Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pinkstarburst

(1,810 posts)
32. What a lovely NIMBY response
Mon Jan 1, 2024, 02:29 PM
Jan 2024

We need to get a solid democratic message on immigration. Right now our message is frustration over bussing out of one side of our mouth (NIMBYism) and saying we are for allowing migrants to come in out of the other. If we want to help these people (which is our current democratic position), that means that all major cities must be able and willing to accept and shelter migrants. There are 10,000 migrants crossing into Texas per day. The vast majority come with only the clothes on their backs and have no family in the US who can take them in. They are completely dependent on US social services at least at first.

If our values say we want to continue allowing the border to be open at the level it is (10,000 homeless migrants per day) then that's fine. But then we have to be prepared to shelter and feed these people until they get on their feet. Not have a NIMBY response of "send them back to Texas" or getting angry about busses and want to lock up busses and fine bus drivers. If we let these people in, every major city must do their part to shelter them because there are 10,000 more coming across every day.

The conversation must shift away from anger at border states/bussing to how can we get resources/funding, guest worker permits? The conversation must shift away from how can I keep those busses from ever showing up at my city, to if we cannot support that many people, to having a conversation at the federal level about how many people we are allowing in per day. Not lashing out at southern border states, who bear the brunt of this anyway.

This must be a national conversation. Not NIMBYism.

And why aren't other major cities VOLUNTEERING to take homeless migrants in? Where is the leadership?

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

IIRC, the migrants have been lied to as to where they were going, and that they'd get work sakabatou Dec 2023 #1
And what do the conspiracy theorists and Fox News hosts want with the border? What is their end game? Initech Dec 2023 #3
Chaos, dissension Mad_Machine76 Jan 2024 #42
I'm not sure Texas gets notice for every person jimfields33 Dec 2023 #2
Is this even a serious reply? we can do it Dec 2023 #6
Texas has 10,000 migrants arriving per day pinkstarburst Dec 2023 #11
The main problem with our border in Texas Texasgal Dec 2023 #16
This isnt NIMBY xmas74 Dec 2023 #23
But they ignored our advice Polybius Dec 2023 #24
Im worried about purposely sending people to xmas74 Jan 2024 #27
But if they still come though then what? Mad_Machine76 Jan 2024 #43
My preference is not to send them to NY Polybius Jan 2024 #53
Why would you do that? TxGuitar Jan 2024 #56
I think you misunderstood Polybius Jan 2024 #60
Sorry TxGuitar Jan 2024 #64
Every city in the US has a list of excuses for why they don't want the migrants pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #28
It's not an excuse if theyre being put into a situation xmas74 Jan 2024 #30
What's your plan? pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #31
My plan? xmas74 Jan 2024 #34
I agree with your plan 100% pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #35
I don't blame the border states for the influx xmas74 Jan 2024 #54
People can hate Abbott all they want, but he got everyone's attention that it isn't just a border state problem. n/t MichMan Jan 2024 #55
Can't believe we have people here defending Abbott's actions here Mad_Machine76 Jan 2024 #58
Ditto! LearnedHand Jan 2024 #59
Two wrongs don't make a right. eShirl Jan 2024 #65
Isn't that the point?? Srkdqltr Dec 2023 #4
Exactly Stuckinthebush Dec 2023 #15
Yup, and it's the exact same reason why the Republican shitheads in Congress GoCubsGo Jan 2024 #29
Empty CPS buildings could be used as shelter. Many have kitchens. LuvLoogie Dec 2023 #5
Despite warning of cold temperatures, migrants choose to come to Chicago MichMan Dec 2023 #7
Or are the news outlets reporting what TX told them? LearnedHand Jan 2024 #61
The reporter had direct quotes from someone at a migrant shelter MichMan Jan 2024 #63
No, but MSM does report the press releases as handed to them LearnedHand Jan 2024 #69
Illinois has water boundaries with the Mississippi and Ohio Rivers. roamer65 Dec 2023 #8
Chicago migrants Maninacan Dec 2023 #9
Message auto-removed Name removed Dec 2023 #19
I see them on street corners here Hangingon Jan 2024 #49
Imagine the chaos in California, Arizona and Texas?? WarGamer Dec 2023 #10
NIMBYism on the part of some. EllieBC Dec 2023 #14
precisely... nt WarGamer Dec 2023 #17
If it's legit Red Mountain Dec 2023 #21
Has Chicago offered to accept all these folks? TexasDem69 Dec 2023 #26
To be fair, no one is handling this well pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #33
Chicago cannot handle 26,000 migrants? pinkstarburst Dec 2023 #12
They might be able to handle it Polybius Dec 2023 #25
Chicago and Illinois welcome the migrants Arazi Jan 2024 #66
can they be sent back to texas? AllaN01Bear Dec 2023 #13
Every one WANTED to go to Chicago. WarGamer Dec 2023 #18
Why should they be? Seeking Serenity Dec 2023 #22
What a lovely NIMBY response pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #32
Other major cities do volunteer: "Sanctuary Cities" ... marble falls Jan 2024 #37
since abbbot didnt want to do anything about them and sending them to chicago, isnt that a nimby response . AllaN01Bear Jan 2024 #39
I live in Texas and I wouldn't compell anyone not MAGA RW Kneejerk to come here. marble falls Jan 2024 #38
Why? TxGuitar Jan 2024 #40
That is a conversation worth having Mad_Machine76 Jan 2024 #44
What other states have plans? TxGuitar Jan 2024 #45
It doesn't matter if the Migrants chose to go there Mad_Machine76 Jan 2024 #46
None of that is happening TxGuitar Jan 2024 #47
Let's look at the numbers pinkstarburst Jan 2024 #50
Why? TxGuitar Jan 2024 #57
Kinda off topic but Trashman272 Dec 2023 #20
Yes. Public health organizations avoid being "law enforcement" like the plague ... marble falls Jan 2024 #36
That would be a DHS question. NT TxGuitar Jan 2024 #41
This whole thing is typical NIMBY ripcord Jan 2024 #48
Chaos? They used to call that "patriotism" Turbineguy Jan 2024 #51
Just a good Baptist being a great Christian? czarjak Jan 2024 #52
Abbott could certainly communicate more effectively and efficiently with other state and municipal leaders. Torchlight Jan 2024 #62
feature not glich prodigitalson Jan 2024 #67
Listening to Chicago and NYC whine about the few immigrants they are getting is disgusting ripcord Jan 2024 #68
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Chicago mayor says Abbott...»Reply #32