General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: In defense of Elizabeth Warren....personal experience [View all]nolabear
(43,819 posts)My father told us stories of her using Indian medicine on him twice to save his life. It seems to have been a combination of some very smart folk medicine (plunging him in cold water to break a fever and swinging him around by the ankles to dislodge fluid in his lungs when he had pneumonia) and a laying on of hands and chanting, talking the fire out of a burn. This is a well known technique used many years ago in Native American lore. My father, who was as meanly judgmental as anyone Ive ever known, spoke of her worshipfully and since much of my childhood was spent watching my mother slowly die I took to her as a source of hope that I had inherited something strong and admirable.
So, I took a DNA test. It shows no NA ancestry. At the same time the line is through my fathers mother so the haplogroups are tricky. And the grandmother in questions father cant be traced on ancestry sites. Weve got everyone else way, way back. And of course that dreamy, longing for connection kid in me still wants it to be true.
I never put NA on a form, and if it was sheer opportunism I can see it as a mistake. But it isnt a simple thing either. Facts and hearts sometimes battle over things. I really like EW and I hate that there seems no way to forgive a mistake when real good can be accomplished thereby. How she continues to handle it will mean a lot.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):