General Discussion

Alva Goldbook

(149 posts)

82. Dan, let's get real here.

Fri Apr 26, 2013, 05:24 PM

Apr 2013

Are you really telling me that since machine guns, which are not protected by the 2nd amendment under the Miller decision, can be registered, that it also applies to a 9mm pistol, which is protected by the 2nd amendment?

Are you suggesting that all private sales of guns are used in gun trafficking?

Yes, the gov't can't regulate church attendance. Thus, why the words, "Congress shall make no law" is used in the 1st amendment. It's also why the words, "shall not be infringed" are used in the 2nd.

what does the 4th amendment have to do with a gun registry?

Guns are property, are they not? Does a gun registry allow the gov't to know what you own? Let's review the 4th amendment again:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

92 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

The problem gun reformers face [View all] ProSense Apr 2013 OP

The bottom line is that pipoman Apr 2013 #1

No, that's not the "bottom line" ProSense Apr 2013 #2

Another false NRA talking point. They just keep flowing... DanTex Apr 2013 #3

"talking point" "talking point" pipoman Apr 2013 #4

Maybe look into why nobody with a clue about constitutional law has even hinted that DanTex Apr 2013 #5

Dan, are you not aware of the interstate commerce clause of the Constitution? Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #9

Are you not aware of the NFA, which requires intra-state sales between private citizens to be DanTex Apr 2013 #17

Would you quit scaring billh58 Apr 2013 #23

Dan, intra-state sales between private citizens already gets a background check. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #41

Intra-state means within the same state. DanTex Apr 2013 #44

What provision of the NFA governs sales within the same state? Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #49

If you sell an NFA gun to someone within the same state, you need to transfer the registration. DanTex Apr 2013 #56

Dan, I'll ask again. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #60

So are you saying I'm wrong? That's a serious question. DanTex Apr 2013 #64

Dan, all I'm asking you to do is prove your claim. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #73

I'm not sure what you are trying to argue here. DanTex Apr 2013 #74

Ain't it tough splainin to folks who can't get their "nomenclature" correct. Hoyt Apr 2013 #53

Hoyt, I dont' actually know the difference between a magazine and a clip. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #55

Guns are far from "progressive." Hoyt Apr 2013 #68

You don't think that the right of self-defense is a progressive value? Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #71

The right of self-defense and the right to own a gun are different things. DanTex Apr 2013 #72

I don't recall seeing a Constitutional Amendment that guarantees you to be free from gun violence. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #75

The constitution also doesn't say anything about self-defense either. DanTex Apr 2013 #76

Are you a 100 pound woman? Typical gun cultist BS. Hoyt Apr 2013 #80

Instead of insulting me, why don't you address the point I raised? Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #81

I could put a bunch of photos of shot kids, give us a break and stop promoting more guns. Hoyt Apr 2013 #87

And the weapons restricted under NFA pipoman Apr 2013 #54

Whether guns are in common use or not has nothing to do with commerce clause or states' rights. DanTex Apr 2013 #58

It has everything to do with NFA registry... pipoman Apr 2013 #61

The "NFA Registry" is not part of the constitution. DanTex Apr 2013 #65

Dan, so basically what you're saying is that because the Fed regulates machines guns one way... Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #78

Constitutionally, yes. DanTex Apr 2013 #79

Dan, let's get real here. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #82

You are confusing the commerce clause and the second amendment. DanTex Apr 2013 #83

No, I didn't! Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #84

OK, I think this is where I hop off the crazy train. DanTex Apr 2013 #85

No, all I'm asking is that you prove your claim. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #90

The ONLY reason that the NFA pipoman Apr 2013 #88

About the constitutional scholar thing. DanTex Apr 2013 #47

So then why didn't it happen praytell? pipoman Apr 2013 #57

Umm, because there weren't enough votes in the senate. DanTex Apr 2013 #59

How do we explain the several Democrats who didn't vote for it? pipoman Apr 2013 #62

They are right-wing Dems like Max Baucus. DanTex Apr 2013 #67

Now, let's be specific: NRAtalkingPoint™ No. 20358 Eleanors38 Apr 2013 #6

In other words, nobody with a clue has any doubts about the constitutionality. DanTex Apr 2013 #7

So the ACLU has gone over to the Dark Side? Eleanors38 Apr 2013 #8

The ACLU didn't say it was unconstitutional. DanTex Apr 2013 #13

Dan, a national gun registry is prohibited by law. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #10

Wow, you guys don't even know about NFA! Fascinating! DanTex Apr 2013 #12

Yes, I am aware of it... Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #43

That wouldn't affect the commerce clause or the Federal Government's jurisdiction. DanTex Apr 2013 #45

No, it would. Alva Goldbook Apr 2013 #51

Miller was a second amendment case. The "unusualness" matters to the second amendment, DanTex Apr 2013 #52

Where is this registry? former9thward Apr 2013 #11

LOL. So not only do you not know what a "Harvard Study" is, you also don't know about the NFA. DanTex Apr 2013 #14

I thought the NFA was a registry for certain firearms, like machine guns, premium Apr 2013 #15

I didn't say "all firearms". But the NFA is most definitely a national gun registry. DanTex Apr 2013 #16

Thanks for the reply. premium Apr 2013 #18

Of course, not of all firearms. DanTex Apr 2013 #21

I tend to agree with you, premium Apr 2013 #22

You never know what Scalia and Co are going to do, but DanTex Apr 2013 #25

Except there is no way to register existing guns using the NFA model hack89 Apr 2013 #39

NFA 1934 umt9 Apr 2013 #35

Thanks. premium Apr 2013 #42

Has it never ever prevented 1 criminal? Poor logic. Since one is able to get an illegal weapon.... uppityperson Apr 2013 #46

Re-read my post umt9 May 2013 #92

LOL. former9thward Apr 2013 #19

The percentages don't affect the constitutionality question. DanTex Apr 2013 #20

I am still waiting for you to disprove one fact presented in that study. former9thward Apr 2013 #30

Amazing, you're still standing by it! Even after it was shown to you that it is right-wing DanTex Apr 2013 #31

Wow a typo! former9thward Apr 2013 #32

LOL. Using false data is not a "typo". DanTex Apr 2013 #33

That dog don't hunt any more. upaloopa Apr 2013 #26

It only takes one person to challenge and you can bet on that person being out there somewhere.. pipoman Apr 2013 #63

It also takes money and a court willing to hear it upaloopa Apr 2013 #77

The money will be there through lobbying groups like NRA pipoman Apr 2013 #89

No it isn't Progressive dog Apr 2013 #66

thye unsolvable problem actually is : we already have 200 million guns librechik Apr 2013 #24

Your last few words billh58 Apr 2013 #28

Yep. Zoeisright Apr 2013 #69

From the article... rrneck Apr 2013 #27

So the GOP is counting on the ignorance of the American people. DanTex Apr 2013 #29

Nothing but falsehoods. former9thward Apr 2013 #34

Uh huh. "There's no loophole". Where have we heard that talking point before? DanTex Apr 2013 #36

Why did you post falsehoods? former9thward Apr 2013 #37

I think everyone outside the NRA bubble understands that you are the one posting falsehoods. DanTex Apr 2013 #38

a "friendly top"? former9thward Apr 2013 #40

"Loophole" pipoman Apr 2013 #91

Yes. rrneck Apr 2013 #48

Maybe their problem is the outright contempt that they have for millions of Democrats and AnotherMcIntosh Apr 2013 #50

Speaking of NRA propaganda billh58 Apr 2013 #70

The problem they face: Goobers rustydog Apr 2013 #86