Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yellowcanine

(36,811 posts)
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:00 AM 6 hrs ago

Why is Vance also trashing the Pope?

I can see why Trump is, it is what he does. But why Vance? I don’t see the upside and there are lots of downsides, particularly for any presidential ambitions. Note that fellow Catholic Marco Rubio seems to be keeping his mouth shut.

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why is Vance also trashing the Pope? (Original Post) yellowcanine 6 hrs ago OP
Because Vance is a whore planning to capture MAGA morons. dem4decades 6 hrs ago #1
That's what they do................... Lovie777 6 hrs ago #2
;-{) PREACHING TO THE CHOIR Goonch 6 hrs ago #3
Because Vance is an asshole. spanone 6 hrs ago #4
J. V. is a specious knob too underpants 6 hrs ago #9
This may be the craziest thing I've seen so far this year Sympthsical 6 hrs ago #5
I imagine that somewhere in Project 25 there's a plan to go after Catholics. yardwork 6 hrs ago #14
Childhood catholic upbringing snowybirdie 4 hrs ago #15
Isn't he Rebl2 4 hrs ago #19
Yes, was raised snowybirdie 4 hrs ago #21
Oh Rebl2 4 hrs ago #22
I read his book snowybirdie 3 hrs ago #23
Because they hate his worldview. WhiskeyGrinder 6 hrs ago #6
Vance is grasping at straws. He can't get traction anywhere. Failed in Iran negotions, supporting Orban... dutch777 6 hrs ago #7
Because he's a lickspittle Maeve 6 hrs ago #8
Moses Mike was getting in some popespank action too Blues Heron 6 hrs ago #10
Because the puppy follows its Master. This is doing livetohike 6 hrs ago #11
Because Vance is a cynical opportunist who has crawled up Trump's colon and has to stay there, Ocelot II 6 hrs ago #12
Opus, that's why MoseShrute 6 hrs ago #13
Because first and foremost he is a Trump ass licker. nt City Lights 4 hrs ago #16
Because ultimately he doesn't really believe his religion. Happy Hoosier 4 hrs ago #17
maybe he already sold his sole eShirl 4 hrs ago #18
Because there is kairos12 4 hrs ago #20

Lovie777

(23,184 posts)
2. That's what they do...................
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:07 AM
6 hrs ago

there is no limit to their evils. Look what they are doing to the US and the world.

As to myself alongwith family and friends, the sense coming from these so called Christians is a smoke screen.

The anti-christ is here.

Sympthsical

(11,017 posts)
5. This may be the craziest thing I've seen so far this year
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:10 AM
6 hrs ago

Which is saying something. Usually whatever this administration manages sounds about right. Trump's nuts, I expect his narcissistic madness.

But JD "Converting to Catholicism is Awesome!" Vance deciding he was going to use his newfound faith to go after the fucking Pope is one of the zaniest right turns I've ever witnessed.

Rubio's quiet because he's an actual Catholic. He's probably appalled by this. But he made his choices - and his bed. I think, starting around the shoe incident, he began realizing he's put his political career permanently to the torch for nothing. He thought he'd be in a position to influence foreign policy in an increasingly multi-polar world, starting with counterbalancing China's rise.

Instead, he's getting an Iranian clusterfuck and Pope Wars. If someone reported he goes home every night and drinks, I'd believe it.

yardwork

(69,458 posts)
14. I imagine that somewhere in Project 25 there's a plan to go after Catholics.
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:43 AM
6 hrs ago

They'll also go after Jews and Muslims and then the mainline Protestant churches.

Trump's so-called spiritual advisor is a prosperity gospel charlatan. The right wing evangelical churches follow the same path - they want a Christian Nationalist state where white men hold all the power.

The pope is a threat.

snowybirdie

(6,713 posts)
15. Childhood catholic upbringing
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 10:09 AM
4 hrs ago

Taught me the Pope is infallible in matters of faith and morals! JD missed that class

Rebl2

(17,819 posts)
19. Isn't he
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 10:32 AM
4 hrs ago

a, you might say, new Catholic? I thought I read the other day he has been Catholic less than ten years.

snowybirdie

(6,713 posts)
21. Yes, was raised
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 10:42 AM
4 hrs ago

A Protestant of some sort. But lord knows how much of that he absorbed as his mom was a drug addicted nurse who stole from her patients.

snowybirdie

(6,713 posts)
23. I read his book
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 10:51 AM
3 hrs ago

Hillbilly Eulogy. Was dismayed how he described his family and how he was raised. He did pull himself up but seems to have many issues. A sad man full of hangups.

dutch777

(5,090 posts)
7. Vance is grasping at straws. He can't get traction anywhere. Failed in Iran negotions, supporting Orban...
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:16 AM
6 hrs ago

at this week's Turning Point convention on and on. The only humiliation left is for Trump to denounce him not just use him as a lap dog. I agree though, how he thinks he gets ahead trashing the pope is beyond me.

Maeve

(43,473 posts)
8. Because he's a lickspittle
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:18 AM
6 hrs ago

AKA, a toady, who believes his way up in the world is by fawning over those richer and/or more powerful than himself.

livetohike

(24,325 posts)
11. Because the puppy follows its Master. This is doing
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:28 AM
6 hrs ago

nothing for his political aspirations. He’s really stupid and sucking up is all he knows what to do.

Ocelot II

(130,800 posts)
12. Because Vance is a cynical opportunist who has crawled up Trump's colon and has to stay there,
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:38 AM
6 hrs ago

because if he wants the Big Job, MAGA will have to accept him as Trump's successor. He doesn't dare oppose or even question Trump's positions on anything, even his own fancy new religion, as to which he has to insist that the Pope is wrong because if he doesn't, he will be tacitly admitting that Trump is wrong. And then Trump will cast him under one of his many buses. Trump can't fire him but he can humiliate him and make his ascension to the Throne of Orange impossible.

MoseShrute

(132 posts)
13. Opus, that's why
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 08:40 AM
6 hrs ago

I just read the book “Opus” by Gareth Gore. He spent years investigating opus dei, the catholic cult. This cult has heavily infested the upper echelons of the US government, from congress to the supreme court. Multiple billionaires and other wealthy elites donate millions to turn this country into a neoconservative branch of the catholic church. Leonard Leo, Fat Tony Scalia, Clarence Thomas, etc etc. Dark money galore is spent to influence congress and sway voters. Pope Francis started cracking down on them, and Pope Leo has also done some things as well. It seems like once you become wealthy you want to take freedoms away from others, even though that same freedom likely played a role in making you obscenely wealthy. My guess is vance is doing damage control for opus since they only like squeaky right wing popes, like The Deuce. I highly recommend reading this book.

Happy Hoosier

(9,553 posts)
17. Because ultimately he doesn't really believe his religion.
Thu Apr 16, 2026, 10:20 AM
4 hrs ago

I'm not saying he is an atheist. But being a Catholic, he should defer to the Pope on spiritual matters. That's what Catholicism is, utltimately... it is a hierarchical organization.

He is Catholic for the trappings, but he does not actually believe the Pope is Christ's Vicar. If he did believe that, he'd think he was endangering his soul.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why is Vance also trashin...