General Discussion

Thunder Chicken

(2 posts)

32. New poster here

Mon Aug 11, 2025, 08:18 AM

Aug 11

Sorry new poster here. Typically just come here for the articles posted, but wouldn’t both the second and third image both be considered gerrymandered? If there are a total of five districts with 60% blue voters and 40% red voters, then shouldn’t the equitable split be three blue districts and two red districts? I don’t support any form of gerrymandering, so 5-0 split favoring blue voters in this scenario is just as illegal as 3-2 split favoring red voters correct?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

39 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Here is how gerrymandering works in two images. [View all] Swede Aug 10 OP

Ridiculous that it's even legal. bif Aug 10 #1

Gerrymandering is NOT legal in real democracies, like Canada and the UK. n/t SidneyR Aug 10 #16

Yes, it is totally avoided by putting it in the hands of independent committees. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 10 #17

If there is a complicated way to run something, Americans will find it and deploy it. Bernardo de La Paz Aug 10 #19

Our systems of measurement are further examples. nt Wednesdays Aug 10 #23

Yes. We all had the excuse of the king in olden times, but the world has moved on, except the US and Liberia. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 11 #29

Some would call it complicated ToxMarz Aug 11 #33

Complication opens opportunities for corruption. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Aug 11 #36

Illinois has some very oddly shaped districts. 3catwoman3 Aug 10 #2

Almost every state does. lastlib Aug 10 #9

Looks like the geographic center of his district isn't even in his district unblock Aug 10 #3

Just FYI for people who want to repost that, they must have changed it, cuz it doesn't look like that now. CrispyQ Aug 10 #4

Wikipedia currently has the same map. KS Toronado Aug 10 #5

This message was self-deleted by its author sl8 Aug 10 #7

Here is a good article about the process used on Ohio Bluetus Aug 10 #28

This message was self-deleted by its author sl8 Aug 10 #6

Looks like Republican Mike Carey in District 15 has the most gerrymandered district. nt SunSeeker Aug 10 #12

This was the Ohio Congressional District map, that was used for the 2024 election. ... aggiesal Aug 10 #8

I've been under the impression that the gop gerrymanders more egregiously than dems. Is this not true? If it wiggs Aug 10 #10

GOP certainly has been more blatant about it in recent times WestMichRad Aug 10 #14

I don't like it when either side weaponizes gerrymandering, slightlv Aug 10 #26

Great point. Texas mid-cycle gerrymandering is just one part of an overall undemocratic effort by the goprs. I wiggs Aug 11 #34

I'm old; I hate to say it, slightlv Aug 11 #35

Yes. Because they are FAR more dependent on it for their political survival and have been for a while. Karasu Aug 10 #22

True, but... Random Boomer Aug 10 #24

What happened to Republicans wanting term limits? Emile Aug 10 #11

Origin Story Marcuse Aug 10 #13

Kicked and recommended Uncle Joe Aug 10 #15

Looks like cheating to me. Dave Bowman Aug 10 #18

We had in NC the I-85 district. mwooldri Aug 10 #20

Gerrymandering + electoral college Hornedfrog2000 Aug 10 #21

You know, normally I don't care who is doing the "gerrymandering" slightlv Aug 10 #25

maybe... myohmy2 Aug 10 #27

I am sure they are eagerly awaiting your check so that they can move. OldBaldy1701E Aug 11 #31

The hope is they over play this round of redisticting Johonny Aug 11 #30

New poster here Thunder Chicken Aug 11 #32

No. That's how Abbott is justifying his gerrymander. Do you agree with Abbott??? marble falls Aug 11 #37

Welcome to DU. Swede Aug 11 #38

Welcome to DU LetMyPeopleVote Aug 11 #39