General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsPlatner is fundraising by dissing Democrats
I live no where near Maine, but recently got this text from Platner, and this is the way it began:
Okay, I see primary fundraising texts often that bash their opponent and that's not surprising, but I rarely see one where they bash Democrats as a whole. Why not blame the Republicans who are doing this crap instead of Democrats who are quite limited in what they can accomplish at this moment in time? How does this help Democrats overall?
Not all that long ago we had two newly elected Democrats switch to Republican in my state, so I'm already feeling betrayed by what are apparently Republicans running as Democrats. This text from Platner just strikes me as wrong.
2naSalit
(103,326 posts)Another thing he has no clue about.
He seems to be be either explaining or complaining but never offering ideas about how to change things. I'd be a little more interested if he sounded a little more like AOC who comes to her constituents with ideas and solutions when they tell her what they want. He's not asking us what we want or need from him, he's telling us what he thinks and not much else. He sounds like a cross between sheehy of Montana and fetterman.
He gets the ((((GONG)))) from me.
Reason: Vertical learning curve, not helpful.
displacedvermoter
(4,752 posts)cachukis
(4,012 posts)everyonematters
(4,203 posts)Are you saying that you disagree with that? If not, this is more nit picking.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)That seems pretty obvious.
sop
(18,889 posts)If I recall Democrats in the House voted to impeach Trump twice, and Senate Democrats voted overwhelmingly to remove him. I believe Platner's being disingenuous.
displacedvermoter
(4,752 posts)paleotn
(22,442 posts)Be specific.
Cha
(319,586 posts)opinion.
Dems are Winning and Overperforming All oveer the Country and Flipping red Seats to Blue.
Even in Red States.
Our Dems are Fighitng for us.. Planter is dead wrong.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)In case you haven't been listening.
In some other year, Analilia Mejias 20-point win in New Jerseys 11th Congressional District might have been a stunning result.
But the progressive organizers romp on Thursday elicited little shock, despite the margin in a district former Vice President Kamala Harris had carried by just 8 points.
It is a warning sign for Republicans that has continued to flash across the country every few weeks. Consistent overperformances in special elections have been an indicator of midterm shifts in the past, and the trend over the last 15 months is particularly strong. In the two-year cycle of special elections heading into 2018, margins shifted to the left in about two-thirds of special elections, according to The Downballot. In November of that year, Democrats netted 40 seats.
snip
The overperformance across the country in special election after special election is a trend that cant be ignored and proof that the American people are souring on Republicans broken promises, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee spokesperson Aidan Johnson said in a statement.
https://www.politico.com/news/2026/04/18/democrats-special-election-results-analysis-00879021
Thank you, Cha. They are winning every special election.
Cha
(319,586 posts)I posted this to MorbidButterflyTat in this thread...
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=21183728
It's So Riciculous that Planter is running on an Anti Dem message... Way to build a Coalition.
"..in case you haven't been listening.." ?
TBF
(36,871 posts)Please define "most democrats".
Assuming you mean democratic politicians - what in the world would you like them to do? If you are talking about politicians as a whole that's not going to fly. Lumping all politicians together right now is equating both parties.
You need to understand that democrats are the minority party. They don't control Congress, Executive, or Supreme Court. I can't believe I have to explain this on a democratic party website. As far as what republicans should be doing, that is another matter.
Republicans should be impeaching the President, because they are the ones who have the votes to get it done.
travelingthrulife
(5,355 posts)This guy sounds unrealistic. A sparkly pony. He's gonna do all these things but no realistic approach to how he would get the votes from Republicans.
Ocelot II
(130,842 posts)radical noodle
(10,644 posts)after having so many disappoint.
paleotn
(22,442 posts)She's well known, well respected, and gave Trump the middle finger. Do you remember "I'll see you in court?"
Platner has issues. I'm not sold on whether he's genuine or not. Generally, I'm not a fan of populists. They spew a lot but much of that wilts when exposed to reality.
BComplex
(9,938 posts)nobody really knows him. I've watched all of his interviews that I could find on YouTube, but I still don't feel secure.
Having said that, I really don't think the 80-year-old governor that takes AIPAC money is who we're looking for, either.
I'm ready for a younger congress/senate, and especially a more progressive leadership structure in our party.
bluestarone
(22,310 posts)I would like to see specific questions asked that are about the votes taking place in Congress NOW. How would he vote on the votes like Fetterman? These questions need to be asked and answered publicly.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)Democrats suck but not me. It strikes me as the wrong approach as well, rad.
I have seen part of his platform on his profile page at BSky. He doesn't say how he will help get us out of the mess that tsf and his maggot crew has gotten us in.
However, he said:
-He wants Medicare for all. ( not a bad thing but how is he going to do this...he does not explain.)
-Fire the SCOTUS and require term limits. ( great, though that isn't going to happen either, at least not in my lifetime)
Another thing about him @ BSky, he never once responds to anyone. Not once.
Cha
(319,586 posts)Understand That Dems need to Take BAck the House and the Senate.
Does Planter think he can do all the things he says he wants alone?
Well, he can't.
Thanks, she.
niyad
(133,115 posts)decent people on there? As for term limits? Does he mean for scotus, or everyone? If scotus, does he actually think a constitutional amendment will pass?
And then there are his disgusting comments about sexual assault victims. I would really love to know who the guy behind the curtain is.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)No respect for women raped or gays assaulted sexually.
I don't like him and I sure as hell don't trust him. When you have to apologize every day for something new that has come to light about their past comments and actions then...I will take a pass.
travelingthrulife
(5,355 posts)mcar
(46,173 posts)This is a disaster waiting to happen.
krawhitham
(5,077 posts)BaronChocula
(4,635 posts)I got that text months ago and it was a major red flag. There's been enough revealed about him since that I totally forgot that text was the first thing that turned me off about him - until now.
MaineNative
(98 posts)stuck between a rock and a hard place. The Platner appeal to some stems from his brutal honesty. Hes sharpened his approach but he still makes a thoughtful person squirm. His comments about women, the skull and bones tat, etc., and it gnaws on some that hes from a monied family. On the other side weve got Governor Mills; capable but old.
I cant call this one, I am too cantankerous, lol. Primaries coming soon.
And of course right after posting this a found Hassan speaking with Platner. https://youtube.com/shorts/b13JCO_eeIk?si=AtschzOKQV3X_qpv
paleotn
(22,442 posts)Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)Platner will be the Democratic nominee, and his haters must face that reality.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)His past history has come into light as the news drips out. Every day he seems to have to come out and apologize for his past comments about women and rape, gay men and rape that he found hilarious. Read his Reddit posts, they are revolting. How could anyone forgive that?
mr715
(3,732 posts)sheshe2
(97,914 posts)I don't and we are making a huge mistake if he does win the nomination.
You and I know that Collins is primed and ready to let loose on him. If he gets the nomination I do believe we will lose.
mr715
(3,732 posts)His schtick does not inspire confidence but he is winning, which makes me feel a little bit uncomfortable.
He will destroy Susan Collins - I have no doubt about that.
paleotn
(22,442 posts)When Republican money and op research is done with him, he wont' be able to get elected to anything. Way too much baggage to exploit.
mr715
(3,732 posts)paleotn
(22,442 posts)mr715
(3,732 posts)Want to bet, though?
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)Earlier this year, I frequently posted that Maine could surely do better than Mills or Platner.
No other candidates came forward, and after several months of capacity-filled town halls where Maine voters could ask Platner unscripted question, he is polling far ahead of Mills despite her ads about his past Reddit comments. Surely, almost all Maine voters are now aware of these comments.
So, I am not suggesting that anyone forgive him, but rather to face the reality that he almost certainly will be the next Dem nominee for senate.
Its becoming pretty clear that, despite past personal errors and missteps, populist candidates are defeating centrist candidates handily.
Now imagine what a populist Dem candidate without Platners personal history could do on the national stage- we have already seen a local example with Mamdani.
Cha
(319,586 posts)calling those with different Opinions "haters"; it's only to Distract and Dismiss the Reasons the opposition doesn't agree with them.
TY, she, for calling that out.
paleotn
(22,442 posts)That's nice.
Trying to out do Fetterman perhaps? Or maybe you agree with him? Hmmmm?
https://emilyslist.org/sound-the-alarm/sound-the-alarm-graham-platner-says-sexual-assault-victims-should-take-some-responsibility-in-now-deleted-reddit-posts/
paleotn
(22,442 posts)https://emilyslist.org/sound-the-alarm/sound-the-alarm-graham-platner-says-sexual-assault-victims-should-take-some-responsibility-in-now-deleted-reddit-posts/
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)I will leave it to Maine voters to decide.
paleotn
(22,442 posts)Your words.
LeftInTX
(34,554 posts)Celerity
(54,656 posts)I understand why many here do not like Platner, but those who are 'Never-Platner' should be upset perhaps with the parts of the Democratic power structure, both nationally (in terms of Schumer and Gillibrand going all in on Mills and Mills alone), and then the Maine state Democratic party itself, for also failing to recruit a better candidate than Mills to take on Platner.
I myself preferred Jordan Wood, but he chose to drop out of the US Senate race and run for Maine-02 in the US House after the conservadem Jared Golden (who years ago stopped even bothering to attend Dem caucus House meetings and who had, pretty likely, the worst voting record of any Dem currently in the House IMHO) chose to retire.
That all said, Janet MIlls is, at the end of the day, really looking like (as I predicted before she even announced her Senate run) a poor candidate to take on a Platner-type, ie an insurgent, a non traditional candidate, in the Dem primary, especially in today's political environment, and especially in Maine, which is tricky state to win in.
I laid out why, IMHO, that is so, here, in a reply to another OP:

in the Democratic primary (which is being shown in the polls).
For instance: Mills is pro filibuster, she is anti-decriminalisation for small personal use amounts of drugs, she has been anti red-flag laws for guns, she has vetoed collective bargaining rights (so is anti-union to an impactful degree), she has vetoed wealth taxes, she has vetoed protections for renters, and she has vetoed some tribal sovereignty laws, etc.
All of that is not even taking into account she would be 85yo at the the end of her first term if she were to win both the primary and the general election. She would be the oldest ever newly elected first term US Senator in American history.
If a person is anti-Platner (and that is a valid stance IMHO, given his baggage), then I would think they must be very unhappy with Mills being their only other main choice (and Schumer and Gillibrand helping to make sure she was and is the only other main option, as they pushed hard to recruit her and only her).

paleotn
(22,442 posts)And he has much more baggage. Nazi symbols? Really? Seen his take on sexual assaulting women? When it's all said and done, Mills will win. And win handily. Because I doubt below is the end of opposition research. And where's there's some of this, there's bound to be a lot more. But hey! If you want to vote for someone who thinks "she's partially responsible" , well, you be you.
https://emilyslist.org/sound-the-alarm/sound-the-alarm-graham-platner-says-sexual-assault-victims-should-take-some-responsibility-in-now-deleted-reddit-posts/
https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5801420-maine-governor-mills-ad-sexual-assault/
Celerity
(54,656 posts)floor' with Platner in the Dem primary will come true at all.
I always strive to not allow personal wish projections to come into play when making prediction calculations.
We can both revisit this as time marches onward.
paleotn
(22,442 posts)I guess Dems are generally cool with sexual assault apologists and random racist statements. And what else might be out there? This may be just the tip. But I'm sure the polls are "locked" at this point. OK.
https://emilyslist.org/sound-the-alarm/sound-the-alarm-graham-platner-says-sexual-assault-victims-should-take-some-responsibility-in-now-deleted-reddit-posts/
ShazzieB
(22,716 posts)If I lived in Maine, I honestly don't know who I'd vote for in the primary. Mills is great, but she'd be taking office at the age of 79 and finishing the term at 85. Ar that point, I assume Maine Dems would then have to start all over again with a new candidate, because a second term would take her into her 90s. But the more I hear about Platner, the more problematic he sounds. What a conundrum. 🤔
RandomNumbers
(19,217 posts)(I don't live in Maine so don't know)
that if she doesn't make it through her term, there will be an opportunity to replace her with another Democrat (but not a guy with a Nazi tattoo and past history of dismissing perp responsibility for assault).
If there is a strong risk that she would be replaced with someone even worse than Collins, who couldn't be ousted at the next regular-cycle GE ... then hmmmm
What bothers me about Maine is why the fuck they came to this dilemma in the first place.
But I don't live there so I will let those who do speak.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)Yup, "honesty" where he talks about the Senate and Congress made up of 'elites'. And Graham is just a regular working class, average, hardworking everyday Joe. Strange considering he attended private school (college prep school cost 12.5K a year) comes from a very wealthy family. He is not your average 'working man'.
Cha
(319,586 posts)"elite" talk from? It sounds so Buzz Wordy familiar.
Especially when he himself came from "priviege"
Why not just be honest? People are finding out anyway.. and it looks bad to misrepresent yourself.
sheshe2
(97,914 posts)plays so much better than I am a rich kid.
(Tourism at $95 a person appears to form a significant part of Platners business.)
Graham Platners takeover of an existing oyster business was actually funded by a $20,000 grant from the Stavros Niarchos Foundation, a Greek billionaires nonprofit, and by his mother, Leslie Harlow, a local businesswoman who owns two restaurants and a gift shop in the area.
His best customer happens to be his mom, one description put it. The fact that I get to have a personal and business relationship with my mom, the fact that my mom has a restaurant that I get to sell my products at, its really quite wonderful, Graham Platner said in a video profile.
https://www.danielgreenfield.org/2025/09/how-rich-kid-politician-was-spun-as.html
Cha
(319,586 posts)portray yourself as working class when everything is handed to you.
Thanks for the research, she.
betsuni
(29,152 posts)So they pretend, go around calling themselves New Deal/FDR Democrats. All righty then, FDR was a working class democratic socialist and presidents Carter, Clinton, Obama, and Biden were all swanky rich powerful upper class elite establishment neoliberal-monsters.
betsuni
(29,152 posts)Seems to me all Republicans have to do is pound him with how Medicare for All will raise taxes, abolish private insurance, government takeover and so on.
Cha
(319,586 posts)sheshe2
(97,914 posts)Cha
(319,586 posts)has gotten way out of hand. And, I so appreciate those who are standing up for the actual Reality of what Planter's roots are.
Why not be proud of where he came from...?Being from Wealth didn't scare off voters from FDR and JFK
JI7
(93,755 posts)What he said about blacks, gays etc was honest ?
I understand that is why people like him there and Maine is a largely white state without many non whites and Jews so thai helps .
But I guess it's a difference of views.
ABC123Easy
(330 posts)If he sticks to the narrative that Dems in Federal office currently aren't doing enough. To me that says he wants them to and plans to himself, fight harder.....I'm cool with it. I feel the same way honestly.
Just curious, are any of us on here pleased with the current level of effort from our federal democrat elected officials?
For me I'd say some of them, yes.....many of them, no.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,327 posts)Beware of false prophets. He has shown you who he is. There is something about him that I can put my finger on and oh its Democrats.
ABC123Easy
(330 posts)I don't follow your reply, sorry.
I will say that I am very suspicious of Platner and others like Sweyer in California. I'd hate to see another Sinema or Fetterman.
It was just that the message from the text that was in the post doesn't bother me too much.
Iggo
(49,974 posts)Youre right, Tats. Were not idiots.
AverageOldGuy
(4,000 posts)-- this idiot, and,
-- a 79-yr-old ex-governor?
NO wonder Collins was re-elected time and again.
dsc
(53,416 posts)Omaha Steve
(109,508 posts)biocube
(234 posts)A whole lot of people underestimate how Trump being hated by most of the political class is a selling point. Market yourself as anti-establishment. No reason to kiss up to Democratic leadership when they poll so unfavorability. Maine Democrats can decide who they want.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)I dont think hes going to suddenly bolt for the Republican Party.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)impeachment is done in the House, and there's no way in hell they could get 67 guilty votes in the senate so that's a pie-in-the-sky promise at best.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)Impeachment starts in the house, but, as you know, it ends up in the senate.
My point is, hes not going to flip and become a republican.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)that you can say anything if it isn't even possible in the long run.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)Thankfully, the numbers of Dems calling for accountability for all the corrupt officials in all the branches of government is steadily growing.
MorbidButterflyTat
(4,628 posts)Cirsium
(3,987 posts)If we only advocate for that which is possible there can never be any change.
People called for Abolition long before it was possible.
Autumn
(48,978 posts)betsuni
(29,152 posts)Cha
(319,586 posts)to Take a Majority of Dems in the House and the Senate.. and he's Texing around the Country that Dems aren't fighting for us.
Which is comlete Bull Shitt.
Not only that but Democrats are Winning All over the country. Flipping red Seats Blue, and Overerperforming.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,463 posts)He holds regular town halls that attract capacity crowds, and accepts unscripted questions from the audience.
If the concerns raised in these Platner-bashing threads are shared by Maine voters, I would hope they would use these frequent forums to get their concerns addressed.
MorbidButterflyTat
(4,628 posts)Medicare for all, impeaching SC justices, require term limits.... promises, promises.
How about unicorns, I think I'd like one.
Cha
(319,586 posts)It Also requires all the Dems in House and Senate who are there now and those running in November.
We need the Majority not just some candidate that says they're not "fighting for us" when they are.
So right.. "Talk is Cheap"..
This is real..
'A trend that can't be ignored': Dems have made up ground in nearly every election since Trump took office
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=21183667
Waywardpedestrian
(6 posts)So what? The majority of Democrats need to and must be called out for their actions. Or lack there of.
Cha
(319,586 posts)Not helping magas?
Dems need to Win the House and the Senate Back to Get anything Done.
And, if Dems think Dems aren't Fighting For us in Congress, why are Dems Winning now All Over the Country.. Flipping red Seats to Blue.. and Overperforming in red states and Districts.
niyad
(133,115 posts)How about the lack of action from the party actually IN power? His phony "woking man" schtick?
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)that they are not doing and CAN do?
Welcome to DU, btw.
niyad
(133,115 posts)radical noodle
(10,644 posts)Thanks, niyad.
niyad
(133,115 posts)sheshe2
(97,914 posts)So.
So what? The majority of Democrats need to and must be called out for their actions. Or lack there of..
So, in fact you are giving us permission to call out Platner for his past racist, sexist and homophobic posts!
Good to know, Waywardpedestrian!
Thank you for giving us 'permission' to call out all the wrongs of a Platner run!!!'
Hot dayum!
Oh, BTW....welcome to DU.
Cha
(319,586 posts)sheshe2
(97,914 posts)
Cha
(319,586 posts)Point that OUT!
JI7
(93,755 posts)How do you have a Nazi tattoo and say bigoted things about people and that should be excused but democrsts that are in minority because people like him voted for Collins are the problem ?
betsuni
(29,152 posts)Clever evil elites trying to pull the sheep over our eyes BUT THEY CANNOT!!!!!1
Um, the opposition party is the Republicans.
Cha
(319,586 posts)Maaho for letting him know who the opposition is... he seems to have forgotten along the way.
delisen
(7,398 posts)Pete Stark was the incumbent Democrat. He was honest with his constituents about his religious beliefs. He was an atheist.
Swalwell primaried him and he and his supporters hammered Stark on his vote against the Republican bill to put In God we Trust on our currency.
So the progressive won by attacking the separation of church and state .
With many of the progressive supporters of Platner the hammer against the primary opponent is age.
I want reliable Democratic senators and representatives to build our country on democratic principles. The races I am focusing are in states other than Maine.
Emile
(42,632 posts)BeyondGeography
(41,160 posts)For reasons why, try other sources than this board.
Celerity
(54,656 posts)saying similar things (in multiple ways and with multiple types of vibes, of course, and some far less stridently/confrontationally, of course) for ages about the endless fundraising texts).
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)on Monday, April 6th. Apparently it's the same old same old with him. I was paying zero attention to him and the races in Maine until I got it. I was just offended by the attitude toward Dems. It's a pet peeve of mine that so many people seem to blame Democrats for this crap than the Republicans who are responsible. I don't live there, and I have no intention of funding him.
Celerity
(54,656 posts)radical noodle
(10,644 posts)Easterncedar
(6,380 posts)I like Mills, although she is too ideologically centrist and pragmatic for me. She has been a very effective and creative Governor. She was terrific during the pandemic. She is honest to the core. She works hard.
But I dont think she can beat Collins. The Rs and Independents wont vote for Mills. Some will vote for Platner.
Some of Dems who are going for Platner are making a calculation that he can beat Collins, and some are desperate for a hero narrative they can attach their fantasies to and just want to believe in the guy who rode in out of nowhere. They find him charismatic.
Its a bad situation, but I will vote for Mills in the primary and expect to have to vote for Platner in the general.
Reader Rabbit
(2,760 posts)And that if he's elected, he'll end up being like Fetterman or Sinema.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)Emile
(42,632 posts)is dissing democrats.
Wow
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)I said nothing of the kind.
travelingthrulife
(5,355 posts)Vet your candidates well.
RandySF
(85,129 posts)Emile
(42,632 posts)when he is in the inevitable (problematic) nominee, I wonder what people will post about all day
Cha
(319,586 posts)We're Dems.
Fall in a love and fall in line. We are good Democrats.
Cha
(319,586 posts)AllyCat
(18,911 posts)From anyone after November24
It starts Pedo just did this OUTRAGEOUS thing!!! Donate now to stop him!
Now Im getting crap for TT in Wisconsin.
Im sick of the fundraising when I need to see action. Ill donate to local folks trying to clean up WI but other than that, Im done.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)I live in Florida but get most fundraising texts from other states. And it's annoying that if I do donate to someone, they just pile on, asking for more and more.
Cha
(319,586 posts)Thinking I'm someone named "Jerry" begging me for money all the time over the years... but never had someone running as a Dem, who is unfairly Bashing Dems begging me for money.
Thank You So Much for letting us know about what Planter is doing, rad.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)Makes you wonder how they got you on their list, doesn't it?
Cha
(319,586 posts)Texts? Because I've told them to stop bothering me... I won't be giving any money to you.
radical noodle
(10,644 posts)Cha
(319,586 posts)Rob H.
(5,868 posts)How about Rep. Jared Golden who isnt running for reelection and therefore faces no consequences for his decision voting against the Iran war powers resolution? Were simultaneously being told that Trump is the greatest extant threat to democracy, yet even putting stumbling blocks in his way seems to be too much to ask.
Having limited power isnt the same as having no power.


