The DU Lounge

debm55

(50,217 posts)

87. Thank you very much, TommieMommie. Is Hellman's the same as Duke's?

Reply to TommieMommy (Reply #86)

Mon Aug 4, 2025, 04:41 PM

Aug 4

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

91 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Pick one, Miracle Whip or Mayo. I use MW because of the sweet tang it has. How about you? [View all] debm55 Aug 3 OP

I loathe MW & my mom was a MW mom. CrispyQ Aug 3 #1

Thank you CrispyQ. I have been a MW person all my life. Enjoy your mayo. It taste bland to me. debm55 Aug 3 #13

Same here customerserviceguy Aug 3 #41

Not a MW fan. Don't quite hate it. The tang reminds me of ?relish. Nota big fan... electric_blue68 Aug 3 #50

Agreed. That fruit salas with MW...oh my god...just thinking about that almost made me throw up. brush Aug 3 #62

Mayo is God's gift to mankind. Miracle Whip is the Devil's spawn!! BuckIowa Aug 3 #2

Oh my. Thems fightin words.------ debm55 Aug 3 #15

I don't feel That badly about MW, but don't really like it. electric_blue68 Aug 3 #51

Mayo anciano Aug 3 #3

Thank you anciano. I like the zip in MW, We all have our tastes. Enjoy the Mayo. debm55 Aug 3 #16

Mayo specifically Hellmann's if available. Ritabert Aug 3 #4

Thank you Ritabert.for sharing with us. I like the sweet tang of MW, and you like Mayo. debm55 Aug 3 #17

I only use olive oil mayo. multigraincracker Aug 3 #5

Thank you very much, multigraincracker. Enjoy your mayo. debm55 Aug 3 #18

either Buzz cook Aug 3 #6

I agree, Buzz cook. When I go out to eat, I take whatever, but at home it's MW. Thank you. debm55 Aug 3 #20

howdi AllaN01Bear Aug 3 #7

Thank you Bear. I guess it depends on where I am eating. At home--MW, Eating out --mayo. Thank you for your links. debm55 Aug 3 #22

Mayo because of that MuseRider Aug 3 #8

But MuseRider, the sweet tang, makes it. debm55 Aug 3 #25

One family of Aunt, Uncle, and cousins used MW EverHopeful Aug 3 #9

EverHopeful. Most people in my steel town used MW, At that time, Mayo was for the upper middle class. Thank you for your debm55 Aug 3 #26

Both, either, it depends on what you are using it for. And whatever taste you need. Srkdqltr Aug 3 #10

Mayo. cloudbase Aug 3 #11

Well cloudbase, if you come to my house, it will have to be something else, mustard? debm55 Aug 3 #28

Best dressed Squeaky41 Aug 3 #30

Aldi MW because of lower fat SheltieLover Aug 3 #12

Thank you SheltieLover. I will have to visit our Aldis debm55 Aug 3 #32

I shop almost exclusively at Aldi. Save hundreds / month SheltieLover Aug 3 #42

Also, Soya Has More Unsaturated Fats ProfessorGAC Aug 3 #63

Ty for sharing, Prof SheltieLover Aug 3 #79

Duke's Mayo! FloridaDAR Aug 3 #14

DUKEs Mayo BOSSHOG Aug 3 #29

Thank you very much BOSSHOG. I have used mayo on various foods. ---when eating out , etc. It's okay, But I want the debm55 Aug 3 #75

And you FloridaDAR are usin fightin words, debm55 Aug 3 #33

As a Hellman's user, and not sure I could find Duke's in NYC (haven't looked).... electric_blue68 Aug 3 #54

As Duke's ads say "It's Got Twang!" TomSlick Aug 3 #81

Looking it up I see that... electric_blue68 Aug 3 #83

Miracle Whip. Hands down Wifes husband Aug 3 #19

Thank you, very much Wifes husband. debm55 Aug 3 #34

Mayo irisblue Aug 3 #21

Thank you irisblue. I am going to try the avocado with the tuna. That sounds great. I agree with the egg salad. It would debm55 Aug 3 #35

I used this recipe aa the base then customized it irisblue Aug 3 #37

Thank you very much, irisblue. That sounds great. I am going to true it. debm55 Aug 3 #73

there is only one 'correct' choice here stopdiggin Aug 3 #23

You are so correct my friend. Hail to the Miracle. Thank you stopdiggen. debm55 Aug 3 #36

Used to use MW, but we're now Hellman's fans surfered Aug 3 #24

Thank you very much surfered for sharing with us. Enjoy. debm55 Aug 3 #72

Neither. Ranch dressing, especially peppercorn bacon ranch. niyad Aug 3 #27

Thank you very much, niyad. I like Ranch Dressing on chicken sandwiches. I will have to try that peppercorn bacon ranch. debm55 Aug 3 #71

MW lite and never mayo. riversedge Aug 3 #31

Thank you very much, riversedge, for your selection. debm55 Aug 3 #58

Neither. I prefer brown mustard, if I use any spread at all. Dorothy V Aug 3 #38

Thank you very much, Dorothy V. debm55 Aug 3 #49

Mayo Mayo Mayo and particularly Hellman's... WVGal1963 Aug 3 #39

Thank you very much, WVGal1963, Thank you very much for sharing the recipe . I think I could live with that mayo that debm55 Aug 3 #48

Mayo Jilly_in_VA Aug 3 #40

Thank you Jilly_in _VA, for your selection. But you will miss that sweet tang. debm55 Aug 3 #47

My husband and I use Miracle Whip peggysue2 Aug 3 #43

Thank you peggysue2. I think the selection has a lot to do with what you were raised on. debm55 Aug 3 #46

I remember someone on this forum who once said (I think) chouchou Aug 3 #44

HAHAHHAHAHH . Thank you chouchou. That's funny. debm55 Aug 3 #45

Mayo. Hellman's, not sure I've ever had a different brand. electric_blue68 Aug 3 #52

Thank you , electric_blue68. But I will still take my slightly sweet tang. debm55 Aug 3 #56

Enjoy 👍 electric_blue68 Aug 3 #57

Not just mayo. Hellman's or Duke's. no_hypocrisy Aug 3 #53

HAHAHAHHAHAH. no-hypocrisy. Will do. debm55 Aug 3 #55

Both. MW for sammies and potato salad LNM Aug 3 #59

Thank you very much, LNM. That makes a lot of sense. Enjoy. debm55 Aug 3 #69

I like both. johnp3907 Aug 3 #60

Thank you very much, johnp3907 for reaching the perfect balance in your foods. Wonderful. debm55 Aug 3 #67

We Only Have Mayo ProfessorGAC Aug 3 #61

Thank you very much, ProfessorGAC, That spicy mayo sounds like a try. debm55 Aug 3 #65

Either one LogDog75 Aug 3 #64

Thank you very much, LogDog75 for your selections. debm55 Aug 3 #66

Mayonnaise LoisB Aug 3 #68

Thank you very much, LoisB for sharing with us. and enjoy. debm55 Aug 3 #70

Loved Duke's real mayo. Ain't going to have it in Costa Rica. sinkingfeeling Aug 3 #74

So sorry, sinkingfeeling, They don't sell it there?? Maybe have a relative ship a bottle once a month. debm55 Aug 3 #76

Hellmann's Mayo walkingman Aug 3 #77

Thank you very much for your selection. walkingman. debm55 Aug 3 #78

I loathe Miracle Whip for exactly that reason. Ocelot II Aug 3 #80

Oh, Ocelot II, it's not that bad. debm55 Aug 3 #82

Only Duke's Mayo jmowreader Aug 4 #84

Thank you very much, jmowreader for sharing your Duke's mayo with us. debm55 Aug 4 #85

Hellman's Mayo TommieMommy Aug 4 #86

Thank you very much, TommieMommie. Is Hellman's the same as Duke's? debm55 Aug 4 #87

No but they are close in taste. I think it's Blue Plate that's the same TommieMommy Aug 4 #89

Thank you , TommieMommy. debm55 Aug 4 #90

Hellman's all the way. catbyte Aug 4 #88

Oh my, MW is vile?. I still get mayo when we go out. It's just MW in our house. Those are figntin words. debm55 Aug 4 #91