Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Betty Boom

(377 posts)
Fri Dec 26, 2025, 03:39 AM Dec 26

Watched "You've Got Mail" Christmas Eve. Question.

Something struck me. The opening credits sequence has this rendering of New York City that the camera travels through. Movie was made in 1998. And yet they have altered this opening sequence so that the new freedom tower is what is shown, rather than the World Trade Center. Why do they feel the need to do that? Like it’s gonna make us sad at the beginning of a romantic comedy to see the twin towers? It’s not as though watching the movie is gonna make us think it’s 2025. She uses a dial-up modem to get her mail on AOL, for goodness sakes. I wish they wouldn’t do this, and I’ve noticed it in other things too. To me, it’s jarring and makes it more noticeable. Thoughts?

11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Watched "You've Got Mail" Christmas Eve. Question. (Original Post) Betty Boom Dec 26 OP
I agree -- byronius Dec 26 #1
It was a heartwarming movie, but when it came out... C Moon Dec 26 #2
I watched When Harry Met Sally mnhtnbb Dec 26 #3
Oh that was done in all films after 9/11 Jacson6 Dec 26 #4
Hate it. Perhaps we should remember the attacks! Wounded Bear Dec 26 #5
I think doing this is silly MustLoveBeagles Dec 26 #6
It does make me sad to see the Twin Towers JustKay Dec 28 #7
As a NYC'r who spent a year 80/81 on the 73rd flr of South Tower 2 it also makes me briefly sad. Wouldn't want it... electric_blue68 Dec 28 #8
Tangential "You've Got Mail" story... electric_blue68 Dec 28 #9
So cool! Betty Boom Tuesday #10
I don't remember the very beginning of You've Got Mail, other than The Cranberries song, MorbidButterflyTat Wednesday #11

byronius

(7,905 posts)
1. I agree --
Fri Dec 26, 2025, 04:41 AM
Dec 26

But artists. They have quirks and odd impulses, especially those artists managing other’s art.

I’m very sympathetic to your complaint, but someone had the power to make such an awful decision. I’m certain they would argue it to both of us.

C Moon

(13,471 posts)
2. It was a heartwarming movie, but when it came out...
Fri Dec 26, 2025, 05:42 AM
Dec 26

I hated it: I was left feeling like I just watched an advertisement for Starbucks, AOL, etc

But even then, I was thinking that in the years that follow those corporate advertisements would be an interesting part of history (for instance, AOL mail is no longer a major player). So my hate for it diminished.

Anyways. Moving on.

mnhtnbb

(33,119 posts)
3. I watched When Harry Met Sally
Fri Dec 26, 2025, 06:52 AM
Dec 26

the other night and was struck by one scene where the twin towers were visible in the background. So no alteration in that movie.
I haven't noticed the towers being replaced in other movies.

Jacson6

(1,768 posts)
4. Oh that was done in all films after 9/11
Fri Dec 26, 2025, 09:42 AM
Dec 26

They thought it would trigger people to remember the attacks.

JustKay

(59 posts)
7. It does make me sad to see the Twin Towers
Sun Dec 28, 2025, 11:55 AM
Dec 28

but I think it's wrong to remove them from films. It's like whitewashing the past.

electric_blue68

(25,929 posts)
8. As a NYC'r who spent a year 80/81 on the 73rd flr of South Tower 2 it also makes me briefly sad. Wouldn't want it...
Sun Dec 28, 2025, 08:11 PM
Dec 28

change, tho. It is what it is.

electric_blue68

(25,929 posts)
9. Tangential "You've Got Mail" story...
Sun Dec 28, 2025, 08:24 PM
Dec 28

NYC'r here.
A thing I've done for many years in The Spring is visit the big pathway of Riverside Park (West edge of Manhattan ?135 St - 72nd St - Westside Highway next to it). I stroll, and sit on the benches a few blocks below the 72nd St entrance when the crabapple, and cherry trees are blossoming! So, so beautiful.
.
So I'm ready to do my walk, but am blocked off ftom the main path. Wth. Oh, there's a movie being filmed. I see the food catered carts.
.
Well, a year or so later I'm in the movie theater, and there's the characters walking though that section; trees all in bloom. Aha!

MorbidButterflyTat

(4,189 posts)
11. I don't remember the very beginning of You've Got Mail, other than The Cranberries song,
Wed Jan 7, 2026, 06:27 PM
Wednesday

but there are plenty of movies made before 9/11 that still show the Twin Towers: Working Girl, Moonstruck, Ghostbusters, Ghostbusters 2, Deep Impact, Die Hard with a Vengeance, Superman with Christopher Reeve, etc.

Really no whitewashing of history going on.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Watched "You've Got Mail"...