Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

cliffside

(1,068 posts)
27. Thanks for sharing the full article! Below is an interview from 7/17 ...
Sun Jul 20, 2025, 09:29 PM
Sunday

partial transcript, full transcript at link.


"2:29
Well, there's perhaps no greater crime
2:31
than genocide. Our next guest, Domer
2:34
Bart, is professor of Holocaust and
2:37
genocide studies at Brown University. He
2:40
is an Israeli American scholar who's
2:43
been described as the US Holocaust
2:45
Memorial Museum as one of the world's
2:48
leading specialists on the subject of
2:50
genocide. And he's just written an op-ed
2:53
for the New York Times headlined, I'm a
2:56
genocide scholar. I know it when I see
2:59

it. Professor Bartoff joins us from
3:03
Cambridge, Massachusetts. Well, why
3:05
don't you, Professor Bartoff, and thanks
3:07
for joining us again. Lay out your case.
3:14
Well, thanks for having me again. Um,
3:17
the case that I made in the article and
3:20
that I've been making for a while is
3:23
that at the beginning immediately after
3:26
October 7th, the Hamas attack on October
3:29
7th, uh, Israeli political and military
3:33
leaders made a series of pronouncements
3:37
which could be interpreted as calling
3:39
for genocide. Um, but there was still no
3:43
at that point there was no evidence that
3:45
this was being implemented. Over time,
3:50
uh, and I would say by May of 2024, it
3:53
became apparent that these statements
3:56
were not only made in the heat of the
3:58
moment following the massacre by Hamas,
4:01
but were actually being implemented in a
4:04
manner that would make it impossible for
4:07
people to live in Gaza, make the entire
4:10
Gaza Strip uninhabitable, and make life
4:13
there impossible, as well as destroy all
4:17
the institutions there would be uh there
4:20
for that group to reconstitute itself as
4:23
a social, cultural, political group once
4:26
the violence was over. Of course, it's
4:28
not over yet. Um I started thinking that
4:32
in May in August that year, I wrote an
4:36
article that explained that. The
4:38
violence has only continued and the
4:41
attempt as you just reported to destroy
4:43
Gaza entirely has continued since and it
4:47
is now clear that Israel is trying to
4:50
concentrate the population of Gaza in
4:53
the southernmost parts of the strip to
4:56
enclose them and to enforce eventually
4:59
either that they would just die out
5:01
there or that they would be removed from
5:03
the Gaza Strip altogether........."




Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

K & R Celerity Thursday #1
"The Holy Land" Skittles Thursday #2
The author is not wrong irisblue Thursday #3
I am not a genocide scholar but I know genocide malaise Thursday #4
K & R democrank Thursday #5
I haven't seen any... druidity33 Thursday #6
And you will see even fewer of them. I found it utterly useless to counter opinions with facts. Beastly Boy Thursday #11
Nah. When neither facts nor morality are on your side, I'd be quiet too. AloeVera Sunday #24
Facts are on my side allright. I keep citing them again and again. Beastly Boy Sunday #29
With facts such as the ADL got canceled its a wonder anyone can even think of debating you. Eko Sunday #31
Ten minutes later, and your post didn't age well, did it? Beastly Boy Sunday #32
Mine aged very well. Eko Sunday #34
I see you are a big fan of rapid aging. Beastly Boy Sunday #35
I can tell you that I am not a fan of using right wing slogans. Eko Monday #36
It's not genocide. nt LexVegas Thursday #13
Some of those same people are saying ethnic cleansing isn't taking place, either Rob H. Thursday #18
It's an academic argument... druidity33 Thursday #19
K&R spanone Thursday #7
The author admits that he is offering an opinion that is contrary to most other sources Beastly Boy Thursday #8
Why let that get in the way of the "concern"? nt LexVegas Thursday #9
Haaretz has some facts too BeyondGeography Thursday #12
And these facts are consistent with urban warfare involving human shields, not genocide. Beastly Boy Thursday #14
Haaretz has reported extensively on the IDF's use of Palestinians as human shields BeyondGeography Thursday #16
And your point is... what? Beastly Boy Thursday #17
You didn't read the article too closely, or something. AloeVera Sunday #22
Ah, thanks for bringing these passages to my attention. Beastly Boy Monday #37
Gee, who should I listen to? A genocide expert or an "emotional healing" blogger? AloeVera Sunday #23
Gaza 2035: A Beacon of Peace and Prosperity in the Flourishing Middle East by Seth Eisenberg - cliffside Sunday #25
Unbelievable. AloeVera Sunday #28
Spinmeister sounds right to me! "Donald Tump Square" :( nt cliffside Sunday #30
Between the two, the 'emotional healing" blogger appears to be more trustworthy and objective. Beastly Boy Monday #38
Domicide should be listed as a war crime too when it's this widespread uponit7771 Thursday #10
Especially when it's domicide in aid of ethnic cleansing. AloeVera Sunday #21
Omer Bartov is an incredible man and scholar I have been reading and listening to for years. His book, Nanjeanne Thursday #15
Kicked and recommended Uncle Joe Thursday #20
Bookmarked underpants Sunday #26
Thanks for sharing the full article! Below is an interview from 7/17 ... cliffside Sunday #27
Netanyahu - Trump - Putin - it's all connnected. Initech Sunday #33
Genocides have a long history. The roots always seem to be based in nationalism religion, and fear. Ping Tung Monday #39
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I'm a Genocide Scholar. I...»Reply #27