Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Donald Trump Proposes Eliminating Income Tax [View all]BumRushDaShow
(164,098 posts)29. "BTW, how many times has a Democratic President followed to fix the Republican failures in economy."
FDR after Hoover
Clinton after George HW Bush
Obama after George W Bush
Biden after Trump
etc.
Clinton after George HW Bush
Obama after George W Bush
Biden after Trump
etc.
You can add JFK after Dwight Eisenhower too. I know my mom used to occasionally mention that little recession that happened in the '50s (1957 - 1958).

(from here - The Forgotten 1957 Pandemic and Recession)
And get a load of this shit - NYT from 67 years ago -
PRESIDENT SAYS DEMOCRATS SELL 'DOUBT AND FEAR'
___________
In Chicago Address, He Calls Them the Champions of Inflation and Spending
___________
AGAIN SCORES 'RADICALS'
___________
Eisenhower Details Record of Expanding Economy in Urging G.O.P. Victory Eisenhower Charges Democrats With Selling 'Doubt and Fear'
By Felix Belair Jr. special To the New York Times.
Oct. 23, 1958
CHICAGO, Oct. 22-President Eisenhower made another ungloved attack on the Democratic party and its candidates tonight. In an address to Republican precinct workers at the International Amphitheatre here, the President sought to identify the Democratic party as the champion of inflation, "frantically merchandising doubt and fear.". The speech was televised nationally and broadcast to the Midwest area by the Columbia Broadcasting System. To a dinner audience of 4,500 party workers, swollen by standees, the President gave his Administration credit for having prevented an economic recession from becoming a major depression. This was done, he said, while staving off "an avalanche of Federal spending" sponsored by Democrats in Congress.
Democrats Called 'Radicals'
The President charged that the "dominant wing" of the Democratic party was composed of radicals" and "those of little faith." He said: "The most deceptive notion taught by self-styled liberals is that when the economy starts] to slow up, only a vast outpouring of your tax dollars will pump us out of the trouble."
President Eisenhower read the record of his Administration in: its management of the domestic economy, keeping the nation's defenses strong and keeping it at peace. He then said this was the reason voters would return Republican candidates to state and Congressional offices in next month's elections. The President was interrupted repeatedly by applause during his address. The most prolonged show of approval came when he remarked that spending public funds to finance the nation out of a business recession was like "trying to live on new debts." Another prolonged applause came when, in describing Republican goals in domestic policy, he said that the party's intention was "to help our working men and women drive racketeers and hoodlums out of American labor."
Earlier in the day the President told a meeting of Republican women voters and workers in the Blackstone Hotel here that the country's best chance of remaining at peace and avoiding a major war was to "stay firm and strong and always ready to conciliate." But his chief emphasis in his address tonight was on the need to keep the economy strong. It appeared from the President's talk that his main purpose was to combat a major charge of Democratic candidates that his Administration had brought on the "Eisenhower recession," which began in the summer of 1957.
(snip)
___________
In Chicago Address, He Calls Them the Champions of Inflation and Spending
___________
AGAIN SCORES 'RADICALS'
___________
Eisenhower Details Record of Expanding Economy in Urging G.O.P. Victory Eisenhower Charges Democrats With Selling 'Doubt and Fear'
By Felix Belair Jr. special To the New York Times.
Oct. 23, 1958
CHICAGO, Oct. 22-President Eisenhower made another ungloved attack on the Democratic party and its candidates tonight. In an address to Republican precinct workers at the International Amphitheatre here, the President sought to identify the Democratic party as the champion of inflation, "frantically merchandising doubt and fear.". The speech was televised nationally and broadcast to the Midwest area by the Columbia Broadcasting System. To a dinner audience of 4,500 party workers, swollen by standees, the President gave his Administration credit for having prevented an economic recession from becoming a major depression. This was done, he said, while staving off "an avalanche of Federal spending" sponsored by Democrats in Congress.
Democrats Called 'Radicals'
The President charged that the "dominant wing" of the Democratic party was composed of radicals" and "those of little faith." He said: "The most deceptive notion taught by self-styled liberals is that when the economy starts] to slow up, only a vast outpouring of your tax dollars will pump us out of the trouble."
President Eisenhower read the record of his Administration in: its management of the domestic economy, keeping the nation's defenses strong and keeping it at peace. He then said this was the reason voters would return Republican candidates to state and Congressional offices in next month's elections. The President was interrupted repeatedly by applause during his address. The most prolonged show of approval came when he remarked that spending public funds to finance the nation out of a business recession was like "trying to live on new debts." Another prolonged applause came when, in describing Republican goals in domestic policy, he said that the party's intention was "to help our working men and women drive racketeers and hoodlums out of American labor."
Earlier in the day the President told a meeting of Republican women voters and workers in the Blackstone Hotel here that the country's best chance of remaining at peace and avoiding a major war was to "stay firm and strong and always ready to conciliate." But his chief emphasis in his address tonight was on the need to keep the economy strong. It appeared from the President's talk that his main purpose was to combat a major charge of Democratic candidates that his Administration had brought on the "Eisenhower recession," which began in the summer of 1957.
(snip)
See... that ain't the "Eisenhower" that gets presented today. It's more distilled into his "MIC" remarks and not the rest of what is still a loon GOP type of thinking.
Why does this Oct. 23, 1958 front page of the NYT look like something you'd see today in 2025?

ETA - if you look at that St. Louis Fed BEA graph, there was a recession during the latter part of the Nixon 2nd term/Ford term, before 1976, where Watergate apparently ruled the day but it all still lead to Carter.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
37 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
The only benefit is we might get to play Running Man with the ultra wealthy for when it crashes.
cstanleytech
Friday
#25
So in other words,a new tax to eliminate payroll taxes eh?? In the end your still taxed.
Bengus81
Friday
#3
That was Trump's plan all along: return to the Gilded Age by replacing the federal income tax with tariff revenue.
sop
Friday
#5
Even one of the original promoters of that - David Stockman - admitted that it was wrong
BumRushDaShow
Friday
#9
stockman wrote one of the finest descriptions of reaganomics - "the triumph of politics"
rampartd
Friday
#10
Do you have to tap your heels three times and wear ruby slippers as well?
travelingthrulife
Friday
#19
"cutting income tax, which he said could be achieved thanks to the effects of his trade policies."
mdbl
Friday
#15
"To replace ALL federal taxes would require tariff revenue to increase by 16 to 17 times..."
J_William_Ryan
Friday
#17
Perfect storm. Fire everybody and then eliminate public funding for services
travelingthrulife
Friday
#18
"BTW, how many times has a Democratic President followed to fix the Republican failures in economy."
BumRushDaShow
Friday
#29