General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump wanted the nuclear codes now debunked
Last edited Mon Apr 20, 2026, 10:37 PM - Edit history (2)
According to retired CIA analyst Larry Johnson: During an emergency meeting On Saturday Trump tried to use the nuclear codes on Iran and he was stopped by General Dan Caine.
According to records no meeting happened as claimed. I still believe Trump needs to be in a mental hospital.
Irish_Dem
(81,877 posts)This must be what the temper tantrum was about.
I wonder how the general stopped Trump from accessing the codes?
John1956PA
(5,017 posts)If that is true, it is a big story.
pcdb
(127 posts)There's also a link down-thread debunking this ridiculous story.
Irish_Dem
(81,877 posts)The US military disobeyed a direct order from the Commander in Chief.
This was organized and not just one general who decided to do it.
One general does not make this decision unless it has been discussed and agreed upon in advance by the top generals. US military operate in packs and groups. They rarely go rogue.
2naSalit
(103,358 posts)They kept him out of the sitcom?
RandySF
(85,174 posts)Im not saying Trump eventually push the button. Most likely scenario, I think, would be drop it where the uranium is buried.
2naSalit
(103,358 posts)On my part seems off so I take your point. I wonder how many times he's tried to do this, though... his being prone to temper tantrums and all.
RandySF
(85,174 posts)but I think it's the most likely ending to it.
2naSalit
(103,358 posts)The Cuban missile crisis, in Key West. This feels kind of like that.
wnylib
(26,239 posts)COL Mustard
(8,301 posts)Although the idea of a National sitcom is pretty amusing, only if I laugh not to cry!
2naSalit
(103,358 posts)I thought about it and decided not to sound like I knew much. I could see something like that happening where the adults in the 'room' have to remove him because he's out of line. Never can tell these days.
Irish_Dem
(81,877 posts)There was a very dicy dangerous situation for some US Air Force pilots.
Top brass needed their wits about them to make good decisions.
Then they have a mentally ill POTUS screaming about dropping nukes when they are
trying to save two pilots. I also think Trump got physical, it was more than just a temper
tantrum.
THEY HAD HIM REMOVED FROM THE ROOM.
Please note that this had to be done in coordination with the secret service.
chouchou
(3,201 posts)There's been many movies that have been made, regarding what's left after World Destruction.
Quite frankly, I don't want to be a part of it.
PCIntern
(28,461 posts)chouchou
(3,201 posts)Nikita Khrushchev (If I remember correctly)
AZ8theist
(7,469 posts)EarthFirst
(4,187 posts)Its terrifying that if this information is credible; that its gone all the way to demanding the nuclear launch codes
Its incredibly reassuring that someone is left that told him NO!
orangecrush
(30,681 posts)To hear that conversation
RandySF
(85,174 posts)Nobody has the legal authority to deny order re. nukes.
displacedvermoter
(4,766 posts)Last edited Mon Apr 20, 2026, 08:36 PM - Edit history (1)
obligation, and legal, to question any order to launch nuclear weapons, just like any other order. The requirement in the UCMJ to disobey an unlawful order is that legal authority. How that plays out if this sort of thing -- if true, it is terrifying, I literally got a chill -- happens again, involving different people, it is hard to say.
Tetrachloride
(9,654 posts)by any means necessary
Safe as Milk
(259 posts)It cannot be a purely unilateral decision. It's a group decision.
FakeNoose
(41,965 posts)I don't have a problem with that. Thank goodness someone with sense is in control.
orangecrush
(30,681 posts)If he tried it he'd be hauled out under guard.
Response to RandySF (Reply #5)
RandySF This message was self-deleted by its author.
Sector 001
(335 posts)mobeau69
(12,415 posts)chowder66
(12,368 posts)magicarpet
(18,938 posts)... I'll get the one star, two star, three star, and four star generals to head for the exit doors. Then where will the trump presidency be ? Is Kegsbreath and his squadron of idiot sycophant going to run the show for you ?
SamuelTheThird
(1,205 posts)He doesn't strike one as a trustworthy source (ie he said Russia didn't interfere in Trumps first election)
flvegan
(66,379 posts)How did/does this retired CIA analyst know this? Was he there? What emergency meeting, any reports of that even happening?
ETA: number of Recs to title, that's kind of my thing
displacedvermoter
(4,766 posts)Polybius
(22,001 posts)n/t
demmiblue
(39,845 posts)flvegan
(66,379 posts)Oh, dear.
demmiblue
(39,845 posts)Wait, no Im not.
calimary
(90,327 posts)And the sooner, the better!!!
mr715
(3,736 posts)Doodley
(11,992 posts)mr715
(3,736 posts)Diraven
(1,928 posts)It's part of the top officers' jobs.
Baitball Blogger
(52,514 posts)Last edited Mon Apr 20, 2026, 08:47 PM - Edit history (1)
Once its confirmed every Republican in Congress needs to be interviewed and asked, How about now?
JoseBalow
(9,605 posts)chowder66
(12,368 posts)Did Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, storm out of an emergency meeting after President Donald Trump said he wanted to threaten Iran with nuclear weapons? No, that's not true: There are no credible or verified reports indicating that such an incident ever occurred. While news coverage has documented internal discussions and differing views within the administration over potential military action against Iran, none describe Caine storming out of a meeting or reacting in that manner to a request from the president.
The claim appeared in a post (archived here) by the @JaokooMoses account on X on April 19, 2026. It read:
CONFIRMED: The US joint Chiefs of staff Air Force Gen. Dan Caine stormed out of an emergency meeting with Trump. Insiders indicate that Trump wanted to invoke the nuclear codes as a deterrence against Iran but Caine refused and invoked the U.S. Uniform Code of Military Justice.
This is what the post looked like on X at the time of writing:
more at linky dink....
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/fact-check-caine-did-not-225644148.html
RandySF
(85,174 posts)Again, the president has sole authority to use a nuke. Military personal can only either resign, sit in the brig or guide him away from dropping it too close to a school or something. That's it.
Bottom line:If Trump decides he really wants to do it, there's nothing to stop him.
Qutzupalotl
(15,837 posts)I care whether Trump wanted to nuke Iran.
Figarosmom
(12,502 posts)storm out of the meeting,not did Caine stop trump from trying to use the nuclear codes. Kinda weasely.
radical noodle
(10,653 posts)All I could find is something saying it's false.
demmiblue
(39,845 posts)Beginning in 2007, Johnson emerged as a critic of Barack Obama's 2008 presidential campaign.[1] As a result he was attacked by his former allies on the political left.[1] According to The New York Times, Johnson is "best known for spreading a hoax... in 2008 that Michelle Obama had been videotaped using a slur against Caucasians".[12] On May 16, 2008, Johnson posted an item entitled, "Will Barack Throw Mama From the Train?" which alleged that a tape existed of Michelle Obama "railing against 'whitey' at Jeremiah Wright's church."[13][non-primary source needed] Johnson claimed that Republicans were in possession of the tape and it "is being held for the fall to drop at the appropriate time." In a subsequent post, Johnson claimed that Obama's appearance had occurred when she was on a panel with Louis Farrakhan. He also explained that he himself had not seen the tape, but had spoken with "five separate sources who have spoken directly with people who have seen the tape."[14][non-primary source needed] The Obama campaign's "Fight the Smears" website denied the rumor, saying, "No such tape exists. Michelle Obama has not spoken from the pulpit at Trinity and has not used that word."[15] On October 21, 2008, Johnson said that, according to one of his sources, the McCain campaign "intervened and requested the tape not be used."[16][non-primary source needed]
Allegations that British intelligence wiretapped Donald Trump
In March 2017, Andrew Napolitano said on Fox & Friends that GCHQ, Britain's signals intelligence service, had wiretapped Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign on orders from President Obama.[12][17] Johnson was the source for Napolitano's claim.[12][18] Sean Spicer, President Trump's press secretary, repeated the claim.[12] Fox News later disavowed the statement by Napolitano.[12]
Russia
Johnson defended Russia from allegations that it interfered in the 2016 presidential election.[19] Since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Johnson has made regular appearances on Russian media and expressed support for its war effort. He has been cited hundreds of times in pro-Kremlin Russian media, including Izvestia, Sputnik, and RIA Novosti.[20] In March 2025, Johnson was one of three media personalities invited to interview Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in Moscow.[21]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_C._Johnson
RandySF
(85,174 posts)He ran a blog in the early 2000's called No Quarter. He lost his mind when Obama won the Democratic presidential nomination.
surfered
(13,811 posts)fact-checking as trolling.
AZ8theist
(7,469 posts)mobeau69
(12,415 posts)2na fisherman
(343 posts)Larry Johnson is not a very credible source nor has this story been independently verified by other news outlets. However, it does sound like something Trump would actually do given his declining state of mind. I wonder if anyone has the courage to stop him before he does such a thing. That person must be aware that he or she would be remembered in history as the one who saved the world from doomsday. Ever since Trump got elected, I said to myself, he's gonna' kill us all. And he seems to be getting closer to that point every day.
RandySF
(85,174 posts)Anyone who attempts to contravene a valid, authentic and legal (in the sense of whether the strike package was legal, and all off-the-shelf nuclear strike packages are pre-vetted for legality to some degree) order would be doing so illegally and risk the charge of mutiny. Now, if POTUS ordered a nuclear first strike out of the blue against China or Russia, there would be questions about legality. But if, for example, he ordered a limited nuclear strike against targets in Iran, such as the hardened and buried Fordow enrichment facility, or a complex in North Korea, it would be very difficult to argue that the president did not have the legal right to do that out of the blue if he or she deemed it in Americas national interest.
So how does the president order the launch of nuclear weapons? The procedure, as far as we publicly know, is as follows: If POTUS decided to launch some or all of Americas nuclear weapons, s/he would simply take out the biscuit or authenticator which s/he carries on his/her person at all times, summon the military aide that accompanies POTUS at all times, who connects POTUS directly to the duty officer at the National Military Command Center. Based on an alphanumeric code on the biscuit, POTUS authenticates himself or herself to the duty officer and orders the desired nuclear launch package.
At this point, if the order is deemed to be authentic (did POTUS respond with the correct authenticator) and valid (is the strike package valid?), it is considered a legal order from the commander in chief. The duty officer then transmits the order and strike package directly to Americas nuclear missiles and submarines and bombers to carry out the order and the desired strike package. At no point is anyone else legally, or even practically, in the chain of command for nuclear launch. Anyone the duty officer or a missileer who contravenes or fails to carry out this order would be doing so illegally.
.https://goodauthority.org/news/there-was-no-legal-way-to-stop-trump-from-ordering-a-nuclear-strike-if-he-wanted-to-expert-says/
Smokster
(24 posts)Farmer-Rick
(12,726 posts)But I guess he could get someone to read the code on the biscuit to him.
usonian
(25,912 posts)https://uisjournal.com/why-the-us-used-the-password-00000000-to-launch-nuclear-missiles-for-20-years/
In the 1962, the president John F. Kennedy signed the National Security Action Memorandum 160(available on this page) by ordering the installation of devices called PAL (Permissive Action Link) on all US nuclear weapons. These systems should have prevent launch without proper authorization. In fact, they were small devices that allowed missiles to be launched only using the right code, given with the right authority.
However, SAC considered the idea of such a strict lockdown a risk to its operational capacity. The main objective of the military leaders was to ensure that, in the event of an attack, the missiles could be launched without delays due to complex orders or communication difficulties with the Central Command, especially if the command channels were compromised during a nuclear attack.
1977: the year the password 00000000 was abandoned.
spanone
(141,851 posts)Without that, it's nothing.
videohead5
(2,973 posts)That the whole civilization would die in Iran. There is only one way that could happen. I believe he would try as insane as he is now.
BWdem4life
(3,028 posts)He was just PRETENDING to be completely unhinged as a negotiating tactic!
Botany
(77,568 posts)His fuck up with his unneeded war on the people of Iran, Bibis side show of trying to make Southern
Lebanon part of Israel, the poll #s, his declining health, and the Epstein files must make him feel like his world is declining around him so he sees using nuclear weapons as an out because he is bat shit crazy.
Doodley
(11,992 posts)MaineNative
(100 posts)Thanks to The Dangerous Ones.
https://youtube.com/shorts/ORaAQjhyZyk?si=Nzdj7FblPX_OzI9Y
FakeNoose
(41,965 posts)He can't launch the nukes alone, even though he thinks he can. Thank you General Dan Caine! There will be books and movies about this craziness very soon, I'm sure!
Upthevibe
(10,207 posts)Jedi Guy
(3,485 posts)Trump doesn't need to ask Caine or anyone else for the codes. A military attache is always with him and this person has possession of the "football", which contains all the required info. All he has to do is present his authentication, select his target(s), and give the order. The attache has no power to deny him access as long as he presents the correct credentials.
While plausible in the sense that Trump is dumb and/or crazy enough to seriously consider using nukes unprovoked, it strikes me as odd that this retired CIA analyst doesn't know the control procedures and thinks Trump has to ask the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs to give them to him.
ToxMarz
(2,995 posts)Sounds like the only one to stand in his way is potentially Secretary of Defense (Kegsbreath). There may have been some issue, but by saying 'he wanted the codes" makes the whole story sound fishy (unknowledgeable). There are no codes he needs to be given by anyone.
Quick search says:
The President has the authorization codes, known as "the biscuit," on their person at all times, rather than asking for them. As the sole authority for nuclear use, the President can order a strike without advisor consultation, but they do not physically press a button; they identify themselves via the codes to the Pentagon.
Key Aspects of the Nuclear Command System:
The Biscuit & Football: The president carries a plastic card the "biscuit", with codes to identify themselves, which are used in conjunction with the "nuclear football," a briefcase carried by a military aide containing launch options.
Sole Authority: The President holds the exclusive power to authorize a nuclear strike. There is no legal requirement to consult with the Vice President, Congress, or military advisors, though the Secretary of Defense must confirm the order.
The Chain of Command: While the President authorizes the strike, the order is transmitted through the military chain of command, where officials must ensure the order is lawful, though they cannot legally prevent an authorized strike.
No "Button": The system is designed to verify the identity of the Commander-in-Chief rather than operate via a simple button press.
While some users on Reddit and Quora speculate that the president only holds part of the code or requires a second code from the Secretary of Defense, official information highlights the president's sole authority and possession of the authentication "biscuit".
MorbidButterflyTat
(4,630 posts)why?
johnnyfins
(3,859 posts)orangecrush
(30,681 posts)B.See
(8,604 posts)wanting the codes and SOMEONE at least, having the integrity, wisdom, morality, and COMMON SENSE to tell him no, far more comforting
than I do the notion that absolutely NO one could or would stop him if he did.
If it's the latter then the world is fukd.
progressoid
(53,265 posts)pat_k
(13,516 posts)... and bullshit like the claim that British intelligence spied on Trump for Obama.
Also reportedly a frequent guest on platforms like Russia Today and InfoWars.
I'm not sure how this particular bit of mis/ dis-information fits with previous bullshit.
We've gotta watch out for this shit. Some is quite insidious counter-resistance propaganda designed to appeal to -- and be spread by -- the likes of us. The aim is often to raise a hope of some sort that is dashed when debunked, leaving us more hopeless, or to provide something right-wingnuts can point to and say "what idiots to believe X."
WarGamer
(18,748 posts)sarisataka
(22,716 posts)critical thinking- dead and buried.
WarGamer
(18,748 posts)Smokster
(24 posts)Normally I'd say Mutually Assured Destruction still holds as a policy or should. Nuclear winter is bad for business, global capitalism and billionaires with their fangs in everything globally such as it is. At this point, I'm not so sure about that stance, whether this latest claim is obvious bullshit or not. This latest Trump administration is not the last and is filled with malignant narcissists, psychopaths, and sociopaths with no guardrails. The "limited nuclear war is winnable crowd" have their fangs deeply embedded in this administration. Along with a new generation of young social media influencers and young people who think nuclear war is a video game in which "one side wins." Critical thinking considers the ramifications of such a mindset...
orangecrush
(30,681 posts)Ol Janx Spirit
(1,035 posts)Not for the story that was debunked?
RandySF
(85,174 posts)A POTUS carries it with them at all times. We want to believe life is like the movies but it's not. If he chooses pre-approve strike package that oder has to be followed or face court martial. And yes, I think he'll eventually nuke the uranium site.
EdmondDantes_
(1,961 posts)Just because we don't like Trump that doesn't mean everything bad about him is absolute truth. He sucks from what we factually know without the need for unfounded rumors from a clown like Larry Johnson.
orangecrush
(30,681 posts)We may find out it was not debunked.
Milley stopped him in his first term.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/military/milley-acted-prevent-trump-misusing-nuclear-weapons-war-china-book-n1279187
Javaman
(65,881 posts)until I see proof to the contrary, he asked for them.
MineralMan
(151,430 posts)Anyone who believed it has no understanding of how that stuff works.
John1956PA
(5,017 posts)With a president who, because of personal physical challenges, needs to make several changes of clothing throughout the day, an aide may be in possession of the biscuit during certain intervals.
Cosmocat
(15,447 posts)they didn't want the fuckwit getting any information that he would bullhorn to the entire planet that would put the troops in peril.
Kid Berwyn
(24,723 posts)The record is full of examples where he has asked the military to do his illegal and immoral bidding, from shooting protesters in DC to bombing Iran for Israel.
What matters is that We the People, like the Constitution says, return to giving the Pentagon its orders.
usonian
(25,912 posts)
According to records no meeting happened as claimed.
Everyone with knowledge of the meeting was ....

Still alive? Yes, he was not well-hung.
Initech
(108,966 posts)And he should also have his TV and his social media accounts taken away from him.