Back to the Future - The Oval Office and Security Guarantees for Ukraine - Silicon Curtain

Edition No227 | 19-08-2025 - Today’s episode focuses on security guarantees – Ukraine has been here before. The Budapest Memorandum threw Ukraine under the bus, stripping away its deterrent weapons, while offering illusory guarantees on security. These proved to be toothless and worthless when Russia invaded. 2025, and are we back to the same exercise of making false promises to Ukraine, as it continues to fact an existential threat to its existence.

We ask what can genuinely deter Russian aggression, and do Western powers have the will and capacity to follow through on what is required. We explore the recent White House summit between Zelenskyy, European leaders, and Trump—focusing on, historical security pitfalls, deterrence theory and practice and the precarious path ahead.

What does it really mean when Ukraine—and the world—seeks security guarantees in the shadow of shattered treaties and lies by Russia and a history of betrayal by Ukraine’s allies.
----------

DESCRIPTION:
Post-Summit Analysis: Security Guarantees for Ukraine

In today's episode of Silicon Bites, we dive deep into the recent White House summit involving Zelenskyy, European leaders, and Donald Trump. This episode explores the pressing topic of security guarantees for Ukraine amidst its ongoing conflict with Russia. We reflect on historical precedents like the Budapest Memorandum, discuss the implications of Article 5-like assurances, and compare potential security models to Israel's strategic support from the US. Key developments, such as Europe's $19 billion weapons package for Ukraine and proposed European-led reassurance forces, are analyzed. The discussion emphasizes the need for credible deterrents and proactive commitments from Western allies to support Ukraine effectively.
----------

CHAPTERS:
00:00 Introduction and Episode Overview
00:24 Support and Contributions
01:01 Focus on Security Guarantees
01:04 Historical Context: Budapest Memorandum
01:48 Recent White House Summit
02:32 European and US Reactions
03:55 Challenges and Ambiguities
06:17 Comparing to Israel's Security Model
12:00 Potential Security Measures for Ukraine
13:53 Concluding Thoughts and Future Implications