Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

luv2fly

(2,699 posts)
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:36 AM 16 hrs ago

Maine Just Delivered a Brutal Wake-Up Call to Democrats. Will It Land?

Thom Hartmann nails it....thank you Thom!

Great article and worth the full read, It was difficult to decide what to include as the four paragraphs so please take a little time to read the full article. Of course it's going to ruffle a certain subset or two of people here, oh well. Thom's right (IMHO as it seems necessary to say these days) and as he notes, Democrats better damn well listen.

--------------

Maine Just Delivered a Brutal Wake-Up Call to Democrats. Will It Land?
Candidates who take on power and promise real real progressive change are the ones voters are rallying behind, because anything less isn’t worth showing up for…
Thom Hartmann
May 01, 2026

Maine just handed Democrats a wake-up call that they’d damn well better actually listen to this time.

Governor Janet Mills suspended her Senate campaign yesterday, leaving Marine veteran and oyster farmer Graham Platner as the presumptive Democratic nominee to take on Republican Senator Susan Collins in November.

The message Maine voters are frankly shouting is the same one I’ve been hearing from listeners on my radio/TV show for years and the same one that pollsters across the spectrum keep picking up across the country: people are sick and tired of mealy-mouthed corporate Democrats who run on focus-grouped slogans and govern like they’re scared of their own shadow. They want fighters.

~ snip ~

The lesson for the DNC, DCCC, the DSCC, and every damn consultant who’s suggested running on an anodyne “don’t make waves” agenda without naming who’s screwing everyday Americans is clear: the New Affordability Agenda isn’t just good policy, it’s also good politics.

~ snip ~

https://hartmannreport.com/p/maine-just-delivered-a-brutal-wake-efb

162 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Maine Just Delivered a Brutal Wake-Up Call to Democrats. Will It Land? (Original Post) luv2fly 16 hrs ago OP
how goes Maine, so goes the nation. nt Javaman 16 hrs ago #1
Up to 1936. Then, it was "as goes Maine, so goes Vermont." DFW 13 hrs ago #45
Remember the Maine, GreenWave 6 hrs ago #128
Yep Aviation Pro 16 hrs ago #2
Her biggest sin is being an older women dsc 16 hrs ago #3
she sure didn't roll over for the likes of Trump or LePage eShirl 15 hrs ago #5
I don't like either her or Platner but yes let's get real JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #6
if we don't live in Maine, we can't do much about it... still if Platner helps give a Dem Senate, I'll take him LymphocyteLover 14 hrs ago #24
I'm thinking he will likely resemble Bernie more than Manchin or Fetterman eShirl 14 hrs ago #44
I hope that this is the outcome. JBTaurus83 13 hrs ago #48
Second that. republianmushroom 5 hrs ago #141
Works for me NewLarry 4 hrs ago #146
I don't see Graham Platner turning centrist. Emile 13 hrs ago #47
I hope so! JBTaurus83 13 hrs ago #49
Feel your pain yankee87 11 hrs ago #72
Understandable. You have good reason. KPN 10 hrs ago #92
Fetterman Mad_Machine76 5 hrs ago #142
And that's OK. We need to stop putting up 79 year olds. It isn't working for us. Scrivener7 15 hrs ago #7
I'm 43 and I feel like I'm out of touch JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #9
Younger people need to vote in greater numbers. Walleye 15 hrs ago #14
It's something I never understand JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #18
Me neither, I guess they think that not voting is making some sort of statement when Walleye 15 hrs ago #21
I think they are just self centered JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #23
Honestly, I see it as an intellectual laziness. It's just too hard. Walleye 14 hrs ago #26
Hence why we have the pig as president. JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #34
Much easier and more gratifying to read Twitter all day than a history book Walleye 13 hrs ago #51
And when you do read history JBTaurus83 13 hrs ago #53
We need mandatory civics classes in high school. SergeStorms 8 hrs ago #119
Are there really school districts where that is NOT the case?? Ursus Rex 6 hrs ago #125
At 43 you still are young. Katinfl 14 hrs ago #27
Thanks, I like that train of thinking lol. JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #35
I think they don't vote -- or didn't in past elections -- as much as they should because they haven't lived long enough KPN 9 hrs ago #101
My son, age 39, NewLarry 4 hrs ago #147
Then offer them something to vote for - TBF 10 hrs ago #85
All they have to do is make a choice. I don't know what they think they're going to get from it, a pony. Walleye 9 hrs ago #99
Whoooooosh .... nt TBF 9 hrs ago #106
What is the point of the " pony " insult? questionseverything 9 hrs ago #108
Bingo. nt TBF 9 hrs ago #112
Not every elderly person is out of touch with the financial difficulties young people face. Bluepinky 10 hrs ago #75
I totally agree, Bluepinky! BComplex 9 hrs ago #100
Right you are! Wish Bernie had been allowed to run! Bluepinky 9 hrs ago #103
Yep or even the changes in the tax code since the early 80s IbogaProject 8 hrs ago #117
I agree; we need younger talent as long as they're equally competent. Callie1979 10 hrs ago #90
We need a mix. quakerboy 9 hrs ago #97
Yes... displacedvermoter 14 hrs ago #28
100% obamanut2012 14 hrs ago #30
Agreed. DFW 13 hrs ago #50
While I don't want another Manchin or Sinema or Fetterman dsc 13 hrs ago #54
That pesky nazi tatoo RoseTrellis 11 hrs ago #68
Her biggest problem is being a corporate Democrat that always loses to Collins. biocube 12 hrs ago #56
She never ran against Collins much less lost to her dsc 11 hrs ago #64
. MorbidButterflyTat 11 hrs ago #66
"..corporate.." Is That WHy "Gov Mills Stood UP Cha 6 hrs ago #123
Sounds like AI mr715 2 hrs ago #158
Not quite Buzz cook 11 hrs ago #69
The state party establishment never learns... the nelm 9 hrs ago #96
Her biggest sin was literally phoning it in while sitting in her den behind a web cam. Hassin Bin Sober 9 hrs ago #94
Hartmann could never bring himself to support HRC. Nothing much has changed. nt pnwmom 9 hrs ago #110
Poeple like that is why we got Traitor & Faxcism Cha 6 hrs ago #122
I might argue "simply being old" A_Woman_from_MI 8 hrs ago #118
Informative article....K & R democrank 16 hrs ago #4
There are a few ideas that never get old JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #10
Hopefully, many Maine voters don't "talk the way" he talks, even if they vote for him displacedvermoter 14 hrs ago #33
"and promise real real progressive change" KS Toronado 15 hrs ago #8
Yes indeed. Magoo48 14 hrs ago #38
Kick dalton99a 15 hrs ago #11
Didnt realize snowybirdie 15 hrs ago #12
"People are sick and tired of mealy-mouthed corporate Democrats who run on focus-grouped slogans sop 15 hrs ago #13
I don't think yelling at our fellow Democrats and calling them. Names is going to work this time. Walleye 15 hrs ago #15
Word BaronChocula 9 hrs ago #98
Then being surprised when Democratic supporters object to the yelling, name-calling, accusations. betsuni 8 hrs ago #113
And, it's not going to help win the Midterms.. All Cha 6 hrs ago #126
Even in private life JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #16
And, I'm sick of Fucking Fascists Running our Cha 6 hrs ago #124
The "New Affordability Agenda" that's a "genuine populist agenda": those are usual Democratic issues, like Harris 2024. betsuni 15 hrs ago #17
Neoliberal is not a left/right descriptor, it is an economic ideology Fiendish Thingy 14 hrs ago #43
"The uselessness of 'neoliberal' as an analytic tool is the very thing that makes it useful as a factional betsuni 10 hrs ago #76
It only documents how the term is used inaccurately Fiendish Thingy 10 hrs ago #86
Neoliberal equals Neoconservative Soul_of_Wit 10 hrs ago #81
False Fiendish Thingy 10 hrs ago #91
Yes MorbidButterflyTat 11 hrs ago #67
So does Susan Collins RoseTrellis 11 hrs ago #71
Yeah, people vote because of Susan Collins' hog. mr715 10 hrs ago #79
I would love for someone to show me how Graham Platner has "taken on power." WhiskeyGrinder 15 hrs ago #19
I think that means strongly worded sentences. betsuni 15 hrs ago #20
He hasn't JBTaurus83 15 hrs ago #22
Voters who support Platner hope he will "take on power." sop 14 hrs ago #36
People should hold off on popping the champagne. JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #42
I think that means he bad mouths Schumer. Nixie 12 hrs ago #57
He spoke truth to power by running, by talking with the people of Maine questionseverything 9 hrs ago #111
Planter needs to "beat" Colins and Stop Trashing Cha 5 hrs ago #138
It is yet to be determined. I remember when Fetterman was the shinny new object that everyone was "fawning" over. lostincalifornia 8 hrs ago #116
I certainly wish we would of known fetterman would be more loyal to Israel than the United States questionseverything 4 hrs ago #152
This message was self-deleted by its author lostincalifornia 2 hrs ago #157
POdcasts? nt Cha 6 hrs ago #129
But does Hartmann JustAnotherGen 14 hrs ago #25
Well we know Platner thinks Black Americans don't tip MorbidButterflyTat 11 hrs ago #65
America is always looking for a hero Keepthesoulalive 10 hrs ago #80
Not in Maine but this is what every Dem voter in my house is saying AllyCat 14 hrs ago #29
Most rank and file Dems know our nation is near collapse JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #37
Yes! We need bamagal62 14 hrs ago #39
Send this to your local party JBTaurus83 14 hrs ago #40
TWS with Jon Stewert did an hour interview with Graham Platner Greyhead 14 hrs ago #31
I was skeptical but this interview turned me into a fan. Listening to him rather than people talking ABOUT him does it. Amaryllis 11 hrs ago #73
Thank you for posting Thom, gab13by13 14 hrs ago #32
Post removed Post removed 9 hrs ago #109
This is a mandatory Progressives angrychair 14 hrs ago #41
I really liked Jasmine Crockett. She spoke very plainly and her speeches were brief. LeftInTX 13 hrs ago #46
I really like her as well JBTaurus83 13 hrs ago #52
As a Texan, do you think she might have won karynnj 10 hrs ago #84
I have heard from Roland Martin that her internal infrastructure was lacking. LeftInTX 9 hrs ago #95
She got gerrymandered in Texas, and it's extremely unfair FakeNoose 9 hrs ago #104
Some math. Maine population is about 1.4 million Nixie 12 hrs ago #55
Bernie has the winning message. usonian 12 hrs ago #58
Republicans sure seem to be scared of him. biocube 11 hrs ago #59
That's why I find it strange that some Dems are still giving him grief Just_Vote_Dem 11 hrs ago #61
Your username checks out Soul_of_Wit 10 hrs ago #87
They are terrified of the next election. You Emile 11 hrs ago #63
I don't think it's progessivism Boo1 11 hrs ago #60
Spot on with that. Smokster 10 hrs ago #77
I've been saying since 2016: we are getting populism whether we want it or not. Better ours than theirs. Hassin Bin Sober 9 hrs ago #102
What has Platner done to instill such unwavering confidence? MorbidButterflyTat 11 hrs ago #62
They'd-damn-better-listen-this-time... Why? betsuni 9 hrs ago #93
Brava, MorbidButterfly! I don't like beinG "Threatened" Cha 5 hrs ago #143
Why would ANYONE think your post is something the rw would advocate? sheshe2 3 hrs ago #155
Mahalo, she.. For more reasons than one! 💙 ☮️🌻🕯️🕊️💜 Cha 3 hrs ago #156
Dems are overperforming all over! 😃 MorbidButterflyTat 1 hr ago #162
Nothing. mr715 2 hrs ago #159
ANyone listen to Jon Stewart's interview with him? THat made me a fan. Amaryllis 11 hrs ago #70
So this guy Platner fought in BUSH/CHENEY phony wars, but not one Nixie 8 hrs ago #114
Wow... Saves All his Bashing fo Dems.. and who is Cha 5 hrs ago #144
Actually he had a lot to say about the Iraq war and none of it was good.Maybe you skipped that part. Amaryllis 2 hrs ago #161
I just learned a scary thing from my Mainiac brother about a Maine congressional race. It seems Vinca 10 hrs ago #74
Egads, that sucks. He's no spring chicken either. He's got to be close to 80. Emile 10 hrs ago #78
Just checked. moose65 7 hrs ago #121
hope he loses as badly as the last time he ran for anything eShirl 10 hrs ago #83
Too Early For This! Aepps22 10 hrs ago #82
Wouldn't this be more appropriate in November as he becomes Senator elect? karynnj 10 hrs ago #88
I agree. But Thom needs to realize that using AI art and AI music is ALSO pro-corporate and sends a highplainsdem 10 hrs ago #89
Completely agree. Joinfortmill 9 hrs ago #105
I still remember Hartmann holding back on support for HRC pnwmom 9 hrs ago #107
Everyone KNEW what the stakes were in 2016, and where was Hartman? We lost the SC because of jackasses like that who lostincalifornia 8 hrs ago #115
Thom Hartmann is a duer. Emile 6 hrs ago #127
He's a public figure, however obscure, and we're discussing Nixie 5 hrs ago #130
Still not cool attacking a duer. Emile 5 hrs ago #131
Thom Hartman is a public figure and the piece he wrote on another Nixie 5 hrs ago #132
He's also a member of our community. Emile 5 hrs ago #133
He's a public figure, and he wrote something critical of Nixie 5 hrs ago #134
Civility Emile 5 hrs ago #135
That works both ways. Nixie 5 hrs ago #136
I see no personal attacks or flaming Emile 5 hrs ago #137
I didn't see it from the poster you targeted either. Just discussing Nixie 5 hrs ago #139
This message was self-deleted by its author Emile 5 hrs ago #140
Yes, "civility works both ways"... Cha 4 hrs ago #148
Good. But his comment was not a DU comment, and even if it lostincalifornia 4 hrs ago #151
I agree. Democrats need candidates who will kick some ass. lees1975 7 hrs ago #120
Post removed Post removed 4 hrs ago #145
We Need to Cha 4 hrs ago #149
I'll take anything I can get. Glaisne 4 hrs ago #153
I did NOT SEE that coming... WarGamer 4 hrs ago #150
Trump campaigned on the affordability issue, Now he claims it is a hoax. Norrrm 3 hrs ago #154
Sorta. mr715 2 hrs ago #160

DFW

(60,367 posts)
45. Up to 1936. Then, it was "as goes Maine, so goes Vermont."
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:23 AM
13 hrs ago

Quite aside from the fact that Maine has voted for the loser plenty of times, in the 1936 election, FDR took every state except Maine and Vermont. FDR’s VP laughed publicly about that, and came up with the alternative “so goes Vermont.”

dsc

(53,432 posts)
3. Her biggest sin is being an older women
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:16 AM
16 hrs ago

let's get real on that. I won't say that was the entirety of the problem but it was a huge part.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
6. I don't like either her or Platner but yes let's get real
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:32 AM
15 hrs ago

She wasn’t landing because she doesn’t meet the moment. She’s against filibuster reform, she was against regulating huge data centers, and yes, most voters prefer to vote for someone who isn’t approaching end of life. People on this site seem to think voters are clawing and begging for candidates between the age of 70-90, the general public is not.

All of that being said, Platner seems really problematic. I believe he will end up being a Manchin or Fetterman, and we will see a lot of buyers remorse here. I hope I’m wrong.

LymphocyteLover

(10,040 posts)
24. if we don't live in Maine, we can't do much about it... still if Platner helps give a Dem Senate, I'll take him
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:21 AM
14 hrs ago

KPN

(17,487 posts)
92. Understandable. You have good reason.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:18 PM
10 hrs ago

Let's hope that Platner is not a Fetterman. Personally, I don't think he is, but what do I know? I live in Oregon. I just refuse to believe that he's playing us all for self-serving purposes -- power and wealth. That's the only reasonable explanation why he might be a Fetterman -- but I just don't see him as just another power-seeker.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
9. I'm 43 and I feel like I'm out of touch
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:40 AM
15 hrs ago

Or not educated enough on many issues. It strains credulity to believe someone who is almost 80 understands how badly young people today are struggling or what the effects of technology and AI are on the future. Before anyone says it; I also apply this to Bernie and others. Everything has its season, and some of these people would be better off as advisors than remaining in office for their entire lives.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
18. It's something I never understand
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:10 AM
15 hrs ago

When I was young I was so idealistic and I wanted to vote on anything possible. Low turnout out in that demographic is nothing new, I just don’t understand it.

Walleye

(45,264 posts)
21. Me neither, I guess they think that not voting is making some sort of statement when
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:16 AM
15 hrs ago

They are entirely wrong. Nobody cares if they don’t vote nobody notices.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
23. I think they are just self centered
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:21 AM
14 hrs ago

They are trying to create a life and career for themselves, so it’s easy to say “they all suck” to absolve themselves from responsibility. I don’t know if there is a way to break through that or if it’s just a part of our life journeys.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
34. Hence why we have the pig as president.
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:38 AM
14 hrs ago

We have a lot of lazy, and frankly stupid people.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
53. And when you do read history
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:57 AM
13 hrs ago

You realize all of this is nothing new. You also will understand why the Pope speaking out is so important. There is nothing new under the sun, but at the same time, we are living in an extraordinary time.

SergeStorms

(20,757 posts)
119. We need mandatory civics classes in high school.
Mon May 4, 2026, 03:17 PM
8 hrs ago

Just one term, it doesn't need to be belabored, but young people need to be more prepared for their civic duties as citizens of the United States. Just my two cents.

Ursus Rex

(494 posts)
125. Are there really school districts where that is NOT the case??
Mon May 4, 2026, 04:48 PM
6 hrs ago

I grew in and near Mobile (deepest-red South Alabama), and I took at least 3 Civics classes before I graduated. Are schools really just not teaching Government/Civics/etc anymore? I agree that it certainly feels that way, but with mandated standard testing, maybe there's teaching ti the test and then it's forgotten.

KPN

(17,487 posts)
101. I think they don't vote -- or didn't in past elections -- as much as they should because they haven't lived long enough
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:35 PM
9 hrs ago

to take elections seriously. Everything in their life is comparatively new and comparatively exciting. They are immersed in new experience and gobbling it up, having the time of their life. Elections are not what energize them because they are distracted with too many other exciting things to pay much attention to politics. And at that point in life, especially in the 18-21, maybe even into their 25 or 26 years, they haven't directly felt the weight of disadvantages on their own personal lives. Hell, when I was that young, I could live on $50-60 a week without feeling stressed or even uncomfortable. I was resilient, adventurous and starry-eyed. Why would I waste good time worrying about politics?

But things have definitely changed today. We are seeing more young people voting. Because it does more immediately affect them today. Nothing gets attention better than direct impact and harm. That's happening to them today. And things aren't getting better so I'm sure the numbers of young voters will continue to grow -- more than we might expect even.

So, I'm pretty optimistic about our younger people going forward.



NewLarry

(168 posts)
147. My son, age 39,
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:29 PM
4 hrs ago

is convinced that since his individual vote won't change the outcome of a presidential election, he's not voting.

I have failed as a parent. Although my daughter, 45, is a real hellion.

TBF

(37,057 posts)
85. Then offer them something to vote for -
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:07 PM
10 hrs ago

this isn't difficult. I'm older now too - gen X - my volunteer work for Obama led me to this website.

I have gen z kids and I can tell you what they are saying. They want progressive candidates, someone like Mamdani gets them excited. They're not going to vote for anyone helping Israel - it's a hot button issue for them. And they can't afford anything right now, so as Clinton said back in the 90s "It's the economy, stupid". Whoever is running for office right now should be laser focused on making this country livable for non-billionaires again.

Walleye

(45,264 posts)
99. All they have to do is make a choice. I don't know what they think they're going to get from it, a pony.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:31 PM
9 hrs ago

It’s a secret vote. Nobody’s gonna know. They’ll still be cool.

questionseverything

(11,919 posts)
108. What is the point of the " pony " insult?
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:52 PM
9 hrs ago

Was social security a pony, was ending the draft a pony, is wanting healthcare for all a fucking pony?

I don’t understand why you are trying to drive off democratic supporters?

Bluepinky

(2,567 posts)
75. Not every elderly person is out of touch with the financial difficulties young people face.
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:26 PM
10 hrs ago

Bernie has been highlighting this issue for years, and he’s very outspoken about the dangers of AI.
Also, he probably would have beaten Trump in the 2016 Presidential election, had his campaign been allowed to continue.
It’s not their age that makes a person out of touch, it’s their mindset.

BComplex

(9,947 posts)
100. I totally agree, Bluepinky!
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:33 PM
9 hrs ago

Bernie Sanders is a national treasure, and he is endorsing Graham Platner. I've been listening to Graham Platner's YouTube videos and interviews, and I get why Bernie believes in him.

Bernie should have been able to run against trump the first time, but the SAME democratic party that he has always supported, did everything they could to NOT support him in that election.

Hence, here we are.

IbogaProject

(6,032 posts)
117. Yep or even the changes in the tax code since the early 80s
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:56 PM
8 hrs ago

FICA taxes didn't hit as hard back before the Reagan tax "reform" after 1982. It all comes down to needing to get more money into the local economy and to remove barriers to getting health care. But Citizen's United has moved our national candidates to the right as much as the GOP has moved further right. We are still not as bad but that isn't going to get strong voter turnouts.

Callie1979

(1,391 posts)
90. I agree; we need younger talent as long as they're equally competent.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:13 PM
10 hrs ago

Congress & the Senate have gotten older & older for the past several years. We've had several examples of outright inability to perform the duties of the office but they dont resign.

quakerboy

(14,903 posts)
97. We need a mix.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:27 PM
9 hrs ago

We need all of us represented.

Older folks are a key voting demographic.
So are middle of life folks.
And young folks.

We should be working to make sure that all are represented among our ranks. Turning 70 doesn't disqualify one from being a public servant. Neither does being 25. or 45. We should have Elected Democrats who can speak to and from EVERY group imaginable.

Honestly, im far more bothered by the wealth of our federal representatives than I am by their ages.

DFW

(60,367 posts)
50. Agreed.
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:37 AM
13 hrs ago

She also suffered from distortion of her actions and positionso. At B one point it was popular to say that she either neglected or brushed off Maine’s Native American tribes. I asked her about that point blank. She said that the ones that made the most noise and complained loudest were NOT looking to improve the status of their people as a whole, but were looking for financial perks for already wealthy casino owners. When they didn’t get everything they wanted, THEN they whined that Janet wasn’t looking out for the tribes. “Corporate Democrats,” my ass. Just because they didn’t have Italian last names, it didn’t mean there was no mafia-like structure that in the tribal casino ownership.

But that's all water under the bridge now. We are all still allowed to hope for a pleasant surprise from Platner. It’s also up to him to deliver or not. Yelling “corporate” all the time will change exactly nothing and conbince exactly no one.

dsc

(53,432 posts)
54. While I don't want another Manchin or Sinema or Fetterman
Mon May 4, 2026, 10:14 AM
13 hrs ago

my biggest worry is he can't win. He literally called rural people stupid in the most rural state in the nation. It will be deplorables on steroids.

RoseTrellis

(192 posts)
68. That pesky nazi tatoo
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:59 AM
11 hrs ago

I think his nazi tattoo might be a bigger problem for Ds. Of course this may actually garner him some republican votes!

Cha

(320,199 posts)
123. "..corporate.." Is That WHy "Gov Mills Stood UP
Mon May 4, 2026, 04:40 PM
6 hrs ago

to Traitor over Transgender Rights".

That buzzword "corporate " doesn't work here.

Buzz cook

(2,912 posts)
69. Not quite
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:59 AM
11 hrs ago

Janet Mills main problem was being a stop gap solution to the perceived problems with Platner.
As usual Democratic leadership panicked and fell back on the "favorite son" idea for a candidate.
So Mills was the anti Platner. As such she had to attack Platner from the right and she couldn't develop a meaningful platform beyond, I'm experienced, I'm moderate, and I'm not him.

Mills was forced into a role that was never going to win. She had to cede the left to Platner and he ran with it. If we're lucky he'll run right into the senate with it.

This whole problem is caused by the Democratic leadership's love of centrists and fear of criticism.
They should have read the tea leaves and seen that there was a leftist backlash growing. They could have been grooming populist Democrats to run against Collins going back several election cycles.
Instead they get surprised by Platner and fumble.

the nelm

(285 posts)
96. The state party establishment never learns...
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:25 PM
9 hrs ago

Anyone else remember Joe Brennan? There was never anything in particular to complain about with the guy and he, by all accounts, performed his job(s) well, but there comes a time to pass on the torch. With him, the state party establishment kept insisting on supporting him election cycle after election cycle for one elected position or another ad nauseum for years.

Hassin Bin Sober

(27,489 posts)
94. Her biggest sin was literally phoning it in while sitting in her den behind a web cam.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:22 PM
9 hrs ago

Showing obvious contempt for questions during a “phoned in” town hall didn’t help her case either.

pnwmom

(110,316 posts)
110. Hartmann could never bring himself to support HRC. Nothing much has changed. nt
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:55 PM
9 hrs ago

Cha

(320,199 posts)
122. Poeple like that is why we got Traitor & Faxcism
Mon May 4, 2026, 04:32 PM
6 hrs ago

the first time

Nothing for Hartman to be proud of.

A_Woman_from_MI

(192 posts)
118. I might argue "simply being old"
Mon May 4, 2026, 03:09 PM
8 hrs ago

People are looking for some new, and yes, younger leaders. Schumer is not the guy to excite/rally the voters we need right now.

democrank

(12,662 posts)
4. Informative article....K & R
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:18 AM
16 hrs ago

One of the most important takeaways from this article was “talk the way they talk” with regards to messaging. Speak to voters like they do in their normal conversations. Enough already with the Washington-based consultant-speak. “Food insecure” is hungry.

Most every time I speak with a farmer, logger, school teacher, business owner, truck driver, nurse, carpenter, college student, I hear the same basic complaint. Congress is out of touch, too far removed from the average person.

In my view, elected leaders need fresh ideas, new approaches, more town halls and a gargantuan shot of courage.



JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
10. There are a few ideas that never get old
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:53 AM
15 hrs ago

People like to eat, people like to have housing, and people like having some leisure time and money. It really shouldn’t be that difficult to talk about.

displacedvermoter

(4,889 posts)
33. Hopefully, many Maine voters don't "talk the way" he talks, even if they vote for him
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:34 AM
14 hrs ago

Again, let us get Joe Rogan -- apparently a Texas resident -- to run for something as a Democrat and he will likely win, and every nasty thing he says won't matter, because he certainly talks like "the average person".

KS Toronado

(23,774 posts)
8. "and promise real real progressive change"
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:38 AM
15 hrs ago

About time our party starts following what Bernie Sanders has been saying for years.

snowybirdie

(6,733 posts)
12. Didnt realize
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:54 AM
15 hrs ago

she is 78 years old! Of course voters should reject her. Way too long in the tooth to begin a career in the Senate! As an old friend used to say, what the hell is wrong with her? And I'm older than her

sop

(19,121 posts)
13. "People are sick and tired of mealy-mouthed corporate Democrats who run on focus-grouped slogans
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:59 AM
15 hrs ago

and govern like they’re scared of their own shadow. They want fighters." - Thom Hartmann

Couldn't agree more.

Walleye

(45,264 posts)
15. I don't think yelling at our fellow Democrats and calling them. Names is going to work this time.
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:03 AM
15 hrs ago

BaronChocula

(4,690 posts)
98. Word
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:29 PM
9 hrs ago

Thom Hartmann is host of a progressive show. As much as I wish every congressional district was a progressive-leaning one, they are not. But let him think members of the Squad could run competitively everywhere. And while I don't always like to listen to moderates, I defer to them knowing their constituents better than I do.

betsuni

(29,226 posts)
113. Then being surprised when Democratic supporters object to the yelling, name-calling, accusations.
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:21 PM
8 hrs ago

More yelling: "It's constructive criticism!" Demanding, "Why do you think Democrats are perfect?" followed by a personal insult.

Cha

(320,199 posts)
126. And, it's not going to help win the Midterms.. All
Mon May 4, 2026, 04:50 PM
6 hrs ago

over America.

We've seen this very bad movie before.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
16. Even in private life
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:04 AM
15 hrs ago

I hate dealing with people who don’t speak clearly. Everything doesn’t need to be dumbed down and simple, but, you should be able to understand what someone stands for clearly when you go to the voting box.

I think it’s the same as an interview for a job. If you don’t have a clear “why”, and a plan of implementation that can be drilled down to a simple message, people aren’t going to spend their time to find out the details.

Cha

(320,199 posts)
124. And, I'm sick of Fucking Fascists Running our
Mon May 4, 2026, 04:47 PM
6 hrs ago

country and Planet into the ground.

We have to win the MIDTERMS.

We have plenty of Dems fighting for us.. It's Not just Maine that needs to win.

betsuni

(29,226 posts)
17. The "New Affordability Agenda" that's a "genuine populist agenda": those are usual Democratic issues, like Harris 2024.
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:09 AM
15 hrs ago

Harris' plan was $25,000 for first-time homeowners, New Affordability Agenda's is $20,000.

Cheaper food and groceries. Ban corporate price gouging.
Raise minimum wage.
Paid family leave, medical leave.
Expand child tax credit.
Extend $35 cap on insulin.
Medicare covering in-home health care.
Minimum tax on billionaires.
Campaign finance reform.
Help small businesses, end four-year college degree requirements for some federal jobs, double # of apprenticeships.
and much more.

Both sides are not the same at all. Neoliberal as an insult for Democrats, all the other name-calling. The Democratic Party is not the enemy, Republicans are. It's the 21st century.

Fiendish Thingy

(23,812 posts)
43. Neoliberal is not a left/right descriptor, it is an economic ideology
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:07 AM
14 hrs ago

Reaganomics was neoliberal, and adopted in some form by both Bushes. Clinton, and to a lesser degree, Obama diluted and repackaged it.

Biden was the first Keynesian president since LBJ, and we all saw how vigorously the oligarchs rebelled against his BBB agenda, getting their Neoliberal saboteurs on the Problem Solvers caucus to gut the bill after promising not to in order to pass the infrastructure bill and avert a shutdown.

The items on your list are classic Keynesian remedies for economic suffering and inequality.

We must ensure that those who campaign on populist, Keynesian policies follow through and sponsor bills consistent with their Affordability Agenda philosophies, and prevent bipartisan saboteurs from substituting the more oligarch-friendly Neoliberal “Abundance Agenda” Trojan Horse. The Abundance Agenda claims to cut red tape to expedite development of housing, manufacturing, etc. creating good paying jobs in the process, but it’s actually a smokescreen for gutting environmental regulations, building codes and labor laws so that developers can maximize their profits.

https://kayuma.substack.com/p/the-abundance-delusion-how-silicon

Trump, on the other hand, is simply a demented Protectionist.

betsuni

(29,226 posts)
76. "The uselessness of 'neoliberal' as an analytic tool is the very thing that makes it useful as a factional
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:29 PM
10 hrs ago

messaging devise for the left. The 'neoliberalism' rubric implicates the Democratic Party in the rightward drift of American politics that has in reality been caused by the Republican Party's growing radicalism. It yolks the two parties together into a capitalist Establishment, against which socialism offers the only clear alternative.

"By relabeling self-identified liberals as 'neoliberals,' their critics on the left accuse them of betraying the historical liberal cause. ... Its basic claim is that from the New Deal through the Great Society the Democratic Party espoused a set of values defined by, or at the very least consistent with, social democracy or socialism. Then, starting in the 1970s a coterie of neoliberal elites hijacked the party and redirected its course toward a brand of social liberalism targeted to elites and hostile to the interests of the poor and the working class. The first and most obvious problem with this version of history is that there is little reason to believe that the Democratic Party has actually moved right on economic issues. ... This chart indicates that the Democrats have not moved right since the New Deal era at all.

"Democrats ... have never been a left-wing labor-dominated socialist party. (Union membership peaked in 1955, two decades before the party's supposed neoliberal turn ... [and working class whites began leaving the Democratic Party during the '60s, also before the supposed Democratic neoliberal turn].) The widespread notion that 'neoliberals' have captured the modern Democratic Party and broken from its historical mission plays upon nostalgia for a long gone era, when the real thing was messier and more compromised... . ... But it is the political climate that has grown more hostile to Democratic Party economic liberalism. The party's ideological orientation has barely changed."

It's "an attempt to win an argument with an epithet"

http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/07/how-neoliberalism-became-the-lefts-favorite-insult

Fiendish Thingy

(23,812 posts)
86. It only documents how the term is used inaccurately
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:08 PM
10 hrs ago

Until Biden was elected, neoliberal economics had inserted itself to some degree into every administration from Reagan through Obama.

The use of Neoliberal as a catchall, broad brush epithet to smear Democrats who don’t pass the progressive purity test does a disservice to legitimate criticisms of neoliberal economic policies as well as undermining progressives’ own efforts to convey their alternative (IMO better) vision for America.

PUBLIC NOTICE: when you see me use the term Neoliberal in a post, it will always be as a descriptor of economic policy, and not a broader definer of left/right politics.

Soul_of_Wit

(129 posts)
81. Neoliberal equals Neoconservative
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:54 PM
10 hrs ago

The right wanted to make "liberal" a curse word, so they couldn't call themselves neoliberal. My ranking of presidents in my lifetime is: 1. Biden 2. LBJ 3. Obama. My biggest issue with Obama was his failure to create a constitutional crisis when they stole an Extreme Court pick from him.

Fiendish Thingy

(23,812 posts)
91. False
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:13 PM
10 hrs ago

Neoliberalism is an economic ideology, embraced by both Republicans (Reagan) and Democrats (Clinton)

Neoconservatism is an ideology primarily concerned with foreign policy and the wielding of state power internationally, including militarily. GW Bush and his administration were the best known proponents of.

The two terms do not exist on the same political continuum.

RoseTrellis

(192 posts)
71. So does Susan Collins
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:02 PM
11 hrs ago

It’s a sad day when this excuse is used to describe how D candidate can’t win against another woman R candidate…

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
22. He hasn't
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:17 AM
15 hrs ago

It shows the weakness of our party in messaging and candidates. Realistically, he should not be in the US Senate, and Dump should have never been elected twice. When clowns have taken over the show, it’s a good time for some self reflection as a party.

sop

(19,121 posts)
36. Voters who support Platner hope he will "take on power."
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:42 AM
14 hrs ago

So far it's only a promise, voters' hopes have been dashed in the past.

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
57. I think that means he bad mouths Schumer.
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:13 AM
12 hrs ago

Although none of them acknowledge Democrats were put in the minority because of election results, everything is Schumer’s fault. And corporations.

questionseverything

(11,919 posts)
111. He spoke truth to power by running, by talking with the people of Maine
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:01 PM
9 hrs ago

And he has beaten mills and schumer so far, so good start

Cha

(320,199 posts)
138. Planter needs to "beat" Colins and Stop Trashing
Mon May 4, 2026, 05:34 PM
5 hrs ago

Dems.

Maine isn't the only seat we need to win. We Need to Win the Midterms. He's NOT going to fight Fascism alone.

lostincalifornia

(5,484 posts)
116. It is yet to be determined. I remember when Fetterman was the shinny new object that everyone was "fawning" over.
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:44 PM
8 hrs ago

Connor Lamb was just an establishment Democrat.

Whether Platner delivers or not, that remains to be seen, but I have always been skeptical of populists.

questionseverything

(11,919 posts)
152. I certainly wish we would of known fetterman would be more loyal to Israel than the United States
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:11 PM
4 hrs ago

That’s my biggest problem with him

Response to questionseverything (Reply #152)

JustAnotherGen

(38,088 posts)
25. But does Hartmann
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:23 AM
14 hrs ago

Have any thoughts about the deliberate, malicious, evil theft of the franchise from Black Americans?

Because honestly? Just me?

Fuck the USA! This is a shit ass country - always has been always will be.

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,703 posts)
65. Well we know Platner thinks Black Americans don't tip
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:52 AM
11 hrs ago

But he's truly very sorry for having been caught saying so.

I'm sorry that so many people think this is what America should be.

Keepthesoulalive

(2,362 posts)
80. America is always looking for a hero
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:43 PM
10 hrs ago

John Wayne is dead perhaps everyday Americans should try to be the heroes we seek. Work the primaries, go to the meetings, vet the candidates based on performance, stop listening to bullshit influencers and make your vote count for everyone not just your immediate needs. I am tired of fighting people in this party who feel my needs are not important and only what white men feel matters. How did that work in the last election?

AllyCat

(18,957 posts)
29. Not in Maine but this is what every Dem voter in my house is saying
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:28 AM
14 hrs ago

We want “bomb throwers” not “milquetoast”.

People need a clear reason to vote FOR a candidate, not “hey! We’re better than that because we, like, care something something”.

PLANS to make our country better.

And as much as I hate to say it, PLANS to rein in Russia and Israel.

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
37. Most rank and file Dems know our nation is near collapse
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:44 AM
14 hrs ago

So of course we all want bomb throwers. Any candidate who doesn’t understand that shouldn’t even be a candidate.

bamagal62

(4,531 posts)
39. Yes! We need
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:54 AM
14 hrs ago

To call out the deep corruption. And, we need to not only do it in speeches, we need to go door to door. Talk to people.
But, I also think there ought to be some sort of training to give those people on the ground a road map of sorts of how to approach and talk to strangers. Just telling people to go door to door won’t work. Not everyone is skilled at things like that. And, republicans have made us hate each other. We have to find a way to speak in a way that softens that barrier to open up listening. Teaching volunteers how to approach that would be a great thing. (I am an introvert and would be terrified going door to door. If someone gave me the skills to do it, maybe I wouldn’t be so apprehensive about it.) just a thought.

Greyhead

(171 posts)
31. TWS with Jon Stewert did an hour interview with Graham Platner
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:31 AM
14 hrs ago
&t=2062s

Very interesting interview. IMO this what the Democrats need to be, more progressive. Graham makes a lot of really good points.
Listen and I think anybody that was on the fence about Graham will become a follower.

Amaryllis

(11,384 posts)
73. I was skeptical but this interview turned me into a fan. Listening to him rather than people talking ABOUT him does it.
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:11 PM
11 hrs ago

gab13by13

(32,609 posts)
32. Thank you for posting Thom,
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:33 AM
14 hrs ago

He is always ahead of the curve and a truth teller.

One of Democrats' biggest enemy is Democrats, we do circular firing squads. Cornell Belcher may be the best political consultant in the business but when I see him on TV I turn the station.

Throwing money at the election is needed but getting out in the streets is more important. Go to Indivisible rallies, walk the picket lines, get arrested trying to get into concentration camps, the politics will take care of itself when people see Congressional Democrats fighting.

I do not espouse to the Schumer strategy that Krasnov will burn it all down and then Democrats will win. We need to fight to stop him from burning it all down.

It will never happen but I wish that Democrats would nominate a non-politician for president in 2028, someone who moderates can't bitch about, someone who progressives can't bitch about. Nominate a fighter who the voters know will hold Magats accountable for what they did to us.

Miles Taylor - 2028
Malcolm Nance - 2028

Do you see where I am going?

Response to gab13by13 (Reply #32)

angrychair

(12,436 posts)
41. This is a mandatory Progressives
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:59 AM
14 hrs ago

This is the rise of the progressive agenda.

Universal healthcare
Universal childcare
Universal education
No more genocide. Here or anywhere else in the world. (No more immigration concentration camps and no more genocide in Palestine and Lebanon)
Abolish (frozen water) (ie tear it completely down and put its function elsewhere with actual checks and balances and accountability)
Less bombs, more education.

This is the will of people.

LeftInTX

(34,756 posts)
46. I really liked Jasmine Crockett. She spoke very plainly and her speeches were brief.
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:23 AM
13 hrs ago

She got directly to the point.

Her opponent gave eloquent, detailed speeches and he won the primary.

Oh what a conundrum!

JBTaurus83

(1,614 posts)
52. I really like her as well
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:54 AM
13 hrs ago

You make a good point. I think Dems in TX perceived her race to be an insurmountable problem. I do think Talarico was very to the point, but there is a big conversation to be had here.

karynnj

(61,071 posts)
84. As a Texan, do you think she might have won
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:58 PM
10 hrs ago

if she had entered the primary several months earlier? ( Asking as I read that that was a factor in some articles.) Did Harris's endorsement come to late to start any momentum? Was it that Texas Democrats had two exceptional candidates?




LeftInTX

(34,756 posts)
95. I have heard from Roland Martin that her internal infrastructure was lacking.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:23 PM
9 hrs ago

Externally, she had tons of signs, blockwalkers etc.

Of course, you had the neighsayers about her being black, but I didn't see that as an issue. With Jasmine, what you see is what you get. Yeah, they could depict her as a welfare queen, voodoo, defund the police, white person hater etc, but those are old, transparent tropes. Voters are more likely to see through those.

Look what they did to John Kerry? He was a white, decorated veteran. What could go wrong?

With Talarico, everyone was saying his religion was an asset, but I knew the GOP would use it to "swiftboat" him and they did as soon as he won the primary, they branded him as a satanic cult member etc..."He's no Christian, he's pro-abortion" etc etc etc...

FakeNoose

(42,117 posts)
104. She got gerrymandered in Texas, and it's extremely unfair
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:45 PM
9 hrs ago

I hope Jasmine Crockett doesn't give up on politics, but maybe she'll find a new constituency in state government?
I hope so.

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
55. Some math. Maine population is about 1.4 million
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:04 AM
12 hrs ago

About 800,000 of that population even vote

A little over 400,000 of those voted Democratic

Whatever those numbers mean, I wouldn’t consider that a knockout punch or however he worded this.*

It seems Collins would have an easy attack on Platner since he voted for her. But she’s getting to be one of those unwanted older women (sarcasm), so she should be easy for him to banish.

*Mills fought Trump right to his face.

usonian

(26,269 posts)
58. Bernie has the winning message.
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:14 AM
12 hrs ago
Bernie has the winning message.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=21217873

(enjoy the graphics there)

How did Graham win? Email from Bernie Sanders
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100221212664


TLDR:
Graham Platner won because his campaign was centered on taking on oligarchy and fighting for the working people of Maine and the U.S.

biocube

(249 posts)
59. Republicans sure seem to be scared of him.
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:20 AM
11 hrs ago
https://www.semafor.com/article/04/30/2026/republicans-plan-all-out-assault-on-platners-candidacy-in-maine

That seems like a lot of money for a state as small as Maine. Guarantee you they don't spend that much to defeat Mills.

Just_Vote_Dem

(3,667 posts)
61. That's why I find it strange that some Dems are still giving him grief
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:30 AM
11 hrs ago

I wanted Mills in the beginning because I wasn't happy with some of the things Platner said in the past, but now that it looks like he's the Democratic candidate I'm all for him defeating Collins

Emile

(43,013 posts)
63. They are terrified of the next election. You
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:43 AM
11 hrs ago

wouldn't believe how much they are spending on advertising for Republicans in the very red state of Indiana.

Boo1

(436 posts)
60. I don't think it's progessivism
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:24 AM
11 hrs ago

winning in ME, I think it's populism. There is a difference.

In an era where everything is expensive, AI is threatening jobs, and the rich just keep getting ahead by pushing everyone else down.....it really makes a lot of sense that populism is...popular.

I really don't like populism, but if it's going to happen I'll much prefer the left-wing type over the right-wing type.

Smokster

(65 posts)
77. Spot on with that.
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:32 PM
10 hrs ago

There's a big difference. Huey Long was an asshole but as a left-wing economic populist he was to the left of progressives, FDR, and the New Deal. In the grand scheme of left-wing history, progressives are actually moderates when it comes to economics and challenging the foundations of capitalist wealth transfer. Even with that, the progressive movement of today resembles nothing close to its past. "Winning" the culture wars, endless political demands, and marginality politics are meaningless drivel detached from real economic demands. Today's progressives love to tinker around the edges on economics and call it "progress." To do that tinkering, wealthy progressives have to unleash a huge dose of authoritarianism on the working class and the poor. People see that and they reject it. And progressives will be the first in line to label Long a fascist, an authoritarian, and declare class war a dead relic of the past. Class war is the only war. Everything else is noise to distract from that fact.

Hassin Bin Sober

(27,489 posts)
102. I've been saying since 2016: we are getting populism whether we want it or not. Better ours than theirs.
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:41 PM
9 hrs ago

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,703 posts)
62. What has Platner done to instill such unwavering confidence?
Mon May 4, 2026, 11:40 AM
11 hrs ago

He talks. Talk is cheap. If he knew how government works he'd know he can't do anything by himself except make noise.

If one person could do it alone wouldn't we all have ponies by now?

"Maine just handed Democrats a wake-up call that they’d damn well better actually listen to this time."

Or what? They won't vote? They'll vote MAGA to teach Dems a lesson? They'll post nasty paragraphs on their substacks?

Personally, I don't appreciate being threatened.

Where's the tough talk for Piggy and the MAGAts???

betsuni

(29,226 posts)
93. They'd-damn-better-listen-this-time... Why?
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:20 PM
9 hrs ago

There's envy that the Republican Party has been taken over the way it's hoped the Democratic Party will be taken over but no luck. The revolution is not happening. It makes a person cranky.

Cha

(320,199 posts)
143. Brava, MorbidButterfly! I don't like beinG "Threatened"
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:12 PM
5 hrs ago

either.

That's the Key to this whole Show.. Maine isn't the Only Seat We Need to win for the midterms. Try the Whole country.

We have been winning and overperforming in the State Elections.. Flipping red seats to Blue. Hartman might want to check that out.

We've been down this ugly road before, in 2010 when the "dems" stayed home to "teach Pres Obama a lesson".

When the "Dems" in the Swing States couldn't bring themselves to vote for Hillary. Stein's and Sarandn's Lies. and Hillary Hate. "Hillary and Traitor are the same". "Hilary would be worse". Too "corporate, establishment". blah blah blan. How did that work out?

I fume at this crap.. I want Dems to Win the midterms.. and I see too much gratuitous bashing of our Dems.. like 2010 and 2016.

Mahalo

sheshe2

(98,202 posts)
155. Why would ANYONE think your post is something the rw would advocate?
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:28 PM
3 hrs ago

This place sure confuses me at times...or not.



Great post, Cha. You nailed it.

Cha

(320,199 posts)
156. Mahalo, she.. For more reasons than one! 💙 ☮️🌻🕯️🕊️💜
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:44 PM
3 hrs ago

Just tried to cover some territory when We Dems lost, and I fiercely don't want it to happen again.

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,703 posts)
162. Dems are overperforming all over! 😃
Mon May 4, 2026, 09:38 PM
1 hr ago

Despite the never ending criticism and the threats of "do this or else," or "don't do that or else!"

I fume over it, too, Cha. It's exhausting.

Attacks from MAGAts and attacks from fellow "Democrats," and "progressives," who don't seem to be able to catch on that they will NEVER get anything from Republican MAGAts but act as if working with Democrats is consorting with the devil, while threatening our elected Dems not to "reach across the aisle!"

Who are progressives willing to reach out to?

This guy: "Maine just handed Democrats a wake-up call that they’d damn well better actually listen to this time."

THIS time.

Then we get lectured about civility.

Mahalo and aloha!

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
114. So this guy Platner fought in BUSH/CHENEY phony wars, but not one
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:23 PM
8 hrs ago

bad word about BUSH/CHENEY. He skips over that 8 years of BUSH/CHENEY wars and just attacks Democrats from every which way with the Revolution performance.

Call me officially suspicious.

Had to shut this off. But I’m not in Maine, so that’s great.

Amaryllis

(11,384 posts)
161. Actually he had a lot to say about the Iraq war and none of it was good.Maybe you skipped that part.
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:56 PM
2 hrs ago

Vinca

(54,253 posts)
74. I just learned a scary thing from my Mainiac brother about a Maine congressional race. It seems
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:20 PM
10 hrs ago

Paul LePage, the former governor, has reared his mentally deranged head and it looks like he has a good chance to win a seat. He makes the worst nut currently in office look downright sane.

moose65

(3,460 posts)
121. Just checked.
Mon May 4, 2026, 03:41 PM
7 hrs ago

LePage is 77. He'll be 78 in October.

Another little tidbit about him: English is his second language. Both his parents were from Quebec, so he grew up speaking French.

eShirl

(20,372 posts)
83. hope he loses as badly as the last time he ran for anything
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:58 PM
10 hrs ago

and slinks back to Florida again with his tail between his legs
and STAYS THERE this time

Aepps22

(401 posts)
82. Too Early For This!
Mon May 4, 2026, 12:55 PM
10 hrs ago

Let’s see if Platner beats Collins before these pronouncements. The same people that claimed they were tired of “weak” Dems and wanted fighters were the same ones that threw Jasmine Crockett away because “she couldn’t win”. I didn’t see Thom comment on that so just let the candidates run and if they win then make the pronouncements.

karynnj

(61,071 posts)
88. Wouldn't this be more appropriate in November as he becomes Senator elect?
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:10 PM
10 hrs ago

At this point, he has shown what will win a Democratic primary. Not to mention, it could be candidate specific and or state specific.

I think that in November, looking back at all the primaries and the general election might be a time where this type of claim might be made.

My hope is that Democrats in all states vote for candidates who win the general election, even if that was not there number one criteria. My guess is that the message and persona of the nominees will differ by state. It seems premature to claim that someone who has not won the seat yet should be considered as the role model of how to win nationally ... even if he matches his own values.

highplainsdem

(62,833 posts)
89. I agree. But Thom needs to realize that using AI art and AI music is ALSO pro-corporate and sends a
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:11 PM
10 hrs ago

pro-corporate and pro-AI bros message even if he's trying to use it for liberal messaging. He should stop using AI, which is based on theft from creatives, almost all of whom are on our side, and who hate AI-generated fake art and music, for good reason.

pnwmom

(110,316 posts)
107. I still remember Hartmann holding back on support for HRC
Mon May 4, 2026, 01:52 PM
9 hrs ago

after she beat Bernie, which helped her lose to Trump. I can't take his ideas seriously.

lostincalifornia

(5,484 posts)
115. Everyone KNEW what the stakes were in 2016, and where was Hartman? We lost the SC because of jackasses like that who
Mon May 4, 2026, 02:40 PM
8 hrs ago

couldn't muster enough gumption to push the OBVIOUS that there are differences between republicans and DEMOCRATS.

Same old bullshit. You didn't motivate enough people.

These armchair political commentators are so full of it.

Democrats win when we are united, and Howard Dean realized that with his 50-state strategy, as opposed to those who push it is all or nothing, and "if you don't do ONE thing that I don't want, I am going to take my marbles and go home"

Well, that didn't work out too well in 2000, 2016, and 2024 did it.

and because of that we have lost the SC for the foreseeable future, and much more.

Blame the Democrats theme.

The fact that the sociopath was elected twice, in spite of January 6, his abuse of power, etc. has more to do with the STUPIDITY OF THE AMERICAN VOTER.

Trump has conned people all his worthless life, and those who voted for him, and THOSE WHO REFUSED TO VOTE, bear the responsibility of where we are today.

trump is the perfect example of what .T. Barnum said: "A sucker is born every minute"









Nixie

(18,093 posts)
130. He's a public figure, however obscure, and we're discussing
Mon May 4, 2026, 05:21 PM
5 hrs ago

his latest slam of Democrats that he wrote on another platform.

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
132. Thom Hartman is a public figure and the piece he wrote on another
Mon May 4, 2026, 05:25 PM
5 hrs ago

platform was posted here.

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
134. He's a public figure, and he wrote something critical of
Mon May 4, 2026, 05:28 PM
5 hrs ago

Democrats on another platform. Maybe the OP should delete it.

Nixie

(18,093 posts)
139. I didn't see it from the poster you targeted either. Just discussing
Mon May 4, 2026, 05:36 PM
5 hrs ago

a public figures writings.

Response to Nixie (Reply #139)

Cha

(320,199 posts)
148. Yes, "civility works both ways"...
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:30 PM
4 hrs ago

Mahalo, Nixie, for explaining that so well.

No way we can't call out anyone for bashing Dems on DU.

I keep reading in this thread that "Hartman couldn't bring himself to support Hillary." That's not someone I would listen to about anything.

lostincalifornia

(5,484 posts)
151. Good. But his comment was not a DU comment, and even if it
Mon May 4, 2026, 07:03 PM
4 hrs ago

is, there is nothing wrong with people expressing their BBB ores or disagreeing with each others views.

lees1975

(7,160 posts)
120. I agree. Democrats need candidates who will kick some ass.
Mon May 4, 2026, 03:22 PM
7 hrs ago

And my vote goes to the ones who will do it.

Response to luv2fly (Original post)

Cha

(320,199 posts)
149. We Need to
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:39 PM
4 hrs ago

Win the Midterms. Not just one seat in Maine.

I'm talking about all over America. Where We Dems have been Winning, and Overperforming in red states and Red Districts..Flipping red seats to BLUE. And the DNC and DCCC have been helping with those wins.

WarGamer

(18,820 posts)
150. I did NOT SEE that coming...
Mon May 4, 2026, 06:50 PM
4 hrs ago

But I guess if you run the wrong candidate, you DESERVE WHAT YOU GET.

Right?

mr715

(3,996 posts)
160. Sorta.
Mon May 4, 2026, 08:49 PM
2 hrs ago

Affordability wasn't the buzzword, inflation was.

I still can't comprehend how, other than that the electorate is kinda a little dumb, that he won the popular vote.

You will never find me on this forum blaming the voters otherwise.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Maine Just Delivered a Br...