Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Envirogal

(244 posts)
11. Very catholic with guilt a driving force
Tue Sep 23, 2025, 10:01 AM
Tuesday

I was also “single issue voter” pro-life. Started dating a very worldly and smart guy, which was thrilling given I was living in a Midwest bubble town where sameness was the natural state of things. (I think I was 12 before I realized there were people that weren’t Catholic out there.)

He was an agnostic atheist, and I had never heard of such blasphemy. I pondered whether he was a devil worshiper because I had no reference point. I drilled him on various issues and his answers always were way more sensible than even my questions! As our relationship blossomed, I started to question things more. The ice started a slow thaw.

And then I got pregnant early on in our relationship. Then I became the biggest hypocrite and got an abortion. The fact that I was able to do that shook me to my core— I never wanted kids but that was overshadowed by my steadfast belief….until I needed one. I felt incredibly sick on how much I judged others and that was when the floodgates came on questioning everything, researching, and atoning for my hypocrisy. I thought if could do that maybe my faith might be masking other truths?

The final straw came when I was on a long trip to Europe and saw all the wealth of churches (built on slave labor), even in small villages. Went to the Vatican and saw the outdated misogyny of the Swiss Guards not saluting the nuns when they did the priests. And on and on.

I never looked back. The religious Reich in this country has only made my conviction stronger. I truly believe that deep religious thought that lanes political is for naïve people and easily broken once you can pop the bubble.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Raised Jewish by agnostic parents. no_hypocrisy Monday #1
Robert Oppenheimer, as you may know, was in the ethical culture movement as a child. NNadir Monday #2
Religious upbringing trueblueinmo Monday #3
Raised catholic got wise Faux pas Monday #4
Agnostic here.... anciano Monday #5
I decided years ago SCantiGOP Tuesday #22
I appreciate you taking the time to respond... anciano Tuesday #23
Fundamental markie Monday #6
attended baptist church as a kid, didnt pay much attention to the religion part tho nt msongs Monday #7
Not religious at all - just moral Nigrum Cattus Monday #8
I was raised Universalist oberle Monday #9
I have 13 years of perfect attendance pins from my small, rural Methodist church. sinkingfeeling Monday #10
Very catholic with guilt a driving force Envirogal Tuesday #11
I did... GiqueCee Tuesday #12
My sig line in this post, from Max Born's Nobel Prize speech.. NNadir Tuesday #13
Ah, yes! GiqueCee Tuesday #14
It turns out that it's not from his Nobel Prize speech but is found in his autobiography. NNadir Tuesday #21
Priests and nuns were mean, especially to kids that needed some help. First grade I had my doubts. twodogsbarking Tuesday #15
My wife experienced that and concurs. NNadir Tuesday #20
Raised in a very liberal Southern Baptist church wysimdnwyg Tuesday #16
I never believed any of it mike_c Tuesday #17
I grew up in the Vancouver area of Canada. pandr32 Tuesday #18
Raised Catholic; was even an altar boy for a short time. SeattleVet Tuesday #19
12 years of Catholic schools and parents that purported to be very religious rurallib Wednesday #24
Southern Baptist GigiLeigh Wednesday #25
My oldest son nearly went insane from reading that book. NNadir Wednesday #27
Raised Catholic. Family still is. Went to Catholic school 12 years. Srkdqltr Wednesday #26
I was raised as an American Baptist (supposedly more liberal than Southern Baptist), we could dance and play cards.. wcmagumba Wednesday #28
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»Question: How many of m...»Reply #11