Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Joinfortmill

(19,315 posts)
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:12 AM 14 hrs ago

Switching from Advantage Plan (which left my area, creating a qualifying event) to Original Medicare. Here's Why

Here's my story: I joined an Advantage Plan when I became eligible for Medicare about 10 years ago. My experience with the coverage and services has been positive until recently when it began to cost me significant out of pocket expenses, which was quite a surprise. In the past they even covered a 100% of a very expensive brain aneurysm procedure including endovascular coilling with two stents. This brain procedure was a ONE TIME EVENT, so hold that thought.

Fast forward three years and I developed an eye disease called neurovascular age related mascular degeneration or 'Wet AMD'. This condition is chronic, and it seems that CHRONIC may be an operative word in how Advantage Plans cover conditions.

Wet AMD requires eye injections every few weeks. They are expenisve. My eye injection costs approximately $2,000 for each injection. The Advantage plan I had covered about 80% of the cost, about what regular Medicare covers. I had to pick up the remainder, which was approximately $400 per injection, which is about $3200 a year.

The short story is that $3200 seems to be the cut off point where Advantage plans no longer have an advantage. That is, the cost of original Medicare, a drug plan, and a Medigap plan will cost me all in, including the $185 Medicare deduction, premiums, and copays approximately $3,000 a year. And that is approximately what I am paying in co-pays to the Advantage plan. If I get this disease in my other eye, which may well happen, my out of pocket costs with the Advantage plan doubles, but my preimiums, etc. with regular Medicare with a Medigap plan will likely remains stable or only increase slightly, and becomes a far better financial option than an Advantage plan.

So, the moral of my story is that it appears that Advantage plans lose their advantage when a chronic condition like mine rears it's ugly head. My condition of approximately 8 injections per year will cost over a five year period about $80k (2,000x8=16,000x 5=80,000) And that is where the rubber meets the road, so to speak. If you have a chronic condition that is expensive to treat as mine is, you might want to consider regular Medicare with a Medigap plan. It may save you a lot of money in the long run.
39 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Switching from Advantage Plan (which left my area, creating a qualifying event) to Original Medicare. Here's Why (Original Post) Joinfortmill 14 hrs ago OP
I switched from an advantage to regular Medicare about 10 years ago Walleye 14 hrs ago #1
Thom Hartmann predicted a year ago gab13by13 14 hrs ago #7
But still, 53% of beneficaries choose Medicare Advantage because they believe it is more affordable for them. Silent Type 14 hrs ago #10
"... they believe it is more affordable." Grins 12 hrs ago #32
Like I said, you get a choice. If Medicare is better for you, take it. If MA is better, take it. But don't try to take Silent Type 12 hrs ago #34
I would be doing tradtional Medicare + a plan to cover my meds, but I chose Medicare Advantage for dental and vision iluvtennis 12 hrs ago #33
Exactly, it's a choice. MA is definitely better for some people, others not. Silent Type 11 hrs ago #35
My daughter is an RN case manager for home care Freddie 12 hrs ago #27
Not exactly true. Traditional Medicare has very detailed coverage rules that prevent some questionable claims. Silent Type 11 hrs ago #39
Will do. Joinfortmill 13 hrs ago #11
Good for you. Luckily, I learned about Medicare Supplement and ignored the "advantage" propaganda. we can do it 14 hrs ago #2
Are there restrictions on switching from Adv. to Medicare? nt Ilsa 14 hrs ago #3
Yes IbogaProject 14 hrs ago #5
Thank you very much. nt Ilsa 13 hrs ago #20
The issue is getting a Medigap supplement Abnredleg 14 hrs ago #6
Thank you very much. nt Ilsa 13 hrs ago #18
Yes, some, unless there is a s qualifying event. Joinfortmill 13 hrs ago #13
Thank you very much. nt Ilsa 13 hrs ago #16
Original Medicare? Sanity Claws 14 hrs ago #4
Advantage Plans include Parts A and B Abnredleg 14 hrs ago #8
Plain Medicare certainly covers doctors visits. gab13by13 14 hrs ago #9
Medicare covers part A & B. Joinfortmill 13 hrs ago #14
Medicare Part A (hospital, etc.) deRien 13 hrs ago #24
Original Medicare is both Part A and Part B Bob_in_VA 12 hrs ago #31
OP--there's a lot of misinformation in this thread. marybourg 13 hrs ago #12
Everyrhing I posted is absolutely true to my experience Joinfortmill 13 hrs ago #15
I wasn't referring to your information. marybourg 13 hrs ago #21
SHIP? Sanity Claws 13 hrs ago #17
This: marybourg 13 hrs ago #22
Thanks Sanity Claws 13 hrs ago #26
Be aware, Supplemental Plans will only cover you once without a full medical history. lark 13 hrs ago #19
It's complicated, for sure. Joinfortmill 13 hrs ago #23
My plan was not being offered in 2026 so I was able to switch EverHopeful 13 hrs ago #25
Last year a friend who had Medicare Advantage was informed that her insurer was no longer doing business in her area. Lonestarblue 12 hrs ago #28
Summation: the Advantage Plan that sounds so good today can bite you in the ass tomorrow Auggie 12 hrs ago #29
Good advice. Joinfortmill 12 hrs ago #30
If you can afford it, always get real Medicare. If you MUST get Advantage due to financial reasons, make sure you Fil1957 11 hrs ago #36
Your health history might prevent you getting a Medigap plan** NGeorgian 11 hrs ago #37
Medicare Supplemental plans can be very expensive. Sogo 11 hrs ago #38

Walleye

(43,012 posts)
1. I switched from an advantage to regular Medicare about 10 years ago
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:15 AM
14 hrs ago

I think it’s better. Of course the Republicans are doing everything they can to ruin Medicare. I probably should get a Medigap. Let us know how that turns out.

gab13by13

(30,275 posts)
7. Thom Hartmann predicted a year ago
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:28 AM
14 hrs ago

that the way that Magats will kill Medicare is by morphing it into Medicare Advantage plans.

Medicare Advantage plans gut Medicare.

I asked people at the hospital that I went to for a procedure and they all said they love dealing with Medicare, no pre-approvals, everything is cut and dried.

I went to 2 different hospitals, 2 different networks, switched 3 of my specialist doctors with zero problems on Medicare.

I'm scheduling my second knee replacement before the shit hits the fan being as I am 78.

Silent Type

(11,667 posts)
10. But still, 53% of beneficaries choose Medicare Advantage because they believe it is more affordable for them.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:42 AM
14 hrs ago

I still have original Medicare, but know that the day will come where I have to consider MA. I'm not for restricting that option, but I am for original Medicare adding some benefits, even if limited to a thousand dollars or so-- dental, OTC cards, etc. And, there are MA plans that will cover more of the cost of costly meds. Those plans cost more, but exist.

Grins

(9,024 posts)
32. "... they believe it is more affordable."
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:38 AM
12 hrs ago

It is far more affordable!

Until, like this poster, it’s not.

The horror of it is that private companies were allowed to use the name “Medicare” in their marketing promotions when their products are not actual Medicare. (Thank you Joe Namath!). It’s a scam. It’s the old HMO crap resurrected.

There was a bill to deny them using “Medicare” in their product naming and promotions, but I don’t know what happened to it.

Silent Type

(11,667 posts)
34. Like I said, you get a choice. If Medicare is better for you, take it. If MA is better, take it. But don't try to take
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:44 AM
12 hrs ago

something away from people just because you prefer traditional Medicare. Heck, try to get traditional Medicare improved.

iluvtennis

(21,395 posts)
33. I would be doing tradtional Medicare + a plan to cover my meds, but I chose Medicare Advantage for dental and vision
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:40 AM
12 hrs ago

coverage. I do reevaluate every open enrollment period.

Freddie

(9,978 posts)
27. My daughter is an RN case manager for home care
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:03 AM
12 hrs ago

She said the exact same thing. Traditional Medicare does not second-guess medical professionals. Advantage plans do. She constantly has to fight with Advantage plans to get the needed days covered, medical devices, etc.
We took her advice and went with a traditional plan with a supplement. My husband had a knee replacement and everything was covered, including physical therapy, except maybe $150 to the surgeon.

Silent Type

(11,667 posts)
39. Not exactly true. Traditional Medicare has very detailed coverage rules that prevent some questionable claims.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 12:33 PM
11 hrs ago

Further, Medicare audits providers exhibiting a billing pattern that is questionable, often 3, 4, 5 years after services rendered, prompting providers to be careful.

Every few days, one reads of Medicare audits where a provider billed millions of dollar over 4 years, when no patient was even seen. Medicare doesn't catch it and we get ripped off.

MA on the other hand often has only 12 to 18 months to recoup questionable services. So they deny upfront. Most denials are overturned quickly once the doc send in records. If you don't think providers -- including Marcus Welby -- don't cheat, you are mistaken.

And, home health gets audited too.

KFF:

Key Takeaways:
"Medicare Advantage insurers made nearly 50 million prior authorization determinations in 2023, reflecting steady year-over-year increases since 2021 (37 million) and 2022 (46 million) as the number of people enrolled in Medicare Advantage has grown. The determinations represent requests for approval that providers are required to submit before providing a service. Substantially fewer prior authorization reviews for traditional Medicare beneficiaries were submitted to CMS – just under 400,000 in fiscal year 2023 – though the number of people enrolled in Medicare Advantage and traditional Medicare were similar in these years.

"In 2023, there were nearly 2 prior authorization determinations on average per Medicare Advantage enrollee, similar to the amount in 2019. In contrast, in 2023, about 1 prior authorization review was submitted per 100 traditional Medicare beneficiaries – a rate of about 0.01 per person — which reflects the limited set of services subject to prior authorization in traditional Medicare.

"In 2023, insurers fully or partially denied 3.2 million prior authorization requests, which is a somewhat smaller share (6.4%) of all requests than in 2022 (7.4%). Though there were substantially fewer prior authorization reviews for traditional Medicare beneficiaries, a larger share was denied – 28.8% in 2023. Denial rates varied across the limited set of services subject to prior authorization in traditional Medicare.

"A small share of denied prior authorization requests was appealed in Medicare Advantage (11.7% in 2023). That represents an increase since 2019, when 7.5% of denied prior authorization requests in Medicare Advantage were appealed. A relatively small share of denied prior authorization reviews was appealed in traditional Medicare (6.4% in 2022) as well.

"Though a small share of prior authorization denials were appealed to Medicare Advantage insurers, most appeals (81.7%) were partially or fully overturned in 2023. That compares to less than one-third (29%) of appeals overturned in traditional Medicare in 2022. These requests represent medical care that was ordered by a health care provider and ultimately deemed necessary but was potentially delayed because of the additional step of appealing the initial prior authorization decision. Such delays may have negative effects on a person’s health."

https://www.kff.org/medicare/nearly-50-million-prior-authorization-requests-were-sent-to-medicare-advantage-insurers-in-2023/




we can do it

(12,960 posts)
2. Good for you. Luckily, I learned about Medicare Supplement and ignored the "advantage" propaganda.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:16 AM
14 hrs ago

IbogaProject

(5,282 posts)
5. Yes
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:23 AM
14 hrs ago

It is only feasible if your plan was funded as part of retirement coverage. Otherwise you have to catch up on the medigap insurance back to age 65. These plans can be a trap. The allure of lower initial costs can trap someone.

Abnredleg

(1,227 posts)
6. The issue is getting a Medigap supplement
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:27 AM
14 hrs ago

If you get a supplement when you first go on Medicare then there is no medical underwriting; that is, they don’t check for prior conditions. After that initial enrollment window, however, the insurer can do medical underwriting and deny coverage if they so desire. Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and New York so not allow underwriting at any time, but that means their supplements are more expensive.

There are also some qualifying events that bypass underwriting such as your plan being withdrawn from your area.

Joinfortmill

(19,315 posts)
13. Yes, some, unless there is a s qualifying event.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:57 AM
13 hrs ago

In my case, the Advantage plan was leaving my State and would not be available in 2026. I took advantage (lol) of that and switched

Sanity Claws

(22,277 posts)
4. Original Medicare?
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:22 AM
14 hrs ago

Did you enroll for part b or some other part? Or are you just on plan Medicare, which I understand covers only hospitals, not regular doctor visits and meds?

I ask because I have to decide what to do by early next year when I plan to retire from FT work and won't have insurance from my employer anymore.
In case you didn't see it, John Oliver covered the problems with Advantage plans. Here is a link,

Abnredleg

(1,227 posts)
8. Advantage Plans include Parts A and B
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:30 AM
14 hrs ago

And usually have a drug plan (Part D). You pay Part B premiums when on an Advantage plan.

gab13by13

(30,275 posts)
9. Plain Medicare certainly covers doctors visits.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:35 AM
14 hrs ago

Plain Medicare doesn't cover dental. It does cover vision checkups but not glasses.

Joinfortmill

(19,315 posts)
14. Medicare covers part A & B.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:01 AM
13 hrs ago

I got Medicare - which covers 80% of most doctors bills, and hospital care; a separate drug plan with no monthly premiums and low drug costs; and a separate medigap plan which covers the 20% Medicare doesn't cover.

Hope this clears up any confusion.

deRien

(313 posts)
24. Medicare Part A (hospital, etc.)
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:28 AM
13 hrs ago

is what you pay for during your working years. When you hit 65 Part B (doctors, labs, tests, etc.) kicks in and you will have to pay whatever the Medicare portion is. Usually, this is taken out of your Social Security check unless you opt to pay monthly or quarterly. I think 2026 the cost is around $206 per month. You can suspend Part B coverage if you are still working and getting medical coverage from your job. You HAVE to let Medicare know that you want to do this as Part B starts automatically when you turn 65. If you have original Medicare, you will need a supplement ~ those are Plan A-Z and offer different coverage. Different companies offer these plans and the costs can vary but the coverage is the same. They don't cover hearing, eyes, dental or prescription. You will have to get separate coverage for those. Prescription coverage is Part D.
The Medicare Advantage (Medigap) is Part C. Those are the ones that have ads on TV 24/7. Hope this helps.
If you are still working, check with your HR person. They can or should be able to help you.

Bob_in_VA

(118 posts)
31. Original Medicare is both Part A and Part B
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:29 AM
12 hrs ago

At least as far as I know. But you can go online to medicare.gov and find out from the 'horse's mouth'.

marybourg

(13,572 posts)
12. OP--there's a lot of misinformation in this thread.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 09:56 AM
13 hrs ago

Please get your info from your state SHIP or other authoritative source.

Joinfortmill

(19,315 posts)
15. Everyrhing I posted is absolutely true to my experience
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:07 AM
13 hrs ago

I am not a Medicare expert, just an old gal. There is a lot I don't know, so please let me know what you think is incorrect and I will respond.

marybourg

(13,572 posts)
21. I wasn't referring to your information.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:14 AM
13 hrs ago

But to the information you were given, from those trying to be helpful, but incomplete and sometimes misleading.

marybourg

(13,572 posts)
22. This:
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:17 AM
13 hrs ago

State Health Insurance Assistance Program, a national program that offers free, one-on-one assistance

lark

(25,610 posts)
19. Be aware, Supplemental Plans will only cover you once without a full medical history.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:12 AM
13 hrs ago

So, if you have it once and cancel because of the expense, you can't go back if you have had any significant disease, including cancer and you also have to get a rx plan. The first few years I was on Medicare, I was very healthy and didn't like paying for the supplement and the prescription plan and not using either. I switched to an Advantage Plan and prompty had 2 head traumas within 6 weeks - not good. I nearly died from an impinged spinal cord - very scary. Anyway, I can;t go back because of my cancer history so will have to manage. Hubs got a supplement because his heart dr. is with Mayo and they don't take Advantage plans. Hope we can afford to continue this. I wish I had never switched, but Humana has been fast with auths. and no problem so far.

Joinfortmill

(19,315 posts)
23. It's complicated, for sure.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:18 AM
13 hrs ago

I was able to switch because of the qualifying event - my plan left the State. I purchased the medigap plan from Fidelity. Representative never asked me about my health or prescriptions. He told me, that because I had a qualifying event, he wasn't allowed to

EverHopeful

(608 posts)
25. My plan was not being offered in 2026 so I was able to switch
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 10:31 AM
13 hrs ago

so I contacted the company recommended about 3/4 of the way through this video and they were amazing. Was on the phone with a guy who explained all the options and arranged a callback a few days later to make sure everything worked out.

The company is called Chapter.

https://www.democraticunderground.com/132280784

Lonestarblue

(13,045 posts)
28. Last year a friend who had Medicare Advantage was informed that her insurer was no longer doing business in her area.
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:15 AM
12 hrs ago

She lives in a small community and options to switch to different providers still covered by her insurer were nonexistent. MA can cancel your insurance at will. Original Medicare cannot.

Auggie

(32,645 posts)
29. Summation: the Advantage Plan that sounds so good today can bite you in the ass tomorrow
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:22 AM
12 hrs ago

Original Medicare, MediGap (Plan G recommended), and the Plan D.

Talk to a Medicare broker to get the best MediGap and D plans for you. Vet the brokers, BTW. Ask for referrals. Ask your friends.

Fil1957

(294 posts)
36. If you can afford it, always get real Medicare. If you MUST get Advantage due to financial reasons, make sure you
Wed Oct 29, 2025, 11:54 AM
11 hrs ago

do lots of research and get the best plan you can.

My 95 year old mother has Kaiser Medicare Advantage, and since she's always lived and will always live in their area of coverage as well as being on Medicaid, it's been terrific for her.

Kaiser is one of the few good ones, and she's one of the few Advantage success stories I've heard of.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Social Security & Medicare»Switching from Advantage ...