Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:16 PM Tuesday

There is something that confuses me a great deal...the concept of "family."

Everyone including my family members say over and over, “you have to keep family in your life, nothing in the world is as important as family!”

My family was abusive to me in every single way possible…physical, sexual, emotional, financial.

My husband has urged me for many years to go no contact, and after battling feelings of guilt, I finally went no contact with my extended family of origin.

Lots of howls of anger, telling me “fambly is everything, you MUST stay close to all of us! How dare you go away?”

Am I missing something?

To me, fambly means: A group of people who feel entitled to hurt you constantly and you have no right to walk away or defend yourself.

Why exactly is fambly important?

I don’t get it.

All I have ever wanted is to get away from all of them.

54 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
There is something that confuses me a great deal...the concept of "family." (Original Post) LiberalLoner Tuesday OP
I don't believe you have any obligation to be around anyone, family or not, that mistreats you let alone abuses you. MLAA Tuesday #1
Thank you so much!!! 💙💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #2
People who get angry at us for setting boundaries Basso8vb Tuesday #3
Thank you so much! My husband is so happy I have set boundaries and is very afraid I might let them back in. I won't.💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #5
Having to scapegoat somebody else terrifies them as any one of them could be "it" SheltieLover Tuesday #3
Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙. I think they are just angry to lose their favorite punching bag. They don't LiberalLoner Tuesday #6
Absolutely! And they absolutely will turn on someone else now that you've extricated yourself SheltieLover Tuesday #8
💙💙💙💙poor next scapegoat. LiberalLoner Tuesday #11
I hear you, LiberalLoner. And I feel/felt your pain -- especially from the guilt. But no more punching bag here either. wordstroken 12 hrs ago #42
Thank you so much! 💙💙💙. I am glad you escaped, too. 🤗🤗🤗🤗 LiberalLoner 12 hrs ago #43
Your husband is correct synni Tuesday #7
Thank you so much! I will try to! 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #13
Great book: "Scapegoat Complex" SheltieLover Tuesday #9
Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙💙. I will find it and read it, even if it is triggering. It might help explain why LiberalLoner Tuesday #14
I just bought the kindle by that author that I think will help me a lot, thanks so much! 💙💙💙I do have C-PTSD which LiberalLoner Tuesday #17
Absolutely it is very common for dysfunctional families to scapegoat one member. SheltieLover 11 hrs ago #48
Perfect example! SheltieLover Tuesday #22
Thank you so so much for being so kind and wonderful! 💙💙💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #23
You are most welcome! SheltieLover 11 hrs ago #49
Excellent advice. Thank you, SheltieLover. wordstroken 11 hrs ago #47
Hi Words SheltieLover 11 hrs ago #50
Will definitely do. Thanks again, Sheltie wordstroken 6 hrs ago #53
You might also enjoy looking up testimonials on You Tube regarding Internal Family Systems (re: "No Bad Parts" book) SheltieLover 11 hrs ago #51
On it. wordstroken 6 hrs ago #54
Blood is not necessarily family. Hope22 Tuesday #10
Thank you so so much. 💙💙💙 I wish you peace and safety, and all the best. 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #15
Keeping close to abusive people, family or not, is masochism NoRethugFriends Tuesday #12
That's what I always thought too, but the outcry when you go no contact is just deafening, you know? And I wonder why. LiberalLoner Tuesday #16
Because that loses them their target for abuse and ugliness. niyad Tuesday #19
Thank you 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #24
A lot of people in society have a Hallmark Cards view of reality spooky3 Tuesday #20
Thank you so so much 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #25
A couple of points from my personal view: the concept of "family" that is niyad Tuesday #18
Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙💙 I stayed close to my fellow scapegoated stepsister, she is awesome. LiberalLoner Tuesday #26
Maybe a new definition of family would help. Perhaps it really is not defined by who you share DNA with! Amaryllis Tuesday #28
I couldn't agree more, Niyad! SheltieLover 11 hrs ago #52
Thank you get the red out Tuesday #21
OMG walking on eggshells like that is classic being a scapegoat or abuse victim! You were abused too as badly as I was LiberalLoner Tuesday #27
I have always defined family in different ways. Lonestarblue Tuesday #29
Very wise 💙💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #30
I got divorced from what I knew as 'family' stillcool Tuesday #31
I'm so sorry for your loss. I can't even imagine how hard it is to endure such a loss. 💙💙💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #32
Thank you. I was surprised... stillcool Tuesday #34
💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗 LiberalLoner 12 hrs ago #44
Growing up in an abusive family, I can attest NO CONTACT is best. They rarely ever accept the Clouds Passing Tuesday #33
💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗. Funny thing is, they are the ones who appear, or are, "normal" to the outside world. LiberalLoner 12 hrs ago #45
KnR Give Peace A Chance Tuesday #35
💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗 I mostly daydreamed about suicide every day. Thought about dashing in front of a school bus. LiberalLoner 12 hrs ago #46
Life is hard, families fight...but clearly yours must have gone far past the point of deserving forgiveness lostnfound Tuesday #36
Thank you so much! 💙💙💙some of it is them simply not admitting, or downplaying the abuse....for example, my LiberalLoner Tuesday #40
Make sure to keep a proper distance. Even in good families. Festivito Tuesday #37
A restraining order is probably most appropriate for my family of origin. Thank you so much! 💙💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Tuesday #38
No...toxic family are not. Tikki Tuesday #39
Yes, thank you...💙💙💙 I regret ever exposing my husband to my toxic family. I wish I had not. LiberalLoner Tuesday #41

MLAA

(19,219 posts)
1. I don't believe you have any obligation to be around anyone, family or not, that mistreats you let alone abuses you.
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:20 PM
Tuesday

Good for you that you made the break! Sending hugs of support! 🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷

Basso8vb

(944 posts)
3. People who get angry at us for setting boundaries
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:22 PM
Tuesday

are exactly the kind of people we don't need in our lives.

More power to you for standing up for yourself.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
5. Thank you so much! My husband is so happy I have set boundaries and is very afraid I might let them back in. I won't.💙
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:25 PM
Tuesday

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
3. Having to scapegoat somebody else terrifies them as any one of them could be "it"
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:22 PM
Tuesday

Hang in there..

We appreciate you here!

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
6. Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙. I think they are just angry to lose their favorite punching bag. They don't
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:27 PM
Tuesday

Have to look at their own problems such as alcoholism and other addictions, so long as they can beat up on me and laugh at me.

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
8. Absolutely! And they absolutely will turn on someone else now that you've extricated yourself
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:28 PM
Tuesday

wordstroken

(1,162 posts)
42. I hear you, LiberalLoner. And I feel/felt your pain -- especially from the guilt. But no more punching bag here either.
Wed May 14, 2025, 01:15 PM
12 hrs ago

Our DU family has given me more support than they ever did.
Your courage is inspiring. Thank you so much.
💙💙💙💙💙

synni

(318 posts)
7. Your husband is correct
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:27 PM
Tuesday

Ignore the gas lighters, get on with your life, and the pursuit of happiness. All the best of luck to you!

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
9. Great book: "Scapegoat Complex"
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:30 PM
Tuesday

It is not an easy read, esp for someone who has bn the victim of such maladaptive behavior, but it will explain the underlying issues.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
14. Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙💙. I will find it and read it, even if it is triggering. It might help explain why
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:36 PM
Tuesday

When my stepsister called the police over my father beating her mother, and my father was arrested, the whole family including of course my father saw her…the 14 year old who was terrified and called the cops…as the bad person who obviously would become a huge failure in life. (She became a success in every measurable way, beyond what any of them could imagine.)

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
17. I just bought the kindle by that author that I think will help me a lot, thanks so much! 💙💙💙I do have C-PTSD which
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:42 PM
Tuesday

I guess is very common for family scapegoats.

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
48. Absolutely it is very common for dysfunctional families to scapegoat one member.
Wed May 14, 2025, 02:55 PM
11 hrs ago

Then when that person leaves or severs ties, guess what? Another member will be targeted for the role.

Think of family therapy like a mobile hanging over a baby's crib. When one toy on a string is touched, the whole thing begins to rock.



SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
22. Perfect example!
Tue May 13, 2025, 04:03 PM
Tuesday

You can likely find a used copy relative reasonably priced.

Kudos to your hubby for encouraging you to cut the crazymakers out of your life.

Focus instead on how your life experiences have made you the wonderful person you are!

You might want to get youd hands on a copy of "No Bad Parts," an exemplary read! Any library should have a copy!

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
49. You are most welcome!
Wed May 14, 2025, 02:56 PM
11 hrs ago

If Psych 101 were taught as a mandatory course in every high school, likely we wouldn't be plagued with these transgenerational maladaptions, but here we are...

Hugs to you!

wordstroken

(1,162 posts)
47. Excellent advice. Thank you, SheltieLover.
Wed May 14, 2025, 02:50 PM
11 hrs ago

I just downloaded a copy of Scapecoat Complex. The synopsis is right on target.

I’ll also check out No Bad Parts as well.

Really appreciate your recommendations.
💙💙💙

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
50. Hi Words
Wed May 14, 2025, 02:58 PM
11 hrs ago

Glad you are finding Scapegoat Complex hitting the mark.

If you want something even deeper, take a peek at "The Inner World of Trauma," by Kalsched. Again, not an easy read by any means, but benchmark work.

Enjoy!

SheltieLover

(67,865 posts)
51. You might also enjoy looking up testimonials on You Tube regarding Internal Family Systems (re: "No Bad Parts" book)
Wed May 14, 2025, 03:00 PM
11 hrs ago

Great stuff!

I don't have any specific testimonials to recommend, but others have shared with me that people say IFS (Schwartz's work) is "life changing!"

Enjoy!

Hope22

(3,950 posts)
10. Blood is not necessarily family.
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:31 PM
Tuesday

My family sounds like yours. They feel threatened if I say no to them. They need me as the triad in there mix. Without us one of them will have to be the victim and they can’t risk that! A nice strong boundary is your friend. My best to you. You deserve peace. 💗🙏🏼

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
15. Thank you so so much. 💙💙💙 I wish you peace and safety, and all the best. 💙💙💙
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:37 PM
Tuesday

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
16. That's what I always thought too, but the outcry when you go no contact is just deafening, you know? And I wonder why.
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:38 PM
Tuesday

spooky3

(37,458 posts)
20. A lot of people in society have a Hallmark Cards view of reality
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:48 PM
Tuesday

and/or they were among the lucky ones to have a functional family, so that they may honestly not understand what you (and others) went through. That's why listening to your own assessment (with support of others if you have them) is far more important than pleasing others who don't get it.

niyad

(123,676 posts)
18. A couple of points from my personal view: the concept of "family" that is
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:46 PM
Tuesday

presented as the ideal, the norm, is BS designed to keep us in thrall, and to keep shrinks and big pharma in their big bucks. This family of the blood, this genetic or legal relation is no guarantee that one will find love and support and encouragement. Often, it is abuse and pain. And one has EVERY right to run as far as possible.

Then there is family of the heart, who may, or may not, be genetically or legally related. This family is there for you, supports you, encourages you, loves and cares about you. Some of us have both. For many of us, we are fortunate to have family of the heart.

There is a damned good reason for this old saying, "Your friends are god's way of apologizing for your relatives." (we will leave the discussion of why god inflicted those relatives in the first place for another time.). Or the one that says you can choose your friends, but not your family. However, one can choose, for one's life and well-being, to stay as far away from one's dysfunctional, abusive, hateful (and politically insane) family of the blood as possible, with no need to feel guilt or angst.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
26. Thank you so so much! 💙💙💙💙 I stayed close to my fellow scapegoated stepsister, she is awesome.
Tue May 13, 2025, 04:15 PM
Tuesday

I consider her to be more family than the people I share DNA with.

Amaryllis

(10,334 posts)
28. Maybe a new definition of family would help. Perhaps it really is not defined by who you share DNA with!
Tue May 13, 2025, 04:33 PM
Tuesday

What qualities would you like to have in family? You can choose a new definition, or new qualities and look for people who have those qualities as friends!

get the red out

(13,738 posts)
21. Thank you
Tue May 13, 2025, 03:57 PM
Tuesday

I have always wondered as well. I didn't have the horrible extent of abuse as you, but my Mom was mentally ill and way back in the 70s the most important thing in our family was to keep her from losing her shit and screaming and cursing at everyone for days on end. Then suddenly it never happened and my sister and I would be in gaslight city.

I never understood family, why anyone would allow them in their business all them time, it always seemed like some dangerous shit to me, always on tip-toes waiting on the eruption, and I was the object of disgust and shame after being diagnosed with mental illness and Mom going scott-free because she never got diagnosed for her bat-shit-crazy (until Dad died and my sister and I got her into assisted living and look after her as we can, she has quite advanced dementia now and is nice, but we got her mental healthcare as soon as she got to asst living to keep her from getting kicked out).

I didn't mean to hijack your topic I have a very weird story but I fully acknoledge that many have suffered much worse than me, but I can't recall when I understood devotion to family, I always worried about "incurring the family hatred" until it became clear to me and them that I just didn't give a shit anymore.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
27. OMG walking on eggshells like that is classic being a scapegoat or abuse victim! You were abused too as badly as I was
Tue May 13, 2025, 04:17 PM
Tuesday

I am so so sorry and I am glad you are free and safe now 💙💙💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗🤗

Lonestarblue

(12,613 posts)
29. I have always defined family in different ways.
Tue May 13, 2025, 04:34 PM
Tuesday

My parents, brothers, sisters, grandparents, etc., are the family I was born into. I’m fortunate to have good people in my family, but I had no choice in who they are. My friends are the family I chose for myself.

stillcool

(33,795 posts)
31. I got divorced from what I knew as 'family'
Tue May 13, 2025, 05:02 PM
Tuesday

several times, but the last one was final. It's been over 20 years now, and they've been dying off. I married an orphan who like your husband encouraged me to let them go. I never wanted children or any family of my own. Scared the bejesus out of me. Life is so frigging hard. I explained to the matriarch that it was me, not her that necessitated my action. Every time I spoke with her I was instantly snapped back into the high drama of time spent there. I suppose it was different because they weren't 'really' my family, but according to her I owed them big time for not ending up as a 'ward of the state'. That 'family' thing can be so detrimental. I wish you well on your journey. We are all alike, and we are all so very different. Doing what 'you' need to do for you, what feels right, is your choice to make. Pro's and Con's and all that. I didn't live near them anymore either, so didn't have to listen to the party-line bull either. My husband of over 30 years died recently, and left me much stronger because of our ability to find our own way. Just do you.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
32. I'm so sorry for your loss. I can't even imagine how hard it is to endure such a loss. 💙💙💙💙💙
Tue May 13, 2025, 05:10 PM
Tuesday

stillcool

(33,795 posts)
34. Thank you. I was surprised...
Tue May 13, 2025, 05:18 PM
Tuesday

emotional pain is something I'm familiar with, but nothing could have prepared me. Funny how much of long ago and far away creeps up on me now. I think the pain is what puts me back there. It's never gone, but I think I never dealt with aspects of loss, fear, shame, 'the usual' from back then. It's like 'muscle' memory, only it's 'emotional trauma memory'. I'm learning an awful lot, and as we know the only way through, is through. Can't find a short-cut, or get around it.

Clouds Passing

(4,703 posts)
33. Growing up in an abusive family, I can attest NO CONTACT is best. They rarely ever accept the
Tue May 13, 2025, 05:12 PM
Tuesday

abuse they have doled out and constantly defend their bad behavior. The family scapegoat is the one who gets the worst of the abuse, yet they are the ones most likely to seek and get help. If you are a family scapegoat, their abuse of you will not stop. It is so easy for them to blame you for everything that’s wrong and attack you because of it.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
45. 💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗. Funny thing is, they are the ones who appear, or are, "normal" to the outside world.
Wed May 14, 2025, 01:44 PM
12 hrs ago

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
46. 💙💙💙🤗🤗🤗 I mostly daydreamed about suicide every day. Thought about dashing in front of a school bus.
Wed May 14, 2025, 01:44 PM
12 hrs ago

lostnfound

(16,959 posts)
36. Life is hard, families fight...but clearly yours must have gone far past the point of deserving forgiveness
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:14 PM
Tuesday

You do you.
Do what you need to stay healthy,.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
40. Thank you so much! 💙💙💙some of it is them simply not admitting, or downplaying the abuse....for example, my
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:32 PM
Tuesday

Brother who was 8 years older than me, started raping me when I was five, and the family coordinated and colluded to keep it happening because they enjoyed seeing me in pain.

After I grew up, some said I was making it up, my brother said it wasn’t a big deal and my mother said I should have fought harder if I didn’t want it, it takes two to tango after all.

Just one example, I could give hundreds more but don’t want to bore people.

Festivito

(13,710 posts)
37. Make sure to keep a proper distance. Even in good families.
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:21 PM
Tuesday

It is good to have some contact for health information and death confirmations.

Even if you have to resort to no phone numbers traded, no addresses traded because they abuse even that. You could resort to a post office box, a one-purpose email account, or a burner phone. Each costs a bit of time and money.

At death, someone needs to contact a family member.

And if they really are that much of a bother. You can always answer every question, every statement, every grunt, with "Oh, really." Unless you have to answer them with a restraining order. In that case, get one.

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
38. A restraining order is probably most appropriate for my family of origin. Thank you so much! 💙💙💙💙
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:32 PM
Tuesday

Tikki

(14,827 posts)
39. No...toxic family are not.
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:32 PM
Tuesday

Toxic in …no one deserves that.

If you have friends and close people who love you and treat you with respect you have every right to
call them family.

Remember the best love you can show to those you have with you now and who you trust and love
is to NOT bring toxic people into their lives.


Tikki

LiberalLoner

(11,044 posts)
41. Yes, thank you...💙💙💙 I regret ever exposing my husband to my toxic family. I wish I had not.
Tue May 13, 2025, 09:48 PM
Tuesday
Latest Discussions»Support Forums»Mental Health Support»There is something that c...