Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LetMyPeopleVote

(168,612 posts)
32. MaddowBlog-With black paint on border barriers, Trump and Noem are repeating a familiar mistake
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 12:51 PM
Wednesday

Last edited Wed Aug 20, 2025, 02:25 PM - Edit history (1)

The last time the president ordered officials to apply black paint to border barriers, it was an expensive failure. Naturally, he’s trying it again.

As you see reports about Trump/Noem painting border barriers black, don’t forget the recent history:

When Trump made this same demand five years ago, it was an expensive and wasteful failure. True to form, he’s repeating the same mistake, expecting a different result. www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...

Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2025-08-20T15:58:42.730Z

https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/black-paint-border-barriers-trump-noem-are-repeating-familiar-mistake-rcna226052

The enormous amount of new spending will also includes money for, of all things, the president’s preferred paint color. The Associated Press reported:

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Tuesday that the entire border wall along the southern border with Mexico is going to be painted black to make it hotter and deter illegal immigration — and she credited President Trump with the idea. Noem spoke during a visit to a portion of the wall in New Mexico, where she also picked up a roller brush to help out with the painting.


The Cabinet secretary added that the paint project is being done “specifically at the request of the president, who understands that in the hot temperatures down here, when something is painted black, it gets even warmer, and it will make it even harder for people to climb.”

There was, however, one relevant detail that Noem neglected to mention: The Trump administration already tried this same idea, and it didn’t work.......

Trump first started pushing the idea in 2019, at which point administration officials tried to explain to him that the painting project would waste too much time and money in pursuit of a goal that wouldn’t make much of a difference anyway. Border officials were confident at the time that Trump understood their concerns and would focus his energies elsewhere.

They were mistaken. In 2020, when the president should’ve been working on the pandemic, he ordered his team to start applying black paint to the barriers along the U.S.-Mexico border, insisting that it would make the barriers hot to the touch and discourage climbers.

To the surprise of no one, Trump was wrong and those who tried to discourage him were right. Not only did the black paint fail to discourage breaches, it also started peeling off about a year and a half after it was applied. The whole endeavor was an expensive waste.

And so, naturally, the Trump administration is giving it another try, expecting a different result, spending a lot of American tax dollars on an initiative that only makes sense in the president's imagination.

Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

So CBP will no longer need daytime jobs taxi Wednesday #1
They shouldn't paint the whole thing black nuxvomica Wednesday #2
... Oeditpus Rex Wednesday #4
Beep! Beep! Ray Bruns Wednesday #11
At this rate, nuking hurricanes will become a real thing. Grokenstein Wednesday #3
The painting contractor must have made a huge bribe. Irish_Dem Wednesday #5
Yeah...my first thought too. Trump going to line his pockets over this too.... Bengus81 Wednesday #20
Trump does nothing unless it benefits him personally. Irish_Dem Wednesday #23
Now the MAGAs will have to come up with some plausible explanation for this stupidity Prairie Gates Wednesday #6
Well, really, it's all about rust prevention, you know, in a desert, where it rarely rains. Mawspam2 Wednesday #7
You really expect stories like this to be from the Onion. Nope, just Trump world. mackdaddy Wednesday #8
Exactly what I thought orangecrush Wednesday #31
Specifically at the request of President Trump Blue Dotty Wednesday #9
I thought Trump's favorite color was tacky gold? RealityChik Wednesday #35
sure, cool story, bro... Javaman Wednesday #10
as a southwest dweller I find it interesting the mythology travelingthrulife Wednesday #22
yup, texas here. locals down at the boarder call it the photo op wall LOL nt Javaman Wednesday #30
Black is a much better background color Oeditpus Rex Thursday #36
Black and Orange! Old Testament Libera Saturday #45
I think I heard a song about this Ray Bruns Wednesday #12
I see a dumb wall and he wants to paint it black C_U_L8R Wednesday #28
Black radiates heat better,too. Mopar151 Wednesday #13
I heard the cartels are rolling out sophisticated countermeasures already..... Red Mountain Wednesday #14
Oven mitts lildDemz Wednesday #15
Reminds me of the times after his foolish partial wall was built, Mexican kids were timing themselves travelingthrulife Wednesday #19
Also walking to the gaps in the fence. Pisces Wednesday #26
Wait till Noem finds out that the Rio Grande is a RIVER! 70sEraVet Wednesday #16
Trump wanted alligators and snakes in the water... sop Sunday #55
Another excellent waste of taxpayer money. sinkingfeeling Wednesday #17
No worry! Mexico will pay for it. dedl67 Sunday #54
Well, that is breathtakingly stupid travelingthrulife Wednesday #18
Just paint it clear and they won't see it and face plant right into it and easier to round up! Brainfodder Wednesday #21
Another Road Runner - Coyote kinda scheme (n.t.) Oeditpus Rex Thursday #38
Paint It Black iamnoone Wednesday #24
LOL, too ridiculous. That wall will be hot no matter what color it is. Fla Dem Wednesday #25
Is this satire? Amaryllis Wednesday #27
Why even bother Hey Joe Wednesday #29
MaddowBlog-With black paint on border barriers, Trump and Noem are repeating a familiar mistake LetMyPeopleVote Wednesday #32
Donald Trump "understands" lots of things that are completely wrong. tanyev Sunday #52
Ever hear of gloves Krusty? Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Wednesday #33
Guess what trump? SandyDoc Wednesday #34
This is so mind-numbingly stupid sakabatou Thursday #37
This is another dumb trump idea LetMyPeopleVote Thursday #39
Blindingly stupid lackey pleasing a demented idiot. mn9driver Thursday #40
Well, they made it tall so people wouldn't climb it. And that worked out well... Aristus Thursday #41
LOL-Noem can only paint one side of this fence and Mexico is having fun painting the other side LetMyPeopleVote Friday #42
Paint one side of the fence intelpug Saturday #48
Now he'll sue Mexico for hurting his beautiful fence. travelingthrulife Sunday #50
SOUNDS SO......CHRISTIAN Skittles Friday #43
Won't help in the winter Old Testament Libera Saturday #44
I bet they'll use undocumented workers to paint it fujiyamasan Saturday #46
No sense of style kiranon Saturday #47
yeah because no one ever climbs at night Skittles Sunday #49
Is it true they're painting the US side not the Mexican side? -nt CrispyQ Sunday #51
Kristi is such a stereotypical moron. mdbl Sunday #53
Are they going to roll paint on by hand like she was doing? nt Hotler Sunday #56
Oven mitts Walleye Sunday #57
When Racist People Get High And Brainstorm DrFunkenstein Sunday #58
Who still wants to come here? truthisfreedom Sunday #59
There is some amazing artwork on the Mexican side of the wall LetMyPeopleVote Sunday #60
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»DHS Secretary Noem says e...»Reply #32