Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Jewish Group
Related: About this forum(Jewish Group) Mahmoud Khalil justifies Oct. 7, downplays antisemitism at Columbia, in NYT interview
THIS IS THE JEWISH GROUP
Mahmoud Khalil justifies Oct. 7, downplays antisemitism at Columbia, in NYT interview
The pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel US protest leader detained by ICE in March calls claims of hostility to Jews at NY university manufactured hysteria, in discussion with Ezra Klein
Six weeks after being released from US federal detention, Mahmoud Khalil, the first pro-Palestinian protest leader to be arrested by President Donald Trumps administration last spring, has defended Hamass onslaught of October 7, 2023, and said concerns about antisemitism at Columbia University reflect a manufactured hysteria.
snip--------------------------------------------
I would push back regarding antisemitism at Columbia. I would really push back on that, replied Khalil, to which Klein responded: There was none?
I wouldnt say there was none. I would say there is this manufactured hysteria about antisemitism at Columbia because of the protests, Khalil replied. He added: Proud Boys were at the doors of Columbia, the very right-wing group. And there are incidents here and there. But its not like antisemitism is happening at Columbia because of the Palestine movement.
There does not appear to be any evidence that members of the Proud Boys were at Columbia. A Columbia antisemitism task force reported last year that Jews experienced crushing discrimination on campus, much of it related to the pro-Palestinian protest movement.
The pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel US protest leader detained by ICE in March calls claims of hostility to Jews at NY university manufactured hysteria, in discussion with Ezra Klein
Six weeks after being released from US federal detention, Mahmoud Khalil, the first pro-Palestinian protest leader to be arrested by President Donald Trumps administration last spring, has defended Hamass onslaught of October 7, 2023, and said concerns about antisemitism at Columbia University reflect a manufactured hysteria.
snip--------------------------------------------
I would push back regarding antisemitism at Columbia. I would really push back on that, replied Khalil, to which Klein responded: There was none?
I wouldnt say there was none. I would say there is this manufactured hysteria about antisemitism at Columbia because of the protests, Khalil replied. He added: Proud Boys were at the doors of Columbia, the very right-wing group. And there are incidents here and there. But its not like antisemitism is happening at Columbia because of the Palestine movement.
There does not appear to be any evidence that members of the Proud Boys were at Columbia. A Columbia antisemitism task force reported last year that Jews experienced crushing discrimination on campus, much of it related to the pro-Palestinian protest movement.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/mahmoud-khalil-justifies-oct-7-downplays-antisemitism-at-columbia-in-nyt-interview/
6 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

(Jewish Group) Mahmoud Khalil justifies Oct. 7, downplays antisemitism at Columbia, in NYT interview (Original Post)
lapucelle
Aug 8
OP
lapucelle
(20,607 posts)1. In addition...
[Khalil] also said that Hamass October 7 atrocities violated international law because they targeted civilians, but characterized it as inevitable. Shortly before Khalils arrest, he led a protest where activists distributed Hamas propaganda on campus.
snip------------------------------------------
While noting that hes against the targeting of civilians, Khalil repeated several times that we cannot ask Palestinians to be perfect victims.
He also implied that the onslaught stemmed in part from the movement toward an Israel-Saudi Arabia normalization deal.
At that point, there was no political process, he claims. It was clear that the Saudi-Israel deal is very imminent, and Palestinians wouldnt have any path to statehood and self-determination. So they had to do that, according to their calculations which, its obvious, were not right.
snip------------------------------------------
While noting that hes against the targeting of civilians, Khalil repeated several times that we cannot ask Palestinians to be perfect victims.
He also implied that the onslaught stemmed in part from the movement toward an Israel-Saudi Arabia normalization deal.
At that point, there was no political process, he claims. It was clear that the Saudi-Israel deal is very imminent, and Palestinians wouldnt have any path to statehood and self-determination. So they had to do that, according to their calculations which, its obvious, were not right.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/mahmoud-khalil-justifies-oct-7-downplays-antisemitism-at-columbia-in-nyt-interview/
JustAnotherGen
(36,724 posts)2. Palestine
Is out of my hands.
lapucelle
(20,607 posts)3. Palestine had a seat at the table, according to the BBC
Palestinians set out terms for agreeing to historic Saudi-Israeli deal
6 September 2023
6 September 2023
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-66734638
JustAnotherGen
(36,724 posts)4. They most certainly did
lapucelle
(20,607 posts)5. 37 year old Democratic congressman Jake Auchincloss on June 21.
lostincalifornia
(4,227 posts)6. It seems that the only ones who don't see antisemitism are the
the antiS@@@@@@