Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

EdmondDantes_

(1,149 posts)
25. Alternatively one can look at the situation as having tried something that didn't work
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 11:54 AM
Monday

That happens. If a doctor tries to treat an illness with one treatment and it doesn't work are they obligated to keep trying? If I start to read a book and find I don't like it, am I obligated to finish it because otherwise I'd be saying starting it was wrong? You don't keep doing a thing that isn't working.

Obviously some Democrats (including both of my Senators) wanted to keep the shutdown going. I don't know how I would vote in their shoes because I'm not in their shoes. I haven't paid any price that I know of this shutdown. I don't have travel scheduled, I don't have SNAP or work for the government. I don't rely on ACA subsidies either. I can see arguments in both directions, but what I can't see is how continuing the shutdown gets what we want. With this deal a bunch of fired government workers get their jobs back and all government workers get to get paid. SNAP gets funded and we get a vote on the ACA subsidies. None of that was true on Saturday. That's a bird in hand at least.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The circle cannot be squared -- if this vote to end the shutdown is right then RockRaven Monday #1
I disagree. pat_k Monday #4
Alternatively one can look at the situation as having tried something that didn't work EdmondDantes_ Monday #25
100% !! WELL SAID ! (and it really NEEDED to be said !) stopdiggin Monday #2
Very well said, bigtree. Sogo Monday #3
K&R nt PunkinPi Monday #5
Then why even have the shutdown? Envirogal Monday #6
Not fighting helps us win nothing orangecrush Monday #7
The problem is that Democrats don't demonstrate Baitball Blogger Monday #8
My feelings, exactly Pototan Monday #9
Completely disagree angrychair Monday #10
What did we get for our 40 days? Billsdaughter Monday #11
How long will Trump spike the football in our face? dem4decades Monday #26
It was a REPUBLICAN SHUTDOWN. The only Emile Monday #12
. Scrivener7 Monday #13
Thanks to centrists they couldn't pass a public option, now Emile Monday #14
You've got it all wrong Orrex Monday #16
Patience, grasshopper. All is going exactly as it should go. This isn't a Law & Order episode. And what are YOU Scrivener7 Monday #17
+1 demmiblue Monday #18
+1 leftstreet Monday #23
Well, that's certainly one way to spin it. Orrex Monday #15
K&R mcar Monday #19
Say It Loud! MineralMan Monday #20
K&R betsuni Monday #21
This message was self-deleted by its author BannonsLiver Monday #22
But Schumer himself welcomes GOPers leftstreet Monday #24
Tell that to the crazy 8. nt yaesu Monday #27
Who needs a majority when you rule like a monarchy C_U_L8R Monday #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»People steady advocating ...»Reply #25