General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums"...I buried friends who deserved better than being folded into somebody else's cheap sermon about patriotism..."
A FB gem...
Daniel Fisk Bennett
I served beside people with every kind of belief and nonbelief imaginable, because that is what the American military actually is when politicians are not trying to sand it down into propaganda. The people beside you on watch are not chosen by a church committee. They are chosen by training, duty, trust, competence, and the shared understanding that the mission matters more than personal religious branding. Nobody doing the actual work needed a theological inspection before deciding whether the person next to them counted. Now a political appointee with a culture-war résumé looks at that reality and decides that minority beliefs can be shoved out of official recognition because the spreadsheet looks cleaner that way. That is not leadership, and it sure as hell is not honor.
On March 25, 2026, Pete Hegseth announced that the Department of Defense was cutting the militarys faith and belief codes from more than 200 down to 31, and he wrapped the whole thing in the kind of bureaucratic language people use when they want an ugly decision to sound responsible. Efficiency always becomes a convenient excuse when powerful people decide certain Americans are easier to ignore. The military can track a service members dental readiness, training history, blood type, weapons qualifications, clearance status, dependent information, medical limitations, leave balance, and career paperwork with obsessive precision. It can track details so small they make normal civilian paperwork look relaxed by comparison. Yet somehow, acknowledging the actual beliefs of the people serving became too much to handle. That excuse deserves ridicule before it deserves analysis. A military that can coordinate submarines, aircraft, satellites, logistics, and global operations can manage a damn belief-code list when leadership believes the list matters. The problem was never complexity. The problem was whose existence became expendable once Christian nationalist politics got closer to the controls. When atheists, humanists, pagans, Wiccans, Druids, Deists, Heathens, Asatru, and other minority-belief service members get pushed out of recognition, the message is not subtle. It says the institution will still take your service, but people in power reserve the right to make your identity disappear when it offends their preferred version of America.
The timing makes the insult smell even worse. Hegseth has already drawn scrutiny for explicitly Christian activity inside the Pentagon, including a Christian worship service that turned the seat of military leadership into something far too close to a government-backed religious performance. Then, after that, we are supposed to accept that a massive reduction in recognized faith and belief codes is just neutral housekeeping. I do not have enough patience left for that level of convenient stupidity. This is the kind of thing that happens when someone mistakes religious confidence for constitutional authority. Private faith is one thing, and nobody is telling Pete Hegseth he cannot go pray, worship, quote scripture, or live according to his own beliefs as a private citizen. Public power is different, especially when that power sits over a military made up of Americans from wildly different backgrounds. The Secretary of Defense does not get to treat the force like his preferred congregation with better uniforms. The Pentagon is not a church annex, and the military is not a prop department for Christian nationalism. If he cannot separate his personal religious politics from his duty to the entire force, then he is unfit for the job. That should be obvious to anyone who understands the oath as something deeper than campaign theater.
Donald Trump owns this disgrace because this is his administration, his appointment culture, and his movements rotten understanding of loyalty. I already had no respect for Trump as a veteran, because the man spent his life dodging sacrifice while constantly demanding worship from people who actually made some. He avoided service, mocked military sacrifice, treated patriotism like merchandise, and turned public office into a monument to his own appetite. Now the administration carrying his name is giving us a Pentagon where minority-belief service members can be made less visible while the usual crowd pretends this is merely administrative tidying. The same people who lecture everyone else about love of country keep proving they only love the country when it flatters their preferred tribe. They praise the troops when the troops make good campaign scenery. They talk about freedom until freedom protects atheists, Muslims, pagans, immigrants, protesters, critics, or anyone else they want pushed to the edge of the frame. Their flag-waving always seems loudest when constitutional principle is weakest. Their version of patriotism has become a performance of dominance, grievance, and obedience. Veterans should be especially disgusted by that, because the oath did not ask us to defend one mans ego. It asked us to defend a Constitution that exists specifically to restrain men like him.
The part that feels personal is not some abstract complaint about labels. It is the knowledge that this country will take almost everything from a service member and still allow politicians to treat that persons place in the national story as conditional. It will take the missed birthdays, the broken sleep, the family strain, the deployments, the stress, the injuries, the dead friends, the damaged bodies, and the years of youth that nobody gets back. It will take the atheist on watch just as readily as the Christian beside him. It will take the humanist in uniform, the pagan in uniform, the Muslim in uniform, the Jew in uniform, the Sikh in uniform, the Hindu in uniform, and the person who does not want any belief label at all. Once the sacrifice has been made, the speeches come out, the flags appear, and everyone wants to sound solemn for thirty seconds. Meanwhile, when actual living service members need recognition, accommodation, support, and honest demographic visibility, suddenly the people in charge find a reason to narrow the record. The VA can recognize atheist and humanist emblems on government headstones, which proves the government knows damn well we exist. Apparently recognition becomes easier when the veteran is dead, silent, and no longer capable of objecting. That contradiction deserves to be dragged into the town square and made to explain itself. A country that can carve a symbol into stone after death can damn well recognize the person while they are still serving.
I want to be very clear about why this matters beyond my own anger. The Chaplain Corps is supposed to support the force, and the force is not a Christian club with a few tolerated outsiders attached for manpower. Religious preference and belief data help the military understand who is serving, what support exists, where accommodations may be needed, and whether the institution is actually seeing its people honestly. Pretending that hundreds of recognized identities can be collapsed into a tiny list without consequence is the kind of lazy arrogance that only looks harmless to people who already expect their own identity to remain protected. Majority groups rarely notice the machinery of recognition because the machinery was usually built with them in mind. Minority groups notice immediately when someone starts removing the bolts. Christian service members with actual integrity should be angry because religious liberty cannot survive as a majority-only privilege. Chaplains who take their calling seriously should be angry because their work is cheapened when the institution pretends some service members are easier to categorize out of sight. Commanders should be angry because trust erodes when troops learn that leadership sees some identities as clutter. Veterans should be angry because every attack on pluralism weakens the constitutional foundation we swore to defend. Nobody who respects the oath should shrug when government power starts playing favorites with conscience.
I earned the right to be furious about this, and I will not apologize for the temperature of my response. I earned it through years of service, through loss, through sacrifice, and through the simple fact that I actually paid a price for the country these people keep using as a backdrop for their religious politics. I buried friends who deserved better than being folded into somebody elses cheap sermon about patriotism. I watched people give parts of themselves to a nation that too often remembers them only when applause is useful. I also know exactly how insulting it feels when a draft-dodging former president and a culture-war secretary treat real service members like supporting characters in their own ideological pageant. They can dress the policy up however they want, but the message lands clearly enough. We were good enough to serve, but our beliefs were too inconvenient to count. We were trusted with duty, but not with visibility. We were useful to the country, but apparently troublesome to the story these people want to tell about it. That is cowardly, sectarian, oath-breaking garbage, and it deserves condemnation without a single drop of sugar poured over it.
My service counted before Pete Hegseth ever touched a Pentagon policy memo. My oath counted before Donald Trump started confusing personal loyalty with national loyalty. The service of every atheist, humanist, pagan, Wiccan, Druid, Deist, Heathen, and minority-belief service member counts whether this administration recognizes it or not. Their place in the military is earned through service, not granted by the theological comfort level of a political appointee. Their dignity does not shrink because someone in power prefers a smaller, cleaner, more obedient version of America. The military belongs to the nation, and the nation includes millions of people who do not believe in God. The Constitution protects us anyway, which is precisely why Christian nationalists keep finding it so inconvenient. I did not serve a church, a preacher, a president, or a partisan movement. I served the Constitution of the United States. If Pete Hegseth and Donald Trump cannot respect that, then they are the ones dishonoring the uniform, the oath, and the country they keep pretending to defend... And they can cordially go fuck themselves!
SouthernOregonDem
(9 posts)Thank you!
Historic NY
(40,168 posts)COL Mustard
(8,455 posts)It has a swastika on it!
(23) Seicho-No-Ie
Historic NY
(40,168 posts)orangecrush
(31,511 posts)GiqueCee
(4,914 posts)Kegsbreath is an oily little turd of a man who has NO business befouling the Pentagon with his Christian Nationalist bullshit, and desecrating the sacrifices of those who survived, and the memory of those who fell in service to the nation.
mwmisses4289
(4,896 posts)Bravo!!!
Every liberal democracy friendly poster on you tube and other platforms should be blasting this out at full volume.
T and his minions prove on a daily basis that they absolutely 💯% hate America and Americans. The only thing some of us can do is wait until elections and do our part to vote them out.
Arthur_Frain
(2,426 posts)Cause thats a stunning read.
Thanks for reposting.
Martin Eden
(15,949 posts)He has more brains and integrity than Hegseth can even comprehend.
I was going to add Trump to the mix, but that foul creature breaks the scale in the negative range.
Wild blueberry
(8,394 posts)He speaks for many. Well written and powerfully eloquent.
Thank you.
SCantiGOP
(14,773 posts)The pseudo-military college in SC. Uniforms and drilling, but no commission and no required service after graduation.
When he entered in the mid-70s (he had a full scholarship) he was asked which service he would be attending: Catholic, Protestant or Jewish. Those were the only options, and attendance was mandatory.
That was just one of the reasons he left after the first year.
odins folly
(660 posts)1) This is an outstanding read.
2) I recall having exactly one conversation concerning my religious preference. I didnt follow any religion and hadnt since about 10 years old. The second supervisor I had was slightly dismayed that I had put Buddhist on my dog tags. He asked and I told him I had none so I just picked one. His response was what if something happened to you and your grandmother had to sit through a Buddhist ceremony ???
3) When I was on my way to Columbia to fight for bush 1s drug war, not once did anyone ask what religion anybody was. No one gave a shit. If youre dead, youre dead.
c-rational
(3,227 posts)LuckyCharms
(23,244 posts)mahina
(20,788 posts)This new exclusionmakes no sense at all.
Thanks for the excellent post.
eppur_se_muova
(42,724 posts)... lack of belief requires no justification; only belief does.
Atheism is not a belief system, just an absence of gullibility.
misanthrope
(9,658 posts)They have "no religion" on there as well.
niyad
(134,571 posts)calimary
(91,110 posts)My biggest problem with it is how on earth do I pick just one sentence in it that sums it up, says it all, and speaks for all? This is one of those times where you are compelled - indeed, ORDERED - to read the whole thing, from top to bottom, and think deeply about every phrase and sentence in it, as you go. Its almost literally holy writ. From the heart, through the conscience, and across the ages.
maxrandb
(17,526 posts)This is the kind of military leader that makes you want to run through a brickwall for them.
chowder66
(12,588 posts)spanone
(142,127 posts)Cha
(321,113 posts)red dog 1
(33,608 posts)peggysue2
(12,626 posts)wendyb-NC
(4,744 posts)It elucidates the thinking behind the stances taken and decisions made by the cabal in Washington in the military and in every other departmental focus.
MustLoveBeagles
(17,809 posts)Thank you for your service sir. And your wise words.
riversedge
(81,844 posts)electric_blue68
(27,562 posts)dixiegrrrrl
(60,184 posts)delisen
(7,459 posts)A very bad Christian Impersonator.
He does an equally bad impersonation of a US Secretary of Defense.