Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yellowdogintexas

(23,199 posts)
15. I had a great dr and I understood the medical terms and my dr respected
Wed Dec 15, 2021, 11:10 AM
Dec 2021

that. He does the ablations to avoid hysterectomies whenever he can.

I submit that many hysterectomies can be treated by other means but those other treatments are not done because:

Drs do the pat the head treatment and tell the patient it is necessary. This scares the patient significantly
Drs are not adaptable to the alternative treatment available
Drs are dismissive of their minority or low information patients
Patient does not have any medical knowledge, or history of regular gyn care and do not know to ask for those treatments.
Patient fears other outcomes in the future.
Patient is happy to get rid of periods, cramps, or pregnancy risk.

Sometimes a hysterectomy results from a surgery intended for a relatively minor procedure but when the dr gets in there what he/she thinks is a couple of minor fibroids turns out to be more serious. I know a woman who went in for a uterine removal for endometriosis which turned out to have invaded her entire abdominal cavity resulting in a 9 hour surgery with specialists called in.

Yes there are unnecessary hysterectomies, but nothing like that article suggests.

Sorry this went on so long I am a medical nerd with 40 years experience in medical claims and related subjects. I can't help myself.

However there are still doctors who recommend hysterectomy because they are lazy, or are older and do not do the other procedures.

particularly black/brown women.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

There are many other reasons than cancer where a hysterectomy might be necessary. Scrivener7 Dec 2021 #1
+1. my immediate thought. stopdiggin Dec 2021 #3
Endometriosis was the cause of mine when I was 39. I sinkingfeeling Dec 2021 #5
There are also molar pregnancies, which can sometimes Scrivener7 Dec 2021 #7
I have no idea, but we do know it's way too large janterry Dec 2021 #12
That seems like it would be much closer to reality than the Scrivener7 Dec 2021 #14
certainly the author(s) of the article don't know squat about other yellowdogintexas Dec 2021 #16
I did. barbtries Dec 2021 #9
Immeasurably Improved - Great Description Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #22
ICE doctor was doing many unnecessary hysterectomies to enrich himself with extra billing. nt Bernardo de La Paz Dec 2021 #2
With my wife, it was cancer, plain and simple DFW Dec 2021 #4
I thought this practice had stopped wnylib Dec 2021 #6
it is, yes you should have them. Best practices now indicate a yellowdogintexas Dec 2021 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author wnylib Dec 2021 #18
This does not appear to be a medically accurate article Pmc1962 Dec 2021 #8
isn't this found in: The hidden harms of oophorectomy? janterry Dec 2021 #11
Thank you Pmc1962!! Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #25
I had to beg for mine LittleGirl Dec 2021 #10
I had a history of endometrial cyst on an ovary with surgery. I was 32+ yellowdogintexas Dec 2021 #13
I had a great dr and I understood the medical terms and my dr respected yellowdogintexas Dec 2021 #15
At least one fifth appear to be unnecessary janterry Dec 2021 #29
I am surprised this article was written by a woman Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #19
There are very serious short and long term side effects janterry Dec 2021 #20
I am talking from information provided Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #21
there is an increased risk of cancer janterry Dec 2021 #23
What does the Mayo Clinic say Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #24
Bravo !! Duppers Dec 2021 #26
??? janterry Dec 2021 #28
Mayo and Cleveland Clinic Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #30
you're all set! janterry Dec 2021 #33
Here is what they say janterry Dec 2021 #27
Briefly scanned the 1st article Mary in S. Carolina Dec 2021 #31
ah, well janterry Dec 2021 #32
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Feminists»The "madness" of unnecess...»Reply #15