Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LiberalLovinLug

(14,521 posts)
19. I'm not sure what you are arguing
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 05:50 PM
21 hrs ago

I agree, the people do not directly elect a "national leader". But their peers choose the one that then the public will choose or not choose. So in the end they are, if not directly, electing a national leader. If the party doesn't put forth a candidate that people will vote for, thats their fault

But the leader who ran and lost, can either resign, or decide to carry on as opposition leader. Or a third option that the party holds a leadership review and maybe forces a new party election.

But when the dust settles......there is one and only one top voice that defines that party in opposition. Here in Canada, Pierre Poilievre, who caters to the maple maga, lost the election, but still speaks as the most authoritative voice for the official opposition. Even immediately after the election.

In the US, it is even simpler, because you only have two serious parties running. So it just seems odd that the person, Kamala Harris, who had almost half the votes and support, had great momentum to build from, with overflowing arenas, did not stay in the spotlight, and be regarded as the voice of Democrats. Until any new primary was called for by the party.

To just cut off all momentum like that just seemed counter productive

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I approve of this message. ananda Yesterday #1
Hell yeah! Me too! Mysterian Yesterday #10
Tax the rich, feed the poor 'Til there are no rich no more I'd love to change the world But I don't know what to do twodogsbarking Yesterday #2
Joshua Christie from Bethlehem said like, it's easier for the poor Justice matters. Yesterday #4
ding. THIS AllaN01Bear Yesterday #5
Re. Trump: and his opposition must follow leaders who are ready to "fight fire with fire," flashman13 Yesterday #3
I am afraid fascist miller will take that as a threat from "radical-leftist"... Justice matters. Yesterday #6
They want us to self censor. We all must speak truth to power. flashman13 23 hrs ago #16
Good ofc, but I think instead of using "fight fire with fire" Justice matters. 20 hrs ago #22
DING .THIS. THE ONCE AND TRUE PREZIDENT SPEAKS volumes !!!!!!!! AllaN01Bear Yesterday #7
Would love to see a poll of how many Trump voters think they voted for the wrong person in November. ificandream Yesterday #8
fighting fire with fire at least gets us back in the game samsingh Yesterday #9
We have been clawing back governorships BumRushDaShow Yesterday #11
thanks for the reminder. That's good. samsingh 22 hrs ago #17
Unhinged , psycopath Maxheader Yesterday #12
We will. We are. mahina 19 hrs ago #24
Yes! Fight fire with fire! BaronChocula Yesterday #13
TY Kick for Kamala! Cha Yesterday #14
I think one drawback about the American system is that there is no formal leader of the opposition LiberalLovinLug 23 hrs ago #15
"In most other democracies, Kamala Harris would have remained the leader of the opposition after the election" BumRushDaShow 22 hrs ago #18
I'm not sure what you are arguing LiberalLovinLug 21 hrs ago #19
In the Parliamentary system, they still don't "directly elect" a "leader" like we do BumRushDaShow 21 hrs ago #21
yes. that is all true LiberalLovinLug 18 hrs ago #27
"Although after Trump lost in 2020, he was still considered the leader of their party." BumRushDaShow 18 hrs ago #28
THIS is The Way! TY, Kamala... electric_blue68 21 hrs ago #20
Now THAT is what I come here for! And you folks of course. mahina 20 hrs ago #23
Is the sound funny for you folks too? mahina 19 hrs ago #25
The Forbes video was apparently recorded with the sound coming from the speakers in the room BumRushDaShow 19 hrs ago #26
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Harris calls Trump 'incom...»Reply #19