Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Beastly Boy

(13,149 posts)
19. I didn't challenge the numbers, did I?
Sat Jul 19, 2025, 11:45 PM
Jul 19

There is a reason for it. While I find none of the available sources for casualty numbers in Gaza particularly trustworthy, my trust or mistrust doesn't matter anyway. It is the responses to the OP I am commenting on. The header of my post should have been sufficient to establish this.

Of course I doubt the accuracy of the numbers that presume all casualties in a war zone to be civilians and to be caused by only one belligerent side of the armed conflict between several warring armies. This proposition is ridiculous on its face, but it is an entirely different ridiculous proposition that I am talking about here.

In anticipation of your deflection I also stipulated that my post loses none of its cogency "even if accounts of the ubiquitous "local health officials and witnesses" are to be taken for granted as god's honest truth". So you may presume whatever you wish about the accuracy of the cited sources, and whatever your presumption may be, it will have no effect on the point I am making.

And, getting back to my point, it has to do with the absolute absurdity of conspiracy theories about IDF setting up a bait, or a trap, or a "kill zone", or otherwise creating conditions to commit ethnic cleansing by distributing millions of meals to Gazan civilians.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

How annalog Jul 19 #1
Some hunters do that. Kid Berwyn Jul 19 #2
Yes it is a deliberate ambush. Starve people, lure them with food, shoot them in cold blood. Irish_Dem Monday #26
It's a blood lust now nowforever Jul 19 #3
It really is Scott Alan Swaggerty Monday #25
May all involved receive everything they deserve. niyad Jul 19 #4
More ethnic cleansing. War criminal Netanyahu/the IDF are showing incredible discretion in being satisfied with... brush Jul 19 #5
Bait. Linda ladeewolf Jul 19 #6
Indeed Scott Alan Swaggerty Monday #24
And sadly, so should we. thought crime Monday #32
It was designed to do exactly what it is doing. AloeVera Jul 19 #7
The absurdity of responses here is mind boggling. Beastly Boy Jul 19 #8
In case you didn't realize... AloeVera Jul 19 #11
No, I didn't realize. And I have no idea whose description of ethnic cleansing you are using or how competent Beastly Boy Jul 19 #15
Ethnic cleansing is not necessarily done with killing, but the removal of Linda ladeewolf Monday #33
Cute 'splaining of what Israel wants. Beastly Boy Monday #34
What source then do you trust to tell you how many Palestinians have been killed by the IDF since 10/7? Stargleamer Jul 19 #16
I didn't challenge the numbers, did I? Beastly Boy Jul 19 #19
I agree. . . Stargleamer Monday #31
"Even if" does indeed imply doubt. However, it also implies that this doubt doesn't play a role Beastly Boy Tuesday #36
But the ratio of meals to kills is useless in making the point you are trying to make Stargleamer Tuesday #38
The ratio of kills to meals is absurd, but it is far from useless. Beastly Boy Tuesday #39
Exactly cabotnn22 Jul 19 #17
Congressional Republicans love Netanyahu. red dog 1 Jul 19 #9
The slavish adoration for this blood-soaked murderer of children AloeVera Jul 19 #12
As do many Congressional Democrats Polybius Jul 19 #13
The evil that men do lives after them; The good is oft interred with their bones. walkingman Jul 19 #10
These are happening every day it seems. Isn't this a war crime? FirstLight Jul 19 #14
Yes, of course, it's a war crime iemanja Jul 19 #18
Yes. Release the hostages. Disarm Hamas. The war ends 24 hours later. Beastly Boy Jul 20 #20
Four aid sites in Gaza with limited hours, only one in the north, compared to almost 400 sites before ... cliffside Jul 20 #21
Look at the map in the NYT article, 3 out of the 4 aid sites are in the south .... cliffside Jul 20 #22
The Trumps want the beachfront property, they are just relocating people to the afterlife. Irish_Dem Monday #27
Seems that way .... cliffside Monday #35
Trump said he was going to relocate them to a beautiful place. Irish_Dem Tuesday #37
Do you recall Trump using the same words about Netanyahu? AloeVera Wednesday #40
Yes he admires people who are sick bastards. Irish_Dem Thursday #42
Unacceptable Scott Alan Swaggerty Monday #23
This is so fuckin' ridiculous... enough is enough!! InAbLuEsTaTe Monday #28
The Gazan's instigated the military Bluestocking Monday #29
Do you think after the 20th or 30th such massacre, the IDF might finally get a clue? AloeVera Thursday #41
It's a daily occurrence now because it's part of the plan Johnny2X2X Monday #30
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»32 Palestinians shot dead...»Reply #19