a blueprint for cruelty that never really went away. Researching this piece gave me horrible anxiety. As you read it, I hope you feel something too.
The Return of Eugenics (Just Without the Lab Coats)
When government policies starve, sicken, and sort people by worth, its Eugenics. We like to think eugenics died with sepia photos and bad science. Thats what I thought. We like to think were better now, right? More humane, more evolved? But the truth is: we just rebranded it. We swapped white coats for red hats and Truth Social posts.
Deny food. Kill health care. Green-light pollution. Politicize pandemics.
Under Donald Trump, that old eugenic philosophy hasnt just made a comeback its wearing a suit, a stupidly long tie, and writing horrendous policy. Policy with almost no checks and balances, I might add.
A Quick Refresher: What Eugenics Really Means
Classic eugenics wasnt fringe. Somehow, I thought it was. Or maybe I just wanted it to be fringe. The U.S. governmentsanctioned sterilization programs that operated for over 70 years, roughly from the early 1900s through the 1970s and, in a few states, even into the 1980s. Listen to me. They forcibly sterilized people, disproportionately poor, disabled, and Black and brown, while figures like Harry Laughlin drafted model sterilization bills that later inspired Nazi Germanys race hygiene laws.
Eugenics was never just about genes. It was about power: deciding whose lives are fit, whose are a burden, who gets resources, and whos written off as too expensive to save.
Trumps Policies Through the Eugenics Lens
1. Make the poor hungrier (SNAP)
During shutdown, the administration fought a court order to fully fund Novembers food benefits for 42 million people. Hunger shortens lives and narrows futures selection by scarcity disguised as fiscal responsibility or Democrats care more about immigrants than Americans.
2. Choke off reproductive health (Title X)
Trumps gag rule gutted the Title X network by half, expelling Planned Parenthood and stripping millions of contraception and cancer screenings. Clinics closed; patients vanished. When reproductive care becomes a luxury, thats population control by class.
Weaponize public charge
The 2019 rule didnt just change policy, it weaponized fear. Millions of immigrant families backed away from Medicaid or WIC, terrified that getting their kids a check-up or baby formula could cost them a green card. Proof that cruelty doesnt have to be loud to do obvious damage. It was a bureaucratic version of the old unfit immigrant trope. At its core, its eugenics in a suit: using health and hunger as filters for who gets to belong, who gets to thrive, and whos deemed worthy of America.
4. Engineer the population at the border
Families are torn apart, leaving scars that wont heal in a single lifetime. Watchdogs uncovered unauthorized surgeries in ICE custody as if the body itself were state property.
And now, theyre peering directly at the body as border policy. A new Trump directive tells consular officers to deny visas to people who are obese, diabetic, or living with other health conditions as if illness or imperfection makes someone less human, less deserving of a future here. This is demographic shaping by design: exclude, harm, deter. A system built to control who gets to belong and rewrite Americas DNA at the border.
5. Deregulate pollution and poison the poor
EPA enforcement collapses under Trump 2.0. The result? More toxins in Black, brown, and poor neighborhoods. More asthma. More cancer. More quiet deaths the headlines dont count. Differential survival by ZIP code environmental eugenics hiding behind deregulation and corporate smiles.
And it doesnt stop there. His administration has rolled back food safety inspections, cut staff at the USDA, and let meatpacking plants run faster lines with fewer checks. Inspectors warn that contaminated food is slipping through, but profit wins.
Its another quiet form of discrimination: who gets clean food and who doesnt. The wealthy eat organic and imported. Everyone else gets deregulated dinner and hopes for the best.
6. Treat a pandemic like a let-it-rip experiment
Congressional probes reveal how Trump officials pressured scientists to push herd immunity by infection. Mass death as public-health strategy. They downplayed fatalities in long-term care facilities and ignored the suffering of elders, disabled people, essential workers, and the uninsured. That wasnt incompetence. It was intent eugenics in real time. The belief that some lives are expendable if it keeps the economy humming and donors happy.
7. Starve the science that saves ordinary lives
Trumps budgets go after lifelines. He slashes double digits from the NIH and guts global-health programs. He even pulled the U.S. out of the World Health Organization in the middle of a pandemic, as if solidarity itself were the disease!
The National Cancer Institute lost nearly $3 billion. Cancer research grants vanish. Early-career scientists see their projects defunded overnight. Heart, lung, and diabetes prevention programs disappear. Even the CDCs basic disease surveillance sits on the chopping block. Congress blocks some of it, but intent still matters. Starve public science, and you privatize survival. Cures become luxury goods. It isnt accidental neglect. Its a slow dismantling of the systems that keep ordinary people alive while the rich buy health.
8. Ration care and legalize discrimination
Trumps health policies boil down to this: make care harder to get healthcare services, especially for the people who need it most. Fewer doctor visits. More skipped meds. Sicker families. And then comes the cruelty dressed as religious freedom. In 2020, his administration rewrote a key part of the Affordable Care Act to let hospitals and insurers discriminate against LGBTQ+ patients. A doctor can legally refuse to treat someone simply for who they are. Withholding gender-affirming care from trans people drives depression, self-harm, and suicide, turning identity itself into a life-or-death condition. Thats eugenics too, when policy decides whos allowed to survive as themselves.
When government policies starve, sicken, and sort people by worth, its Eugenics. We like to think eugenics died with sepia photos and bad science. Thats what I thought. We like to think were better now, right? More humane, more evolved? But the truth is: we just rebranded it. We swapped white coats for red hats and Truth Social posts.
Deny food. Kill health care. Green-light pollution. Politicize pandemics.
Under Donald Trump, that old eugenic philosophy hasnt just made a comeback its wearing a suit, a stupidly long tie, and writing horrendous policy. Policy with almost no checks and balances, I might add.
A Quick Refresher: What Eugenics Really Means
Classic eugenics wasnt fringe. Somehow, I thought it was. Or maybe I just wanted it to be fringe. The U.S. governmentsanctioned sterilization programs that operated for over 70 years, roughly from the early 1900s through the 1970s and, in a few states, even into the 1980s. Listen to me. They forcibly sterilized people, disproportionately poor, disabled, and Black and brown, while figures like Harry Laughlin drafted model sterilization bills that later inspired Nazi Germanys race hygiene laws.
Eugenics was never just about genes. It was about power: deciding whose lives are fit, whose are a burden, who gets resources, and whos written off as too expensive to save.
Trumps Policies Through the Eugenics Lens
1. Make the poor hungrier (SNAP)
During shutdown, the administration fought a court order to fully fund Novembers food benefits for 42 million people. Hunger shortens lives and narrows futures selection by scarcity disguised as fiscal responsibility or Democrats care more about immigrants than Americans.
2. Choke off reproductive health (Title X)
Trumps gag rule gutted the Title X network by half, expelling Planned Parenthood and stripping millions of contraception and cancer screenings. Clinics closed; patients vanished. When reproductive care becomes a luxury, thats population control by class.
Weaponize public charge
The 2019 rule didnt just change policy, it weaponized fear. Millions of immigrant families backed away from Medicaid or WIC, terrified that getting their kids a check-up or baby formula could cost them a green card. Proof that cruelty doesnt have to be loud to do obvious damage. It was a bureaucratic version of the old unfit immigrant trope. At its core, its eugenics in a suit: using health and hunger as filters for who gets to belong, who gets to thrive, and whos deemed worthy of America.
4. Engineer the population at the border
Families are torn apart, leaving scars that wont heal in a single lifetime. Watchdogs uncovered unauthorized surgeries in ICE custody as if the body itself were state property.
And now, theyre peering directly at the body as border policy. A new Trump directive tells consular officers to deny visas to people who are obese, diabetic, or living with other health conditions as if illness or imperfection makes someone less human, less deserving of a future here. This is demographic shaping by design: exclude, harm, deter. A system built to control who gets to belong and rewrite Americas DNA at the border.
5. Deregulate pollution and poison the poor
EPA enforcement collapses under Trump 2.0. The result? More toxins in Black, brown, and poor neighborhoods. More asthma. More cancer. More quiet deaths the headlines dont count. Differential survival by ZIP code environmental eugenics hiding behind deregulation and corporate smiles.
And it doesnt stop there. His administration has rolled back food safety inspections, cut staff at the USDA, and let meatpacking plants run faster lines with fewer checks. Inspectors warn that contaminated food is slipping through, but profit wins.
Its another quiet form of discrimination: who gets clean food and who doesnt. The wealthy eat organic and imported. Everyone else gets deregulated dinner and hopes for the best.
6. Treat a pandemic like a let-it-rip experiment
Congressional probes reveal how Trump officials pressured scientists to push herd immunity by infection. Mass death as public-health strategy. They downplayed fatalities in long-term care facilities and ignored the suffering of elders, disabled people, essential workers, and the uninsured. That wasnt incompetence. It was intent eugenics in real time. The belief that some lives are expendable if it keeps the economy humming and donors happy.
7. Starve the science that saves ordinary lives
Trumps budgets go after lifelines. He slashes double digits from the NIH and guts global-health programs. He even pulled the U.S. out of the World Health Organization in the middle of a pandemic, as if solidarity itself were the disease!
The National Cancer Institute lost nearly $3 billion. Cancer research grants vanish. Early-career scientists see their projects defunded overnight. Heart, lung, and diabetes prevention programs disappear. Even the CDCs basic disease surveillance sits on the chopping block. Congress blocks some of it, but intent still matters. Starve public science, and you privatize survival. Cures become luxury goods. It isnt accidental neglect. Its a slow dismantling of the systems that keep ordinary people alive while the rich buy health.
8. Ration care and legalize discrimination
Trumps health policies boil down to this: make care harder to get healthcare services, especially for the people who need it most. Fewer doctor visits. More skipped meds. Sicker families. And then comes the cruelty dressed as religious freedom. In 2020, his administration rewrote a key part of the Affordable Care Act to let hospitals and insurers discriminate against LGBTQ+ patients. A doctor can legally refuse to treat someone simply for who they are. Withholding gender-affirming care from trans people drives depression, self-harm, and suicide, turning identity itself into a life-or-death condition. Thats eugenics too, when policy decides whos allowed to survive as themselves.
History Repeats in Modern Dress
1. Mussolinis Battaglia per le Nascite criminalized birth control for the unfit and subsidized healthy families.
2. Francos Spain stole babies from political dissidents and single mothers. Los niños robados, to be raised by morally pure families.
3. American eugenicists wrote sterilization laws adopted in 32 states; Nazi Germany used them as models.
4. Trumps eugenics: decide who belongs, punish weakness, and call it efficiency.
( references are listed at the end of her post )
https://alyssajmilano.substack.com/p/its-eugenics-stupid
1 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Important and informative (It's The Eugenics, Stupid - by Alyssa Milano) (Original Post)
Pluvious
13 hrs ago
OP
CrispyQ
(40,447 posts)1. Great commentary!
People have dark, vintage ideas of fascism & eugenics, but don't recognize it in modern context.
I didn't know she had long covid. Sorry to hear that. She was outspoken against Trump before covid, too. She took heat for bashing him on her personal page & basically said, too bad if my politics turn you off & you don't follow my professional page anymore.