Jewish Group

lostincalifornia

(4,230 posts)

8. I am not surprised that some are now playing the "label" card, because

Reply to lostincalifornia (Original post)

Fri Aug 1, 2025, 09:22 AM

Aug 1

He is a rabbi and a Jew, is justification for calling all Jews as “complicit” for what is happening in Gaza if they don’t do anything about it.

It doesn’t matter who he is, calling all Jews as complicit is bullshit

it doesn't matter how he identifies either, because he is providing an excuse for anti-Jewish bigotry.

No surprise that some would have no problem with this.

so what if if he is a rabbi, Meir Kahane was a rabbi and a racist piece of garbage, Norman finkelstein is a vile holocaust piece of garbage minimizer.

It is no different than those who were enthralled with Reverend Wright collectively blaming of all white people for the ills of the world.

Oh, he is a rabbi, oh he is a Jew, so it is OK to collectively blame ALL Jews for complicity if they don’t do something.

He is a jackass promoting anti-Jewish bigotry, and because he happens to be a rabbi, he is getting the attention he wants as a political activist.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

JustAnotherGen lapucelle Mosby LeftInTX Cha

20 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Calling out Jews as complicit if they do nothing about Gaza is a dog whistle [View all] lostincalifornia Jul 31 OP

I read the comments to the article. Beastly Boy Jul 31 #1

Jews should be able to live their lives as they choose. Do we expect every individual to do... what, exactly? question everything Jul 31 #2

I find it similar to those who call out Palestinians moniss Jul 31 #3

I agree. lostincalifornia Jul 31 #4

This is much worse. The discussion begins: "If Israelis and Jews Don't Act Now..." lapucelle Aug 1 #9

The people saying that JustAnotherGen Aug 1 #11

Someone pointed out this week that the ONE group with the power to UNILATERALLY end this war lapucelle Aug 1 #13

They do not want it to end. They must be destroyed instead... then it will end. Oopsie Daisy Aug 4 #20

Some NEVER miss an opportunity to blame Jews...all Jews. Behind the Aegis Aug 1 #5

and it doesn't matter how they identify themselves either, because they are providing an excuse for anti-Jewish lostincalifornia Aug 1 #6

ITA JustAnotherGen Aug 1 #7

I am not surprised that some are now playing the "label" card, because lostincalifornia Aug 1 #8

There are definite JustAnotherGen Aug 1 #10

Neither will I. lostincalifornia Aug 1 #18

Thank you for posting this LetMyPeopleVote Aug 1 #12

It is hurtful and unfair. lostincalifornia Aug 1 #19

I asked a question in post 10 i was hoping Mosby Aug 1 #14

I did not bother to read the post. Why legitimize it? question everything Aug 1 #15

Just posting on DU legitimized the place. Mosby Aug 1 #16

I think the problem Mosby is that there are some who have such antagonism toward Israel and Jews lostincalifornia Aug 1 #17