Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 06:42 AM 17 hrs ago

Daylight saving time bill stalls again in US Senate

Source: msn/Reuters

12h


WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Senate briefly took up a long-stalled effort on Tuesday to make daylight saving time permanent and end the twice-yearly practice of switching clocks, but again failed to reach consensus.

Senator Rick Scott, a Republican, and other senators went to the floor to push for passage of the bill first unanimously approved in March 2022, but Senator Tom Cotton said he would oppose any effort to fast-track the bill. "The American people love having an extra hour of sunlight," Scott said.

Congress has debated the issue for years. It held a legislative hearing earlier this year and won support from President Donald Trump for the change, but does not appear any closer to agreement. Standard time resumes on Sunday in the United States. Year-round daylight saving time was used during World War Two and enacted again in 1974 in a bid to reduce energy use because of an oil embargo, but was unpopular and was repealed later that year.

Cotton said that the bill's proponents are pushing Congress to repeat a prior mistake that would create absurdly late winter sunrises and force children to go to school in darkness in much of the country. The legislation would let states choose which time they want to remain on, but some worry that would lead to a patchwork of time zones across the country.

Read more: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/daylight-saving-time-bill-stalls-again-in-us-senate/ar-AA1PnpLu



Good. This will probably be the first and only time I agree with Cotton-head.

I was a victim of the last time they started daylight savings in January over 50 years ago, and having to go to school with a flashlight because the neighborhood lighting was so poor. The northern-most tier of states used to having longer nights in winter (but longer days in summer) have lighting infrastructure in place to deal with that. But further south within the CONUS, in the most densely populated urban areas where children don't have the luxury of a school bus showing up in front of their door, and have to walk and/or take public transit to school, the level of lighting needed has been non-existent. And *finally*, medical professionals are coming out with the research about the negative physical impact of year-round daylight savings time versus standard time or even the time changes. IMHO, they need to go back to the "April/October" because that previous switch had the changes happening closer to the equinox weeks.
47 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Daylight saving time bill stalls again in US Senate (Original Post) BumRushDaShow 17 hrs ago OP
rick scott was a victim? rampartd 16 hrs ago #1
Don't See Where He Said That... GB_RN 16 hrs ago #2
FYI - The OP comments are referencing myself, personally! BumRushDaShow 16 hrs ago #4
I Figured. GB_RN 16 hrs ago #6
You mean Tom Cotton? BumRushDaShow 16 hrs ago #3
"how about starting the school day an hour later"...Correct! Escurumbele 14 hrs ago #25
Bet you'd feel different about that if you were... Trueblue Texan 16 hrs ago #5
Adults have an easier time dealing with evening darkness just due to a "height advantage" BumRushDaShow 15 hrs ago #9
I've seen the things you cite happen in daylight. Trueblue Texan 15 hrs ago #10
This is a different era BumRushDaShow 15 hrs ago #17
just pick one + end the savings shit. pansypoo53219 16 hrs ago #7
I mean. You can start school later SSJVegeta 15 hrs ago #8
And what happens with the parents who have to go to work BEFORE school starts? BumRushDaShow 15 hrs ago #11
Some schools do (or did) offer before and after school programs radical noodle 15 hrs ago #15
Yes - SOME schools BumRushDaShow 15 hrs ago #18
The funding of schools always shows up inequities in our systems radical noodle 14 hrs ago #20
Oh for sure BumRushDaShow 14 hrs ago #23
Everything has to move together, if school starts one hour later, then industry must allow of r that as well. Escurumbele 14 hrs ago #26
Rick Scott will do anything to make him look accomplished after he defrauded Medicare mdbl 15 hrs ago #12
Indiana stayed on one time for years radical noodle 15 hrs ago #13
I remember my first trip to Cincinnati for a conference BumRushDaShow 14 hrs ago #19
You could start by using the European dates for changing - end of March, end of October muriel_volestrangler 14 hrs ago #22
"humans do normally get up earlier when the sun rises earlier (and when it's warmer)" BumRushDaShow 13 hrs ago #30
Not everyone liked it. Jokerman 13 hrs ago #31
grew up in Indiana LittleGirl 12 hrs ago #33
I definitely prefer daylight savings time. 4:15-4:30 sunsets are not cool! Lucky Luciano 15 hrs ago #14
And 4:30 AM sunrises in the summer also aren't cool Jerry2144 14 hrs ago #27
Give it up. Feed some children. twodogsbarking 15 hrs ago #16
Arizona does just fine without it edhopper 14 hrs ago #21
Phoenix is at 33 degrees north maxsolomon 11 hrs ago #38
Sunrise is 7:30 edhopper 11 hrs ago #39
No, the whole country should be alternating Standard Time and DST like it currently is. maxsolomon 10 hrs ago #40
Why should the entire lower half of the country edhopper 9 hrs ago #41
Because they have empathy for our plight? maxsolomon 8 hrs ago #42
It hurts businesses, mostly the construction industry who have to stop working at around 04:00pm Escurumbele 14 hrs ago #24
"we will all adapt" BumRushDaShow 13 hrs ago #32
If only the earth were flat Jerry2144 14 hrs ago #28
Get rid of "daylight saving" time and go with joshdawg 13 hrs ago #29
Absolutely. Leave the time the way the earth has time. chouchou 12 hrs ago #34
Year round standard time. PoindexterOglethorpe 12 hrs ago #35
At this point I just want them to pick one Tree Lady 8 hrs ago #43
Okay, twice a year is hardly constant changes. PoindexterOglethorpe 7 hrs ago #44
Lol I have sleep issues Tree Lady 6 hrs ago #45
And, quite a few people live in one time zone and work in another. JustABozoOnThisBus 5 hrs ago #47
Who gives a flying fuck? We have a fucking NAZI running this Country in collaboration with Putin Bengus81 12 hrs ago #36
If there is any issue that should be controlled at the state level, this is it. thought crime 12 hrs ago #37
I would Rebl2 6 hrs ago #46

rampartd

(2,772 posts)
1. rick scott was a victim?
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 06:49 AM
16 hrs ago

did he get hit by a school bus?

how about starting the school day an hour later, or installing lights at the bus stop?

"better to light 1 candle than to curse the darkness." st christopher.

GB_RN

(3,456 posts)
2. Don't See Where He Said That...
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:25 AM
16 hrs ago

On the other hand, in the text below the line break, the OP says that he/she was a victim of that original case of dumbassery. Trust Dickhead Scott (Q-Medicare Fraud) to take up the mantle that Rubio (Q-Lazy) set aside for the thankless “glory” of being Cantaloupe Caligula the Corpulent’s Secretary of State, pushing this shit. This stupidity benefits only ONE…maybe two…states: Florida and Hawaii. That said, only assholes from one of those two states are pushing this bullshit. DST deserves to die, but if we have to let it linger in our misery, then let’s keep as-is (or move it to the weekends after the equinoxes).

GB_RN

(3,456 posts)
6. I Figured.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:32 AM
16 hrs ago

Dickhead is a known liar, but pretty sure even HE wouldn’t make a claim as fact-checkable as that: Asshole was in the Navy at that time, not riding a bus/walking to school.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
3. You mean Tom Cotton?
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:25 AM
16 hrs ago

The daylight savings nonsense was supposedly pushed by farmers to have "extra light" in the afternoons and then when that became a joke, it was pushed by the recreational lobbyists who wanted extended hours at places like golf courses.

There have been efforts to start the school day "later" (and especially for high schools where the kids are showing up half a sleep to school), but starting school "later" screws with the parents' work schedule and requiring some kind of "before school" daycare/babysitting at a significant cost.

Trueblue Texan

(3,937 posts)
5. Bet you'd feel different about that if you were...
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:31 AM
16 hrs ago

...a mail carrier or a person who delivered home health services. I've done both and it is no fun trying to get your job done in the dark. Not only is it often scary, it's downright unsafe.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
9. Adults have an easier time dealing with evening darkness just due to a "height advantage"
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:49 AM
15 hrs ago

as opposed to children exposed to child predators driving around in vans snatching kids off the street in morning darkness. And add to that, the perpetual issue experienced by children fortunate to have a school bus to pick them up and having drivers not seeing the children running for it and ignoring the big flashing lights on the bus, and driving around it while a child is crossing the street to get on the bus. And that happens with public transit buses in the mornings too, but there's no "flashing school bus-type light" to alert drivers to people crossing the street to get to the bus.

Trueblue Texan

(3,937 posts)
10. I've seen the things you cite happen in daylight.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:55 AM
15 hrs ago

Everything is about perspective. As I kid I remember catching the school bus in the dark and I was not afraid, even though I had to walk a couple of blocks to get there. As an adult working in the dark, I had plenty of close calls. Most kids are either walked or driven to school by family members--even in the poorer neighborhoods.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
17. This is a different era
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:26 AM
15 hrs ago

where you have more abductions - and that includes by ex-'s and other family members with beefs.

Most kids are either walked or driven to school by family members--even in the poorer neighborhoods.


Disagree. In the poorer neighborhoods, they don't always own a car (or it may have been repo'd or is out of commission), so the parents use public transit. And with a number of schools that have been closed due to funding issues (like here in Philly), there are middle/junior highs that are not really close and the school district has no money for a school bus.

As I noted, the lighting infrastructure is NOT there in many urban areas. The assumption has been that because these cities are "dense" then there is plenty of light but that light mostly goes up into the sky contributing to light pollution and there are many more places for perps to hide. And you can add those areas where some children will actually ride a bike to school - and doing so in the dark increases the chance of a stolen bike and/or getting hit by a car like a deer.

An increase of children being hit by cars going to school in the dark was one of the biggest issues that finally triggered some sense to get rid of that bullshit under Nixon.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
11. And what happens with the parents who have to go to work BEFORE school starts?
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 07:56 AM
15 hrs ago

(which are most of them if they are not on some kind of delayed schedule and/or are on shift work)



They will need a "before school" daycare or some facility (or the school itself) offering something for kids, which often means an extra cost if the school doesn't offer that for "free".

radical noodle

(10,423 posts)
15. Some schools do (or did) offer before and after school programs
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:16 AM
15 hrs ago

free of charge to parents. Teacher's aides were usually paid to do that, and since they're underpaid, they welcomed a way to make a little more money. I don't know if they still do it, but it seemed to work well in the school system I'm familiar with. They sometimes paired it with tutoring for the kids who needed some extra help that parents were unable to give. Before school programs included breakfast.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
18. Yes - SOME schools
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:42 AM
15 hrs ago

and parents have availed of that by need due to their own work schedules.

But when you have school systems like Philly's without any "dedicated" state funding and mainly relying on property taxes (where almost a quarter of the population is in poverty), then they don't have the resources to handle that if such a change were made for starting school "later" (for ALL).

There have been calls for starting them later for high schools due to teens needing more hours of sleep, allowing them to perform better during the day, but that age group can handle "dark" better than the little ones and don't need the parents to accompany them to school.

This was one of the pushes behind allowing remote work (where possible) because you have some parent able to deal with a later (delayed) schedule. But corporate America ain't having that because the "touchy-feely" bosses want to be able to "touch and feel" their employees at the office and are paranoid if they can't "see" them.

radical noodle

(10,423 posts)
20. The funding of schools always shows up inequities in our systems
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:03 AM
14 hrs ago

in so many ways. This being one. The differences between inner city and rural schools compared to wealthy suburban schools is outrageous.

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
23. Oh for sure
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:23 AM
14 hrs ago

Both my sisters live in 'burbs adjoining to Philly. The one I live closest to is in a town of 5000, which is part of a township of 4 towns (for a total pop. of 20,000) that share public services like police, fire, schools, libraries, etc. They literally built TWO brand new schools - an elementary and a middle school, during my niece's time in their school system.

Meanwhile here in Philly, we still have the same 100+ year old piece of junk elementary schools with mold, asbestos, no air-conditioning (and slow attempts to put in window units where they suddenly discover that the electrical systems can't handle all that), continual heating problems in winter, and roof leaks.

The first "newer" school building that I went to wasn't until high school, which was a building built in 1959, which was considered "old" by the time I went there. I went to middle/junior high in the SAME building that my mother used for high school back in the '40s (and that was when the building was already a couple decades old). The middle/junior high school had no field and had a "playground" for recess on the roof that was caged in.

Escurumbele

(3,951 posts)
26. Everything has to move together, if school starts one hour later, then industry must allow of r that as well.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:31 AM
14 hrs ago

mdbl

(7,651 posts)
12. Rick Scott will do anything to make him look accomplished after he defrauded Medicare
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:00 AM
15 hrs ago

That man has no business making laws. Stupid Florida!

radical noodle

(10,423 posts)
13. Indiana stayed on one time for years
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:09 AM
15 hrs ago

and it worked fine. Everyone liked it, then Mitch Daniels (R) was elected governor and restarted the system of changing back and forth. For some time, he allowed each county to decide what time to adopt and that was a real Republican nightmare. People were working in one time zone and living in another.

I've seen articles saying changing the time back and forth is bad for your health, so I'm not sure what to believe about that. I only know that whenever the time changed, my body had a difficult time adjusting.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/changing-clocks-to-daylight-saving-time-is-bad-for-your-health/

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
19. I remember my first trip to Cincinnati for a conference
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 08:55 AM
14 hrs ago

and during my off time, I hopped a Greyhound bus to Indianapolis (so I could say I had been to Indiana ) and ran into that time thing (especially trying to figure out what I should do with the depart/arrive times on the bus schedule ).

The way they USED to have daylight savings was "April / October", which are closer to when the equinoxes (equal days/nights) happened. Then some idiots changed it to starting early March and ending early November.

From the AMA - Sleep doctors’ orders: Use standard time 365 days a year

(snip)

Nearly two-thirds of parents (64%) said they would be concerned about their children’s safety if they had to go to school before the sun comes up. That would be common if permanent daylight saving time were adopted.

In 2022, the AMA House of Delegates also moved to support ending daylight saving time.

“For far too long, we’ve changed our clocks in pursuit of daylight, while incurring public health and safety risks in the process. Committing to standard time has health benefits and allows us to end the biannual tug of war between our biological and alarm clocks,” AMA Trustee Alexander Ding, MD, MS, MBA, a diagnostic and interventional radiologist, said at the time.

(snip)


This supposedly better aligns to the body's circadian rhythms. Humans are NOT crepuscular like deer or raccoons.

muriel_volestrangler

(105,078 posts)
22. You could start by using the European dates for changing - end of March, end of October
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:14 AM
14 hrs ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Summer_time_in_Europe

https://www.dw.com/en/spain-revives-eu-daylight-saving-debate/a-74490343

Spain is trying to get daylight savings ended - but Franco put them in the German time zone for political purposes, and they've never bothered coming off it. So it's no surprise they don't like having "double daylight savings" in the summer and adjacent months; they could fix that themselves.

As far as circadian rhythms go; without timetables (school, work, transport ...) to adhere to, humans do normally get up earlier when the sun rises earlier (and when it's warmer), and daylight savings mimics that; it's just that left to ourselves, we'd change things gradually, not "no change, then an hour, then no change".

BumRushDaShow

(162,418 posts)
30. "humans do normally get up earlier when the sun rises earlier (and when it's warmer)"
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:53 AM
13 hrs ago

But by then, school is almost over. Here in winter, the sun wouldn't be coming up until almost 8:30 am in December/January.

I remember going to school downtown during that period - every day catching a commuter train ( "7:40 am Express" ) and a bus, and the sun wasn't coming up until after 8 am (through February) when they pushed to that "early" daylight savings starting January, and I had to be in school by 8:45 am.

Before this current schema, it was the first Sunday in April (equinox was a couple weeks before then, in March) and the last Sunday in October (about 6 weeks after the September equinox).

It was moved to the first Sunday in March (BEFORE the spring equinox, which isn't until a couple weeks later) and first Sunday in November (about 7 weeks after the September equinox). So it's effectively only about 4 months of standard time and 8 months of daylight time.

Going to work during this current range (which I think went into effect in 2007), it is pitch black at 6 am and that is when I was headed out to commute to work. Not too many people work the "9 am to 5 pm" thing anymore.

Jokerman

(3,553 posts)
31. Not everyone liked it.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:59 AM
13 hrs ago

Doing business in Indiana in the 90's for companies with customers across the country was challenging. Most of our customers changed time twice a year and we didn't which caused confusion with business hours and shipping deadlines. Being on the same time as our customers year-round was a tremendous improvement.

Personally, I have no problem with an hour time-shift twice a year but apparently it does confuse some people.

LittleGirl

(8,862 posts)
33. grew up in Indiana
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:53 AM
12 hrs ago

and then moved to Arizona where they too didn't change the stupid clocks.

Now, I live in CA who voted for this madness to end but the government won't let them change!

Stop the nonsense. sheesh.

edhopper

(36,747 posts)
39. Sunrise is 7:30
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 12:27 PM
11 hrs ago

in the winter.
And should the whole country be on DST for North Dakota and Maine?

maxsolomon

(37,707 posts)
40. No, the whole country should be alternating Standard Time and DST like it currently is.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 01:02 PM
10 hrs ago

I hold an unpopular opinion on this, but it is informed by living at 47.6 degrees north.

AZ does what it wants already - standard time.

maxsolomon

(37,707 posts)
42. Because they have empathy for our plight?
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 03:30 PM
8 hrs ago


Dividing up Time Zones by latitude would be weird but I'm game. My phone resets to the time wherever the plane lands.

Escurumbele

(3,951 posts)
24. It hurts businesses, mostly the construction industry who have to stop working at around 04:00pm
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:26 AM
14 hrs ago

because of it. It hurts public sport parks who many do not provide lights on their Tennis, Pickleball, Basketball courts. It hurts the Golf industry, by 04:00pm you cannot see the ball anymore, etc., etc.

It serves no purpose. I don't agree that any changes should occur, it should be daylight saving time (DST), we want to go back from work to our homes with still some daylight.

I do understand that Standard Time seems to be better for people, but we are adaptable, I personally rather have DST, be able to get out of work and do some sports, and being able to do so because I still have sun light.

I believe the problem with health is the change, going back and forth every year, but if left at DST, we will all adapt, it will stop being a concern.


Jerry2144

(3,039 posts)
28. If only the earth were flat
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:38 AM
14 hrs ago

Then we wouldn’t have changing hours of daylight. Or seasons, for that matter. How do those Stable Geniuses explain both of those things for their flat earth opinions?

joshdawg

(2,893 posts)
29. Get rid of "daylight saving" time and go with
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:51 AM
13 hrs ago

standard time. Stop all the b.s. about saving daylight. Leave the clocks alone. Sheesh!

chouchou

(2,540 posts)
34. Absolutely. Leave the time the way the earth has time.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:56 AM
12 hrs ago

"But..but...in the winter ...the children have to go to school in the dark"....
"Then change to damn hours of the school!! What's the big deal."

Tree Lady

(12,847 posts)
43. At this point I just want them to pick one
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 03:37 PM
8 hrs ago

And stay there, the constant change is hard on my body especially as I age.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(28,250 posts)
44. Okay, twice a year is hardly constant changes.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 04:40 PM
7 hrs ago

Last edited Wed Oct 29, 2025, 05:25 PM - Edit history (1)

Plus, apparently no one who complains about the switch has ever crossed a time zone. The general rule of thumb is that you can adjust in 24 hours to a one hour time zone change.

So taking days? Seriously? One freaking hour.

(Edited to fix typo)

JustABozoOnThisBus

(24,451 posts)
47. And, quite a few people live in one time zone and work in another.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 05:58 PM
5 hrs ago

It's all kinds of fun when arranging to meet someone for dinner, in one location or the other.

Bengus81

(9,532 posts)
36. Who gives a flying fuck? We have a fucking NAZI running this Country in collaboration with Putin
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:26 AM
12 hrs ago

and people are worried about setting a couple of clocks forward or backward?

thought crime

(937 posts)
37. If there is any issue that should be controlled at the state level, this is it.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:43 AM
12 hrs ago

Winter daylight savings for the most northern states is a horrible idea. For Florida Golfers, it might be nice (the Golf Business is lobbying heavily for it).

Rebl2

(17,138 posts)
46. I would
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 04:53 PM
6 hrs ago

not like daylight savings time year around. It would still be dark here at nine in the morning. I remember one of the local meteorologist saying that a couple of years ago.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Daylight saving time bill...